4 ms·
This entry doesn't feel like a complete thought to me, basically some observations on notional "magic" and the rules for developing and implementing the same. C
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
This entry doesn't feel like a complete thought to me, basically some observations on notional "magic" and the rules for developing and implementing the same. Conceptually there has been a lot of work done on Magical systems, both from a technical point of view and story point of view, very little of which seems referenced :-).
Typical RPG systems use magic either entirely, or mostly entirely, for combat. Meaning attacking and defending against attacks (physical and magical) which result in damage to the player or the opponent. And unlike Magic in books like the Harry Potter series where it has more of a 'tool' nature (travel, lighting, retrieving things, fixing things, cleaning, Etc.)
That said, having dabbled in game design I have found that "real world" things like economics and physics express self contained and dynamically stable systems. That can be useful in the fantasy world given that one ever burning fire spell could burn everything in the game universe if there wasn't something which prevented that from happening. So thinks like the inverse square law and conservation of (magical) energy really help out in keeping the game from becoming radically unbalanced.
When I read "The Magic Goes Away" by Niven I felt it was an interesting take on 'magic as alternate scientific thing' and Zelazny's unfinished "Changling" trilogy about magic in an alternate world an interesting 'magic is where you find it' sort of system.
- FlailFast 11y ago+1 to Zelazny's take on magic. Didn't realize Changeling was meant to be a trilogy (although that makes a ton more sense in retrospect, too bad it never had a threequel). I also find his Chronicles of Amber to be an interesting take on Universe building, although the magic system is less formulated (but damn is the whole Pattern/Chaos thing cool). All of which to say: if you haven't read Zelazny you should, he's a wonderful writer.
- CurtMonash 11y ago+N to any Zelazny praise, for N a rather large integer. An attempt was actually made to codify Amber into a "diceless" RPG. Had some great times playing it.
- lizzard 11y agoThere's at least a couple of AmberCons (like AmberConNW: http://www.amberconnw.org/ http://www.amberconnw.org/), entire weekends where a bunch of people get together to run games in this system.
- babuskov 11y agoI still remember playing Shadows Over Riva where you had magic to see through walls or teleport to a distance thus completely avoiding combat with though enemies. Sure, if none of the mages in your party had those it made the game much harder, but that's the whole fun IMHO. If you are only playing the game yourself, I don't see a need to balance out the skills, spells, races, etc. I understand that balance is needed in MMOs and such, but I love single-player games that give you freedom and ability to "rule". Another example (non RPG though) of great non-combat magic is Heroes of Might and Magic where you have spells to summon boats, walk over the oceans, teleport across the map, see the treasure/resources obscured with fog of war, disguise your army as more powerful creatures, etc.