5 ms·
Birth rate is rarely the correct metric because it is affected by longevity. The metric most people are interested in is fertility rate, where Germany still has
by lern_too_spel 11y ago
Birth rate is rarely the correct metric because it is affected by longevity. The metric most people are interested in is fertility rate, where Germany still has a long way to go to pass Singapore. https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2127rank.html https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/...
- alkonaut 11y agoThis. Birth rate has a lot of uncontrollable factors like demographics. A slump in people in ages 20-40 will inevitably leas to falling birth rate at the same fertility. And that will repeat in 20-40 years. The factor to focus on is the fertility and the fraction of working adults. Germany has a very traditional view of the labour market and women often have to stop working for years when having children. This means that a large group of women don't work, or (equally bad for the economy), a large group of women chose not to have kids. The only proven solution is subsidized childcare, longer parental leave, individual taxation.
- tokenadult 11y agoThe only proven solution is subsidized childcare, longer parental leave, individual taxation. This is an interesting comment to me, because I'm trying to think of example country pairs in which a country with subsidized childcare, longer parental leave, and individual taxation has a higher fertility rate than an otherwise similar country that lacks those things. The United States continues to have a higher fertility rate than many countries in Europe that have more subsidized childcare and longer mandated parental leave than the United States, for example, so I'm not sure that these public policy factors outdo the effect of other cultural and economic factors in either raising or lowering the country-wide fertility rate.
- digitalzombie 11y agoUS also have large immigration. I've noticed countries that have huge immigration can offset any birthrate. Japan is in trouble cause they don't have any immigration laws.
- alkonaut 11y agoSweden-Germany is such a pair. They both have high immigration rate too.
- dheera 11y agoNot to mention that in these highly-developed countries with solid education systems and modern career opportunities, the value-creating power of an individual is several times higher than that of an average individual in a developing country. The fertility rate among founders in Silicon Valley is probably even lower, but that group of people is creating an immense amount of value for society in return for not creating as many kids.
- sanoli 11y agoThey're creating stuff that's valuable to society. I don't see though how they're so much greater than other people who create value, like medical researchers, biotech researchers, engineers, artists, etc.
- dheera 11y agoAll of those professions count too. My point is that the value-creating power of any well-educated individual (in any profession) is higher; thus, the government of a country with a solid education system shouldn't be afraid of a lack of population expansion; value to the country isn't indicated by number of lives.
- bluedevil2k 11y agoI'm not sure creating yet another social media photo sharing disappearing anonymous comment app is more valuable, to society or the individual, than children.
- junto 11y agoBingo. Came here to say this too. Germany has a very large aging population. In 15 years time a large percentage of these will have died (baby boomers). Germany has some interested ng regional issues too. Many old DDR states have lost much of their younger generation. These states are filled with people in their late 50's and older.