4 ms·
This is sad in many ways. It's sad that people think being vulgar is funny. It's sad that people get carried away with what's funny and feel they need to be c
by mc32 11y ago
This is sad in many ways.
It's sad that people think being vulgar is funny.
It's sad that people get carried away with what's funny and feel they need to be cool.
It's sad that people are rearing to jump on anyone who is but a symbol of something the masses disprove of, again, mainly not out of being a good citizen, but out of trying to be cool. The defender of the faith.
It's sad that people's alcohol fueled idiocy -not crime,but idiocy, becomes public and has repercussions in real life.
It's sad these vigilantes one day will also make fools of themselves, this is inevitable, one can hope the pitchforks will not come out for them, but they probably will.
It's sad people and companies don't have the wherewithal to separate private from public lives. If I were to become an employer one day, what you say on your time is your province, not mine. When you're representing the company, that's different.
- kohanz 11y ago> It's sad that people's alcohol fueled idiocy -not crime,but idiocy, becomes public and has repercussions in real life. Maybe not a "crime" by the definition of the law, but a lot of things that aren't crimes, such as sexual harassment, are grounds for losing your job. If you display such behavior in public, you should be willing to face the consequences, especially if you work as a government (publicly-funded) employee. > It's sad these vigilantes one day will also make fools of themselves, this is inevitable, one can hope the pitchforks will not come out for them, but they probably will. I've heard this argument before. Despite what some people think, not everyone harbors racist, sexist, or otherwise wholly objectionable thoughts in the recesses of their mind and of those who do, certainly most of them know better than to spout such things to a public audience.
- mc32 11y agoWhat you mention are but a few of the socially unacceptable things in "liberal" environs, others will have locally unacceptable behaviors. There are regional and industry differences. I recall an attorney who prosecuted domestic violence got in trouble when it was found out he engaged in violent sex; consensual, but brutal non the less. In other places people get accused of burning religious books. It's all puerile revenge, not really much to do with social justice. Sometimes social justice is a nice cover, when it coincides.
- onion2k 11y agoSexual harassment very much is a crime. A woefully under-reported one, because lots of people don't think it's a crime.
- mc32 11y agoDo you honestly think his vulgar display was sexual harassment? Is the provincial or local government prosecuting this? Otherwise it's unwelcome and uncouth, but not illegal and your equivalency would be wildly exaggerated. He, the vulgar firee, should sue the province for illegal sacking --unless he displayed similar behavior toward coworkers or customers.
- oddevan 11y ago> not everyone harbors racist, sexist, or otherwise wholly objectionable thoughts in the recesses of their mind and certainly not everyone speaks such things publicly. I'll agree that "not everyone speaks such things publicly." The issue here is that jokes that are funny or at least "okay" in one context are incredibly offensive out of that context, and social media makes it easy for jokes to be taken out of context. But everyone, everyone has something in their mind that someone else finds objectionable. This is human nature. Even if those thoughts are not voiced or acted on, they are still there. The internet is so large with so many different views that inevitably someone will offend someone else without meaning to; even views that one person does not consider "sexist" could be "sexist" to someone else.
- Retric 11y agoI would take it further. People hate A, other people hate (not) A, and plenty of people on both sides hate those who don't pick a side. In the end there is no stance that does not offend someone. So, I don't think we can use offending someone as a reasonable rule for anything.
- darklajid 11y agoSo my brother sent me a youtube link yesterday. It was a show by Luis CK, containing gems like I'm waiting to see their kid. They're so beautiful, maybe I want to fuck their kid, I don't know. I'm not saying I would kill a kid and fuck him, … (continued for another moment or two) Now.. That's a stand-up comedian of course. The setting is clear. We obviously KNOW that he's trying to provoke and that he isn't serious. This isn't exactly my type of humor, but let's pretend I'd say something like that to a friend and someone overhears that. Or just quote it. Why would that change anything? I assume these things would fall below the 'objectionable thoughts' umbrella in your list. Would I deserve to be attacked for that? Fired for that? followed by I wouldn't fuck a kid. I wouldn't do that. Maybe a dead kid. Who are you hurting? He's _dead_. Who are you hurting?
- kohanz 11y agoThat's not really a comparable scenario. Being overheard in a private conversation is not what's being discussed in the FHRITP case. What if you said a similar type comment, but on camera to a television reporter who decided to ask you a question to clarify the "joke" (remember that the general public does not consider this a joke, nor does it consider it funny), and you involved the reporter or their child in the joke (e.g. similar to the "vibrator" comment)?
- darklajid 11y agoAgreed. If we're talking about the drunken guys in front of the camera and the FHRITP thing (I .. didn't even know about that), that's plain insulting. That's the point, I guess: Insult/provoke in a direct manner. But this thread and the article talk about other cases as well and I'd argue that the PyCon case was merely a private conversation that someone overheard. I'd expect to be able to say the lines above to a friend and bystanders have nothing to do with it.
- kohanz 11y agoYes, the Pycon and FHRITP scenarios are on completely different planets as far as I'm concerned. I guess I'm focusing more on the latter because of recency bias and because it's in my backyard, geographically.
- ohitsdom 11y ago> If I were to become an employer one day, what you say on your time is your province, not mine. What about the guy that had the racist blog? Would you be ok with that type of public internet behavior from your employee? Even if they identified themselves as your employee and had a picture online posing in front of the office?
- corobo 11y agoThe next sentence covers that "When you're representing the company, that's different."
- ohitsdom 11y agoYeah but in context of the post, it sounded like that was meant to read "on company time".
- kohanz 11y agoWhen is someone "representing the company", though? That's what a lot of this boils down to. Is it only when they are officially operating for the company? In this age of public LinkedIn profiles, etc., it's far too easy to associate the actions of an individual with their employer. In the FHRITP case, the man worked for a public (provincial government) organization, so I'm not surprised that there was outrage that someone who behaves in that way in public was on the public payroll.
- protonfish 11y agoHe was speaking anonymously and got doxed - as were the developers joking at the conference. We all do and say stupid things now and then and if somebody were filming you 24/7 it would not be very long before they documented something that was a social faux pas. There is a big difference between blurting out drunken nonsense and soberly, premeditated publishing under a personally identifiable account, especially if it is part of your job to be the public face of the company.
- 11y ago
- ChuckMcM 11y agoIt seems to be helping though. Outrage aside, it has been how communities have policed themselves since people were kicked out of the cave for taking too much mammoth at dinner time. The whole #FHRITP "meme" if you can call it that is a great example of how you really don't want adults behaving. And since their parents aren't around to teach them, we get employers (or schools) doing that. Learning that all of your actions have consequences is a ritual of growing up. And the older you get, the bigger the consequences.
- cazum 11y agoI believe the question that needs to be asked is: do we really want angry twitter doling out the consequences? Do a bunch of outraged keyboard warriors with too much time and doxxing knowhow really speak for what the entire community?
- mc32 11y agoIt'd be fabulous if everyone acted civilized and subdued their inner animal to capitulation. In my experience, there are very few people who will not intentionally or accidentally say something which goes contrary to the norms of the day. Maybe they are new to the culture, maybe the parents were undereducated, maybe they were wealthy and could belittle people. Either way, I have found very very few people who will never have spouted something magnanimously stupid at one occasion or other. Most of these people didn't "mean" it. Didn't outwardly believe such thing, though some did out of ignorance, or differing social contexts. Still, I hold people should have the right to segregate public from private life. What does it matter to you if someone does not pay the taxes the should self report from internet commerce? That's not your business's business. Nor is it their business if someone is a religious bigot, or racial bigot, etc., outside of work. If the were a problem, you'd have lots of employees who'd fail. Whites and non whites, blacks and non blacks, male and female and other sexual genders. Holding people to this "idiocy" standard, no doubt, would affect the least educated in "the proper received" way to communicate. Maybe let's abolish heavy metal, rap, hip hop, rock, etc., and anyone who listens to those music genders because they are so misogynistic, anti authoritarian and generally promote bad thoughts through normalization of such.
- mynameismonkey 11y ago>It's sad that people's alcohol fueled idiocy -not crime,but idiocy, becomes public and has repercussions in real life. I'm not sure I have this thought out well enough to write down but I'm going to try. I love the Internet, I love the Web. I love the new communications these technologies allow and empower. However, I have long been worried about the perceived anonymity of the Web, from both perspectives of (1) "hey you really shouldn't think you are anonymous" and (2) "wow, you are a complete moron when you think you're anonymous". I have also witnessed an inexorable degradation of personal content and personal speech on the Web, largely due (in my opinion) to this perceived anonymity. Maybe it's my British upbringing, but I for one would welcome a few more people being held to account publicly for that which they say in public. For many of us, there existed a world before this one that was less generally rude, more consequential. As a child and a young man, I knew that the people around me might see me acting in a given unsociable manner and report to my parents/aunts/uncles/cousins/whomever. This seems to have been forgotten online. I'm not certain how far to take this thought, but it seems to me that it wasn't all that long ago that in smaller, more defined communities, more people were similarly held to account by their community for their speech and actions. Our collective community has grown from village and town and city to worldwide, is this not perhaps simply the social mores and expectations finally beginning to catch up? If so, is that entirely a Bad Thing (TM)? Could it, should it lead to a more polite, more respectful online community of humanity?
- mc32 11y agoI'm not so sure. I'd like for people to behave more maturely and not act grotesquely uncouth, but I don't think I want a mob establishing and meting out justice. People can easily misidentify a person, and have the wrong one get the brunt. But mainly, all people should have the right to private time where they can hold and express unpopular views. I've known lots of "progressives" who in private will produce quire rude comments on those who don't align with their world views. It's a kind of hypocrisy, but hypocrisy isn't the villain. The thought we know what's right and we're gonna learn them a lesson on the internet is the mob condition which is wrong. This is the modern stockade and public shaming.