3 ms·
>They served their purpose and were good approximations for calculations we did and observations we had all those years. In other words they were empirically m
by foldr 11y ago
>They served their purpose and were good approximations for calculations we did and observations we had all those years.
In other words they were empirically more-or-less correct. That's what I was talking about in my first paragraph.
>Only if "previous dietary advice" was only all about fat, and only if it consisted of just saying "fat makes you fat".
I don't see the point of picking over the details of the example. Take plate tectonics. The scientific consensus used to be that the Earth's crust was not formed of separate moving plates. The current scientific consensus is exactly the opposite. If you have a concept of wrong according to which it's possible for neither of P and ¬P to be wrong, then I'm not sure where we can go from there.
- coldtea 11y ago>The scientific consensus used to be that the Earth's crust was not formed of separate moving plates. The current scientific consensus is exactly the opposite. If you have a concept of wrong according to which it's possible for neither of P and ¬P to be wrong, then I'm not sure where we can go from there. That's the whole point of Asimov's article - the relativity of wrong. The example he gives for this is not at all different from yours (earth being flat and earth being non-flat are also opposite propositions). So it's not like the "plate tectonics" examples changes anything in his argument. The argument is that P and ¬P can both be useful if the first could explain a phenomenon to the best degree available at a time, and the second to an even better degree available at a later time. In that sense P and ¬P are degrees of wrongness and truthness. His is the argument that "wrong" depends on utility, as there's usually no absolute match with the objective status universe (ding an sich), so we just have approximations with different degrees of wrongness.
- foldr 11y agoYep, that's what I said in the first paragraph of my original post. In purely empirical terms, scientific progress is usually quite conservative. However, if you look at the content of the theory, and not just the predictions that it makes, scientific progress looks much less conservative. In the case of the flat earth example, it is indeed true that the flat Earth theory was not totally wrong in the sense that it made some approximately correct predictions. However, it was totally wrong in its assertion that the Earth is flat -- it simply isn't.
- hyperpape 11y agoI think you're going too far here, both in saying something that sounds incorrect, and in reading things into the essay that I don't see there. There's no need to say that P and ¬P are ever both (somewhat) true, only that evaluating a scientific theory isn't just a matter of finding some single consequence of it to say "this prediction is false: REJECT" (a sort of crude Popperian picture). Instead, the theory should be tested on its overall explanatory power, ability to predict, etc, etc. For each statement the theory implies, that statement is either true or false. But considering two theories, each of which implies some falsehood, we may wish to say that one is still less wrong. I also didn't notice the sort of Kantian picture you allude to in the essay.
- coldtea 11y ago>I think you're going too far here, both in saying something that sounds incorrect, and in reading things into the essay that I don't see there. How so? Isn't the article's "earth is flat" / "earth is round" (the opposite), both being degrees of wrong (and thus true), a P and ¬P thing? >Instead, the theory should be tested on its overall explanatory power, ability to predict, etc, etc. Exactly. And, what the article says is that both P (flat) and ¬P (non-flat: round) had the best explanatory performance each at their time.
- rdc12 11y agoThis is the same as the example Asimov gave thou, plate tectonics being that the surface of the earth moves at imperceptible rate. That only over great time does this have any impact on the positioning of land masses. Instead of it being moving at a rate of zero (or static), it is moving at some tiny amount above zero.