7 ms·
>The law that the NSA used to authorize its collection of vast amounts of information about the telephone calls of ordinary Americans is no more. But the US ca
by mrweasel 11y ago
>The law that the NSA used to authorize its collection of vast amounts of information about the telephone calls of ordinary Americans is no more.
But the US can still snoop on my internet traffic if it happens to parse through the US, because I'm not an American. For the majority of the world the issue was never that the NSA spied on US citizens, but that they pretty spy on everyone else as well.
Don't get me wrong, I think it should be illegal for the US, or any other nation, to spy on its citizens, but it still only half the problem.
- cm2187 11y agoIn fact I have seen several articles in major european newspapers claiming that big countries are going around restrictions on spying on their own citizens by letting friendly countries do it, then exploit the data. I don't know if there is any substance in these allegations but they seem plausible.
- venomsnake 11y agoRichard Marchinko stated the same, although in his fiction books. It was in the early nineties. I would not be surprised at all.
- tehwalrus 11y agoIf you have a proper Data Protection Act(s) passed, it should be illegal for people in a country to obtain or use data stolen against the country's laws elsewhere. Not ideal, but it would make illegal the circle of spying you describe. (not that the authorities, particularly here in the UK, give a flying F about whether they're breaking existing laws...)
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoI hate playing devil's advocate on this topic, but here goes. There are _real_ terrorists out there, and also agents of other states. These folks need observation for a free country to be able to do the various things it has to do. (Or, if they don't, it remains to be shown how such a setup would effectively work). I am completely against maintaining files on your own citizens which can then be "mined" to find illegalities or improprieties later on. However -- that doesn't mean that some folks shouldn't be watched. Heck, in a country with 250M people, the odds are that there are a heckuva lot of borderline crazy people who should be monitored. I seriously hope the local constable has a good idea of the top people in his area that he should keep an eye on. I think we make a mistake when we focus on the NSA exclusively and talk as if all data collection is wrong. We need a principle that allows for nuanced collection -- not one-size-fits-all slogans. So sure, I hope the other agencies are collecting info on folks in my country, and I hope they share that information with my own country's security services -- under the right circumstances and with the right protections in place. What I don't want to see happen is the creation of a data pool where crimes can be "discovered" that normally wouldn't matter. (Really hated writing that, but somebody had to do it)
- Nursie 11y agoIt was never the case that all collection was wrong. However it is still wrong to just collect all the data you can on everyone, even if everyone now doesn't include your own citizens. >> So sure, I hope the other agencies are collecting info on folks in my country, and I hope they share that information with my own country's security services -- under the right circumstances and with the right protections in place. This is no different from having your own guys do it. Possibly it's worse.
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoI think, perhaps, the way out of this is a universal moratorium on the commercial collection and retention of data, along with safeguards for data mining by government agencies for criminal (not intelligence) purposes. We must remember that as far as I can tell, governments have always wanted to collect whatever they could about anybody -- citizen or not. I do not agree with this, but the tendency is not limited to one government or another. What's new in the equation is the vast numbers of commercial applications/services that also want to track your every move online in order to keep you as a customer. It's this collection/retention of data that governments are now tapping into. If nobody had kept anything past 2 or 3 days, there wouldn't be much to mine.
- mike_hearn 11y agoThe distinction you are looking for does not exist. The primary justification for what the NSA is doing is crime: namely terrorism. The entire purpose of the NSA is to find criminals, which is a problem, because the definition of criminal can be anything the people in power want it to be. For instance in the UK they're busy trying to crack down on "extremism". The Prime Minister has given a speech about extremism where he actually said words to the effect of "For too long we have been a passively tolerant society where if you follow the law, we leave you alone". GCHQ is absolutely being mandated to find extremists. It's merely the next chunk of the slippery slope that started the moment the law changed to try and fight terrorists.
- 11y ago
- dfinninger 11y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes Might be what you are referring to... at least for the English speaking world.
- secfirstmd 11y agoThis has been done and openly acknowledged by GCHQ against American citizens and NSA against British citizens since the 1980s.
- rmc 11y agoAll too often, US groups that should be allies in the fight against state survelliance show their true colours and only really campaign when American privacy is under threat.
- DavideNL 11y ago>> but it still only half the problem. agreed, but not half the problem: 4.43% of the problem :-) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependencies_by_population#Countries_and_dependencies_by_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependen...
- happyscrappy 11y agoThat this is the top comment shows how unrealistic opinions on some subjects are on HN. Spies should not be spying, soldiers should not be fighting, there should be no countries. Might as well ask for unicorns.
- rmxt 11y agoYou made the unfortunate jump to the other extreme from the GP: nowhere did the GP say or imply that "spies should not be spying, soldiers should not be fighting." There's room for nuance between "dragnet surveillance" and "no covert operations," but you seem to have missed that.
- happyscrappy 11y agoIf they are not supposed to spy on Americans or foreigners what exactly are they supposed to do?
- rmxt 11y agoNo one (in this thread at least) has said that they are not supposed to "spy" completely. What people are concerned with is dragnet surveillance. The way you are framing the issue is a classic case of a false dilemma. EDIT: My apologies, it looks like the top comment does drop that in at the end. That is indeed an unfortunate generalization. I do think that a more moderate and "middle-of-the-HN-crowd" approach would actually entail something short of dragnet surveillance though.
- mrweasel 11y agoSoldiers aren't asked to shoot every single foreigner traveling through your country, just in case they may want to hurt you. There's nothing wrong in having an intelligence agency that spy on people you may suspect of wanting to hurt you or your country. What the US does, other countries do this as well, is spying on people that aren't suspected of anything, even people living in their own or allied countries. Even worse is that in the process of ensuring that they are able to do this surveillance they actively harm people legitimate ability to have anonymous or secret conversations. As someone living in a country that views it self, even prides it self on being a close ally of the US, I find the US behavior reprehensible. "Yeah, let's be friend, trade and support each other, but just to be sure I'll also go through your mail", that's no way for a civilized country to behave. I know this may read like a tirade against the US and that unfortunate, because other countries are just as bad. I'm equally disappointed by my own country and our politicians, it's just their actions have yet to be fully revealed.
- pvnick 11y agoIndeed that is still a huge problem, but let's take some time now to celebrate the progress that has been made before doubling down and focusing on the other things. It's been a long time coming but we're actually seeing progress now. Let's take some time to pat ourselves on the back.
- DennisP 11y agoAlthough I sympathize, I think domestic surveillance by any country is the most insidious, because it undermines the democratic process. Without that, there's no hope of keeping this stuff in check. What's most important in your country is whether your own government is spying on you (either directly, or indirectly by getting feeds from the NSA).