3 ms·
Perhaps I got to the party late, but I've read some dynamite analysis of the problems of healthcare by commenters and articles on HN. Most all of these are able
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Perhaps I got to the party late, but I've read some dynamite analysis of the problems of healthcare by commenters and articles on HN. Most all of these are able to lay out the drivers of the problems and suggest concrete, simple ways to fix things.
However when I look at the current proposed solutions, they are neither simple or concrete. Instead (to me) they look byzantine, obtuse, and obfuscated.
This leads me to believe that either lots of really smart people have vastly underestimated the complexity of the problem, or that the people currently charged with fixing it are unable or unwilling to work in a direct manner.
All three of these are interesting conclusions.
- camccann 17y agoMaking things happen in politics typically requires convincing at least some threshold number of largely disparate groups that they each stand to benefit (in some tangible, direct way) from your proposal, or at least won't be harmed by it. This tends to constrain the space of possible solutions in awkward ways, as an initially simple proposal may accrete peculiar exceptions, irrelevant attachments, and other cruft until enough people are happy. If you're lucky, the final result of the process will still fulfill the purpose of the original proposal. If you're unlucky, the crufting process will have completely undermined the original intent and you'll have to either vote against your own proposal (which is embarrassing) or pass it anyway (wasting taxpayer money on all the useless cruft). That said: smart people are often prone to underestimating the complexity of problems outside of their domain of expertise, and it's easy to propose solutions when you're not the person implementing them. So it's probably a bit of both.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoIt seems based on your reply that we will never know, then, whether initial assessments of complexity were correct. If the description of a problem never matches the solution, it becomes very difficult to have a conversation about whether a solution actually addressed a problem, no? The problem mutates from it's original nature and becomes assembling and coordinating disparate groups. I note that there are many examples of solutions to problems in legislative circles done in a direct fashion -- I'm not certain this is as much a requirement of legislative solution-creation as much as a certain style of decision-making. I don't have any conclusions, just the observation that if the goal is to gain support of various groups, then it's not really about solving the initial problem any more, because with just a small number of groups it's very easy to over-constrain a solution. Very interesting. Is it a bug? Or feature?
- camccann 17y agoI note that there are many examples of solutions to problems in legislative circles done in a direct fashion -- I'm not certain this is as much a requirement of legislative solution-creation as much as a certain style of decision-making. Well, it's a feature of politics-in-general, not legislating as such. One could probably observe the same dynamics arising semi-spontaneously in any context where a group with a diffuse distribution of influence has to make a collective decision. It's the old "design by committee" problem, just writ very large when we're talking about the US federal government. Very interesting. Is it a bug? Or feature? That's more of a value judgment than I'm prepared to make. I'd call it an inevitability, for decisions made in certain environments.
- lionhearted 17y agoWell, the above isn't a comprehensive solution, but it should help a good bit. Here's why I believe the above suggestions would help the current state of things at minimal cost and downside - Doctor's fees: When something costs a lot and the supply is artificially restricted, lessening those restrictions on supply usually makes the cost go down. Medical insurance: When a good is tax free if purchased through a specific administrative process, but taxed if purchased independently, you're going to see the process utilized and administrative costs go up. If you offer the same benefit without the required administration, you would expect administrative costs to go down. Drug costs: The more trials and greater burden of proof on a drug company before releasing a drug to market, the longer it will take to get to market and more it will cost to get to market. If you can reduce the requirements without compromising safety, drugs will most likely get a little cheaper and get to market faster. I think a lot of people want a comprehensive solution, and this is not a comprehensive solution - but it should help quite a lot at not much cost, and it isn't particularly politically charged in one direction or the other. There's complex problems, but if there's a simple way to take a few medium-sized dents out of the problem that's likely to work with relatively low cost or downside, I reckon that ought to be pursued.
- bokonist 17y agoBasically, the current system is a local optimum for a large number of powerful interests. Also, the beneficiaries of a current system all are organized, while the beneficiaries of some major reform are not organized, thus their lobbying power is greatly muted. If you're interested, I wrote a blog post where I lay out in detail why the politics of healthcare reform solves for complicated solutions: http://intellectual-detox.com/2009/09/10/the-perfect-healthcare-plan-and-why-well-never-get-it/ http://intellectual-detox.com/2009/09/10/the-perfect-healthc... I'd love to hear your thoughts. Also, I highly recommend "Government's End" by Jonathan Rauch which is the single best book to understand Washington. It talks a lot about this issue. The core problem is that the structure of our political system is fundamentally pro-entropy. Madison was completely wrong about factions. Unfortunately, the only way to defeat entropy is with concentrated authority. But that is anathema to the American ideology. So the entropy continues to increase unabated.
- camccann 17y agoIf you enjoy interesting, just-crazy-enough-to-work, will-never-actually-happen solutions to the health care problem, take a look at this one: http://hanson.gmu.edu/buyhealth.html http://hanson.gmu.edu/buyhealth.html the author of that piece has some interesting perspectives on the issue.