4 ms·
Pretty disgusting, but not surprising. What amazes me is that juries place any weight on jailhouse informants. As the article suggests you can be convicted sol
by danieltillett 11y ago
Pretty disgusting, but not surprising.
What amazes me is that juries place any weight on jailhouse informants. As the article suggests you can be convicted solely on the information provided by a single jailhouse informant. What sort of jury could come to an 12-0 vote that any case like this was beyond reasonable doubt?
- downandout 11y ago>What sort of jury could come to an 12-0 vote that any case like this was beyond reasonable doubt? People that have not ever had had friends or family ensnared in the criminal justice system tend to project popular myths and natural biases onto anyone in jail. One of those is that people in jail are all idiots that do nothing all day but sit around bragging to their cellmates about their crimes. This is why jailhouse snitches are believed by juries, despite the obvious incentive to lie.
- danieltillett 11y agoWell yes. If juries gave no weight to the testimony of convicted criminals with an enormous incentive to lie then prosecutors would stop putting them on the stand. It tells us how broken the whole jury system is when prosecutors go to the effort of obtaining these testimonies. Interesting here in Australia these jailhouse testimonies are not given much weight by juries and when used (rarely) they are seen as a desperate attempt by the crown to bolster a very weak case. I guess the more people learn about how corrupt these testimonies are the less juries will believe them and hopefully they will stop being used.
- geomark 11y agoWhat sort of jury could come to an 12-0 vote that any case like this was beyond reasonable doubt? If you have served on a few juries like I have your (anecdotal) evidence may indicate (as mine does) that most people are very stupid and unable to apply even the most basic logic. Then again, maybe it is only the stupid ones (myself included?) that can't figure out how to get out of jury duty so the jury pool self selects for stupidity.
- danieltillett 11y agoI have been called to serve on a few juries, but have so far been excluded by either the defence or prosecution. I still find it hard to believe that you could get together 12 people no matter how stupid that would convict on the basis of jailhouse testimony alone. What were they thinking - someone in prison out of the goodness of their heart and with no expectation of reward just decided to go to the authorities and tell all despite being in an environment where being a snitch gets you killed?
- geomark 11y agoAgree. My small sample (3 cases) indicates hung jury is the expected outcome. Seems like long odds to get a conviction. The key - a skilled lawyer can win at the jury selection stage almost regardless of the merits of the case.