3 ms·
I don't consider SN to be a good alternative to Slashdot. It exhibits many of the same problems as Slashdot, but they're usually worse at SN than at Slashdot.
by JimFJones 11y ago
I don't consider SN to be a good alternative to Slashdot. It exhibits many of the same problems as Slashdot, but they're usually worse at SN than at Slashdot.
While many of the stories are the same at both sites, they're typically on Slashdot well before they're on SN. Many low-quality submissions get through on SN, as well, most of which would have no chance at Slashdot. Of these low-quality submissions at SN, many of them come from a small number of frequent contributors who are known to consistently send in biased and inflammatory submissions. While Slashdot's editors aren't known for doing a good job, we aren't seeing anything better out of SN's editors, and in fact I'd say they're doing a worse job based on some of the submissions I've seen there that have made it to the SN front page.
The SN community is also quite tiny. Most of the comments I've seen come from a relatively small number of people. Slashdot still offers a much larger community. This results in much better discussion at Slashdot, while much of the discussion at SN is inane, if not totally off topic.
Slashdot's moderation system isn't great, but I do find it generally does help me identify high quality comments, while also helping me to disregard low quality comments. That's not the case at SN. When I read the comments at SN, I always have to set it to show -1 comments. Very insightful and informative comments often end up at -1 on SN, while many of the highly-rated comments are absolutely worthless. The very small number of active users results in an even smaller number of users who are allowed to moderate, and this has resulted in the moderation system being used to push specific agendas or target certain other users, rather than giving a quasi-objective rating of a comment's value. The moderation system at Slashdot is generally helpful. The moderation system at SN is used as a weapon.
SN had a lot of potential. But now that the Slashdot beta site is gone, and likely won't be back, the biggest benefit of SN is gone. With its lack of quality submissions, with its small community, with its moderation problems, and with it's other less-serious flaws, SN provides no benefit over Slashdot. Slashdot offers better stories faster, its community offers wider and deeper points of view, its moderation system is much fairer and more balanced, and it's just a much better news source than SN is.