3 ms·
It seems based on your reply that we will never know, then, whether initial assessments of complexity were correct. If the description of a problem never matche
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
It seems based on your reply that we will never know, then, whether initial assessments of complexity were correct. If the description of a problem never matches the solution, it becomes very difficult to have a conversation about whether a solution actually addressed a problem, no? The problem mutates from it's original nature and becomes assembling and coordinating disparate groups.
I note that there are many examples of solutions to problems in legislative circles done in a direct fashion -- I'm not certain this is as much a requirement of legislative solution-creation as much as a certain style of decision-making.
I don't have any conclusions, just the observation that if the goal is to gain support of various groups, then it's not really about solving the initial problem any more, because with just a small number of groups it's very easy to over-constrain a solution.
Very interesting. Is it a bug? Or feature?
- camccann 17y agoI note that there are many examples of solutions to problems in legislative circles done in a direct fashion -- I'm not certain this is as much a requirement of legislative solution-creation as much as a certain style of decision-making. Well, it's a feature of politics-in-general, not legislating as such. One could probably observe the same dynamics arising semi-spontaneously in any context where a group with a diffuse distribution of influence has to make a collective decision. It's the old "design by committee" problem, just writ very large when we're talking about the US federal government. Very interesting. Is it a bug? Or feature? That's more of a value judgment than I'm prepared to make. I'd call it an inevitability, for decisions made in certain environments.