3 ms·
My sister just paid $2600 for an MRI. I just paid $860 for an MRI. Apparently, there are other places a few miles away where I could have paid $400 less for t
by stcredzero 17y ago
My sister just paid $2600 for an MRI. I just paid $860 for an MRI. Apparently, there are other places a few miles away where I could have paid $400 less for the same MRI.
In Japan, the same MRI would cost $160.
- natrius 17y ago"In Japan, the same MRI would cost $160." The upfront cost would be $160, right? I'd prefer to subsidize healthcare for people who actually need help. You and I are probably around the same place economically speaking, so why don't both of us just pay for our own healthcare?
- daniel-cussen 17y agoAccording to patio11, they are actually cheaper in Japan because of cheap-o machines.
- patio11 17y agoThat did not strike me as something I would say, so I checked on SearchYC and found who actually said it. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=794374 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=794374 My experience on healthcare in Japan is largely positive, except for the one time I really needed it. (And I lived through that, though it was a bit touch and go for a while.) Don't get me started on dental care, though. I had a business trip to Chicago recently and used the opportunity to drop by my parents' dentist for a long overdue routine cleaning. My conversation with them was almost comical: I kept offering to pay them money and they kept asking me how they could help me find a way to get insurance to pay for it. (It ended up costing about five times what my last cleaning in Japan did -- and would have been cheap at twice the price. Don't get me started on Japanese dentistry.)
- daniel-cussen 17y agoMy bad. That's not the quote, but I should have been more specific and quoted something other than a YC comment I vaguely remembered.
- jerf 17y agoHow hard would it have been for your sister to go to the $400 place and pay $400? If the answer is "very", then you don't have a market. I consider the idea that the US has a free market in health care laughable. How "free market" something is is a continuum, not a binary distinction, but my ability to price discriminate or choose among competing insurance providers is effectively nil. I sometimes wonder how much of the problem could be fixed if we took the simple step of stopping making it virtually necessary to get health insurance from your employer for tax reasons and then just see what happens for a couple of years. (But naw, too simple, let's pass a 2000 page law.)
- gcheong 17y agoMilton Friedman seemed to think it would be a good idea: http://www.hoover.org/publications/digest/3459466.html http://www.hoover.org/publications/digest/3459466.html
- camccann 17y agoHow "free market" something is is a continuum, not a binary distinction Even worse: it's a multi-dimensional continuum, where the function mapping points from the space "all possible markets" to the space "quality of the resulting health care system" is almost completely unknown, but probably has lots of local maxima and minima distributed throughout the space. The task we're faced with is "maximize the value of the quality function by making semi-blind guesses, while hopefully not landing in a very bad local minimum". I don't think they covered an algorithm for that one in my CS classes...