8 ms·
The weaker sex
- s_kilk 11y agoThis may mark me out as an asshole, but I don't have very much sympathy. Back when I was about 15 and still in school, a bunch of our classmates dropped out to go working in construction jobs after completing the Junior Certificate (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Junior_Certificate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Junior_Certificate). At the time Ireland was enjoying a boom in construction, so there was decent money to be made for anyone willing to stop their education and haul bricks around a field all day. To my friends and I this was a transparently idiotic strategy, grasping at an easy short-term gain which no-one believed would last more than a few years. But of course we were made out to be the real chumps for staying in school. Fast forward to now and every one of the dropouts is un-employed, having enjoyed a few short years of decent wages and then witnessed their livelihoods disappear into an economic black hole around 2008.
- Apocryphon 11y agoWhat happens when the tech bubble bursts? Yes, certainly we live in the information age, and there will always be a need for tech workers, but the demand will fall with the economy. So isn't there an element to short-term gain for people who went into tech simply because of the past decade?
- s_kilk 11y agoWhat happens when the medicine bubble bursts? Or the engineering bubble? We could say this about any profession, that the good times may end some day. That doesn't make the decision of those young men any less short-sighted. They had every chance at _not_ being under-educated labourers, but they chose explicitly to take that path, even when most around them advised that the construction bubble was in serious danger of collapse in the near future. Maybe I too will be destitute some day, but that's a different story.
- DanBC 11y agoI'm glad this article mentions male suicide. Rates are higher for men and this isn't completely explained by the fact that men tend to use more lethal methods. The article mentions that men with poor education in rich nations are particularly struggling. This is supported by a bit of data we have: builders are becoming an industry with a higher than average risk of suicide. Other professions tend to have access to means and methods, or detailed knowledge, neither of which applies to builders. I'm aware of two great campaigns that tackle male suicide. One is Australian: soften the fck up (they don't censor the word on their website): http://softenthefckup.com.au/ http://softenthefckup.com.au/ Campaign Against Living Miserably: https://www.thecalmzone.net/ https://www.thecalmzone.net/ I am always interested in hearing about other campaigns from anywhere.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoThere appears to be some concerted effort to leave unhinged comments on any popular article that might be construed as feminist. I wonder how they'd justify these rants? Do they actually think they're convincing people? Is this related to conspiracy theories in some way? This article would appear to be what the commenters would want, greater support for disadvantaged men and boys, but it seems to have wound them up even more.
- RodericDay 11y agoWhen I was still a fairly generic STEM kid, skeptical of "feminism" and a bit tempted to oppose it via "egalitarianism" or something like that, I got into an argument over the internet where my opposite said this: "Mainstream, sex-positive feminism is about equality and is concerned with the rights of men whenever they're in question. I'm a total feminist who believes that the significance of male rape is hugely devalued by society, that family court relies on outdated standards, and a few other 'MRA' bulletpoints. I find nothing but agreement when I pursue these ideas in a public, academic, or otherwise serious sphere. The Men's Rights movement, however, is not a legitimate offshoot of a cruel and uncaring feminism. It's a reactionary, hostile internet culture that inevitably finds itself tied up in aggressive takedowns of feminism, responsible for fomenting a lot of denial of its legitimacy through a cherry-picked view of fringe perspectives, poorly considered, half-scientific 'biotruths' and a thin veneer of concern for the rights of men. Feminism is not called feminism because it hates men. It's called feminism because it comes from societies with a history of gross, outrageous repression of women. As we move closer to equality, it becomes natural that men should involve themselves in the movement and ensure that it considers their rights as well. But feminism does that. MRA denies that only as a stepladder to get into a denial of the legitimacy of the female accomplishments of feminism. That's what it is at its core." I was very impressed. I conceded, and it's stuck with me to this day.
- thsealienbstrds 11y agoRegardless of club affiliation, generally speaking it makes no sense to have women stand up for men's rights. Men need to stand up for men's rights because then at least you can assume authenticity based on shared self-interest. In that respect, even MRA is, for men, an improvement on feminism.
- _random_ 11y agoIt would be nice if Economist could post an article discussing the supply of "marriageable women" (using their words). Also, plenty of old failing "you can have it all" narrative like: "Women have learned that they can be surgeons and physicists without losing their femininity." vs http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-3078210/Number-women-freezing-eggs-soars-400-one-year-careers-prioritised-motherhood.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-3078210/Number-wom... In much of the world they still enjoy social and legal privileges simply because they have a Y chromosome. vs http://www.quora.com/What-is-the-logic-behind-France-banning-paternity-tests http://www.quora.com/What-is-the-logic-behind-France-banning... But there were some good conclusions: "More generally, schools need to become more boy-friendly...".
- Mz 11y agoI recently read "Working in the Shadows: A year of doing the work (most) Americans won't do." http://www.amazon.com/Working-Shadows-Year-Doing-Americans/dp/1568586388/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1433104880&sr=8-1&keywords=working+in+the+shadows http://www.amazon.com/Working-Shadows-Year-Doing-Americans/d... It makes some excellent points about how pathetically underpaid some jobs are and how crucial they are to the functioning of society. People (mostly men) who do back-breaking labor, like harvest food from the fields, are critical to the food supply, yet it is often paid less than minimum wage. My dad grew up on a farm and was a soldier for more than 2 1/2 decades. I always find it pretty galling when folks who make good money are basically snobby assholes about the value of blue collar work. We really need to do something about making sure that critical jobs get paid a living wage -- not out of compassion or charity but out of enlightened self-interest. That's the only way the spoiled educated people who made "good" career choices will get to keep sitting on their asses at a computer and still eat. Sigh. There are some things very wrong with this world. Not in a "gosh, we are all assholes" sort of way but in a "gosh, we are all idiots -- what happens if we can't fill these blue collar jobs and the grocery store shelves sit empty?" sort of way.
- nascentmind 11y agoI don't understand why there is such a disdain for blue collar jobs. Isn't it honest living? The good are tangible and benefits the society. Boys in the developed world are 50% more likely to flunk basic maths, reading and science entirely. Then why is the media crying out that STEM fields are dominated by men and more women should be encouraged? The problem in the US is that they cry that manufacturing jobs are going away. Why don't they attract some? Manufacturing complements with engineering. They develop society. The only reason that education and healthcare where supposedly most of the women are present as per the article is still present in the US is because it has not been outsourced. It has nothing to do with high skills.