3 ms·
> I know socialism doesn't work without either one of these articles. You should share this proof with everyone. I certainly would love to see concrete proof
by KirinDave 17y ago
> I know socialism doesn't work without either one of these articles.
You should share this proof with everyone. I certainly would love to see concrete proof for and against any general economic policies. The intricacies of such a proof would be fascinating in and of themselves, I'm sure.
And also, who was really critiquing religion here? The author is upset at people who are using incorrect information to reinforce an unsupported bias in their lives. He's clearly not Christian, but I don't think that he's arguing that this is a specific Christian belief or that Christians have a unique defect that makes it susceptible. It's just a matter of fact and coincidence that most people retelling this story are Christian Americans... their news has pushed this story harder and more loudly than any other.
My impression from the data you've given me so far: You think capitalism is better and you're not interested in arguments to the contrary. I cannot tell if you are being serious about socialism being obviously wrong or not.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI've found that arguing about socialism is like arguing about predicate logic: tedious and pointless if both parties don't get it. How many examples of failed socialist policies does it take to find a pattern? For some, no amount will ever do. And these are not hard sciences -- the best we have is empirical evidence, failed experiments from the past, not theory. So no, right now I am not interested in discussing the role of countless historical examples in forming a pattern. I was hoping for a nice, meaty historical piece in the rebuttal to the pilgrim article, but that's not what I found, sadly. But you guys can carry on. Socialism versus Capitalism has been done many, many, many times before, and it will be done many, many times again.
- gloob 17y agoHow many examples of failed socialist policies does it take to find a pattern? How many examples of failed capitalist policies does it take to find a pattern? On the assumption that we're defining socialism as "everything Stalin, Kim Jong Il, and Ceausescu did", I'll take a similar tack in the opposite direction and contend that capitalism is responsible for the American incursion into Vietnam, Watergate, and Abu Ghraib (since they were all carried out by a capitalist country). A couple of possible counterarguments to this would be (1) that individuals, not capitalism itself, are responsible for these events, and (2) that America isn't really capitalist and theory shows that they wouldn't happen in a truly capitalist country. Note that both of these counterarguments are the same as the ones used by the proponents of socialism, Marxism, etc., with the difference that "America" is replaced with "the USSR/Cuba/North Korea". There are good arguments to be made against socialism and similar policies. Your post does not contain any of them.