19 ms·
Stress Test Recap: Bitcoin
- tedunangst 11y agoDoesn't this kind of put a dent in the whole micro transaction argument? Once we hit peak Bitcoin, if I want to tip you a penny for your HN comment, I'm not going to pay a nickel in transaction fees to do so.
- Ellipsis753 11y agoYes. Although they're been quite high before. At the moment they're still in the pennies.
- biturd 11y agoI have never bought btc, there is a fee? This is a function the wallet provides? Who gets the fee? I have bought dogecoins as a joke, and I have a wallet for that, which I send a few coins here and there to others, which cost me nothing. Not quite following what I thought was the basic principles of how this works now.
- blhack 11y agoThere is a fee, it goes to the person who processes your transaction (a bitcoin "miner"). Dogecoin has the same thing. It was likely not free for you to send those coins (unless it was an off-chain transfer via a hosted wallet [think transferring money between checking accounts at USBANK])
- ryanlol 11y agoThe fee is optional and currently just make your transactions get processed faster. Although, a hostile party would be able to stop transactions without fees from being processed simply by flooding them.
- tylersmith 11y agoFees are in most cryptocurrencies. They go the miner that finds that block which includes your transaction. The miner gets a standard block reward (currently 25btc) plus the fees from all transactions included in that block. The idea is that in the long term as the block reward tends toward 0, the value of bitcoins rise and a tiny fee from each transaction compensates the miners as much or more than the current block reward does which will continue to incentivize them to be honest. Currently, fees are essentially an anti-spam measure to keep people from creating millions of transactions with the same coin and DDoSing other transactions. I.e. without fees a single person could be issuing more transactions than this stress test did, for free, non-stop.
- davidgerard 11y agoThe original idea was that as mining rewards are reduced with time, miners will get their fees from transactions instead.
- kristianp 11y agohttp://bitzuma.com/posts/making-sense-of-bitcoin-transaction-fees/ http://bitzuma.com/posts/making-sense-of-bitcoin-transaction...
- nkuttler 11y agoBitcoin was not designed for microtransactions. Whoever told you that was wrong.
- davidgerard 11y agoRed herring: Bitcoin was not particularly designed for any use case at all. The thing in the white paper is the cardboard-and-string proof of concept that something like Bitcoin could exist at all, and the white paper talks about improving the protocol in due course. Of course, nobody did. It is, however, true that microtransactions were heavily touted by Bitcoin advocates, until of course it became blindingly obvious that Bitcoin didn't scale.
- javert 11y agoMicrotransactions don't need to go on the blockchain.
- tveita 11y agoMore to the point, they don't need to use Bitcoin at all.
- brighton36 11y agoHow would you transfer micropayments if not Bitcoin? I don't believe there are any other solutions that don't require an inordinate burden on all persons involved...
- themgt 11y agoIt's become beyond obvious that existing Bitcoin blockchain technology has no real ability to scale, function as a long-term store of value, or withstand even moderate attacks by bad actors. The hype has gotten in the way of building something that makes sense, and the continued belief in "Bitcoin" as the answer rather than some mew - perhaps maybe with a lot of further innovation - blockchain inspired tech, seems mostly tied up in the "investors" left who spent real dollars for the bits they're now watching depreciate, and can't bring themselves to admit an interesting, failed technology's digital coins are worth about as much as old Pokemon trading cards.
- javert 11y ago> some mew - perhaps maybe with a lot of further innovation - blockchain inspired tech There is no other way to get a decentralized global ledger. Well, if there is, it would be a huge discovery, just like bitcoin was. > It's become beyond obvious that existing Bitcoin blockchain technology has no real ability to scale Once you have the ledger, you don't need to put every transaction on it. Lots of them can happen off the chain. So yeah, your "obvious" is another word for "wrong".
- aliakhtar 11y ago> Once you have the ledger We've had ledgers for quite a while, bitcoin wasn't the first digital ledger. I still don't understand the use case of a decentralized ledger, other than for illegal uses.
- natrius 11y agoYou're in for a treat, then. A blockchain is a world computer. Each program on the computer has its own storage that nothing else can write to, so anyone sending a transaction to the computer knows exactly what the result will be. (Most blockchains only have one program, like Bitcoin. Others have multiple programs that can call each other, like Ethereum.) This shared, unforgeable platform can be used to coordinate interactions between individuals, corporations, or other entities. This technology gives mankind a new superpower: we can interact with anyone on the planet with predictable results and near-zero transaction costs. Interactions that only involve information, like financial markets, can be guaranteed to follow the rules of the blockchain, which will eliminate all financial middlemen you pay fees to today. Real world interactions can't be governed by software, but they can be guided by software. Reputation systems that run on blockchains will tell you exactly how likely you are to be satisfied with a real world interaction, so you can interact with complete strangers who live anywhere on the planet. I think most trade will be blockchain-mediated in the near future.
- patio11 11y agoQuick mental math: 2.5k transactions or so in a block, 3 cents each for transaction fee means that it costs $75 or so to fill up a block with economically irrelevant transactions (i.e. moving money from one of your pockets to the other). This means you can degrade the performance of the Bitcoin network for about $10k per day. You can probably optimize that down to $3~4k or so by being smarter about the transactions you're DDOSing with. This is left as an exercise for the reader.
- stream_fusion 11y agoAn argument behind not increasing the block size, is that miners can price-ration the inclusion of transactions in blocks. During periods of high network contention, an ordinary user can include a higher-fee to prioritize their transactions. Correspondingly, the cost for attacking the network using spurious transactions will increase.
- sarahj 11y agoI remember reading about Bitcoin a couple of years ago and expressing disbelief that many of the major advantages being heralded were little more than fantasy, these were: * Micro-transactions. * Replacing practically everything related to money in developing countries. From this thread it is clear that many of those dreams are still very much dreams - the ever growing energy and resource requirements to participate significantly in the network is staggering, the amount of storage required for the blockchain is a burden to even tech-aware users (unless of course one would want to trust a third party...), and now it would seem that there are minimum bandwidth requirements which sit outside what is possible in even modest parts of the USA - impossible to achieve in places where the main link to the internet is a satellite. If I was feeling particularly optimistic I would say that Bitcoin has been shown to be unscalable in it's current form. Further, the network itself tends towards centralization because of the ever growing storage, processing and bandwidth requirements. I look forward to seeing where the future of crypocurrencies leads us- there is so much promise.
- brighton36 11y agoYou wouldn't believe how clunky the Internet was when it first started. This stress test is fairly minor compared to the problems bitcoin had in 2011 and 2012. With time, the blockchain will improve. Just like the Internet. You should look into the Lightning Network paper, there's no shortages of solutions in bitcoin. Meanwhile, traditional financial platforms have been stagnant for decades.
- kaoD 11y agoThe internet got better as time went by. The blockchain is getting worse.
- aliakhtar 11y agoIn 2000, about 5-6 years after the internet was easily available to public, I had a dial up connection, email, IM, a web browser, etc in the middle-of-nowhere town in Pakistan where I was born. Bitcoin has been out for close to 6-7 years and does not even come close to the maturity / adoption of internet.
- natrius 11y agoThere are lots of uninformed claims here about Bitcoin's scalability. If it's a topic you're interested in, you should do some reading on your own. In particular, the Lightning Network proposal is a promising approach to dramatically increase the number of transactions that can occur trustlessly, but without having to put each transaction on the blockchain. http://lightning.network/ http://lightning.network/
- davidgerard 11y agoIt has the unfortunate problem that, like sidechains, it doesn't exist. We already have altcoins. This might be an actually innovative altcoin. But it's not really going to be Bitcoin.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dogecoinbase 11y agoThe logical next step, of course, is miners themselves flooding the network in order to drive up transaction fees.
- kanzure 11y ago> The logical next step, of course, is miners themselves flooding the network in order to drive up transaction fees. That's unnecessary. Miners can choose to include no transactions in blocks. They can also choose to include only transactions paying higher-than-average transaction fees if they want to make it more obvious to others that they are going for high fees.