4 ms·
they tie you up with wikis, bug trackers, pull requests and a lot of other things around just git hosting that are difficult to transplant to anothe
by aaronbrethorst 11y ago
they tie you up with wikis, bug trackers, pull
requests and a lot of other things around just
git hosting that are difficult to transplant to
another service.
Are you saying that some people say GitHub should be avoided for GNU projects because it's too useful?
- worklogin 11y agoNo, if you read the exact sentence you quoted, it should be avoided because those value-adds are lock-ins that are hard to move to a new service.
- aaronbrethorst 11y agoNo one's forcing you to use GitHub's wikis, issue tracking, or pull request facilities. One would only use these features if they were useful. Hence my question.
- cha0s 11y agoEmbrace the usefulness! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend_and_extinguish http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend_and_extinguish
- jordigh 11y agoNo, but that's a common criticism of the GNU project, that we think anything useful should not be done. The overall issue with SaSS is this. Bit tl;dr, but worth reading it when you have the time: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/who-does-that-server-really-serve.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/who-does-that-server-really-s... In the private discussions I saw, there was some disagreement over whether Github is SaSS or not, but many felt like it was. (Btw, the official stance is that there is one GNU project with many packages, and all of these packages form part of the GNU operating system. So R, GIMP, Gnome, and Octave are GNU packages and part of the GNU project and operating system.)
- bonsai80 11y ago"tie you up" might have been better written as "lock you in". Those tools can certainly be made available through other means via free (as in freedom) software. It takes work in doing so and that's what Github is selling - ease and convenience. Github has obviously done a great job of making these tools useful and approachable. The point about having ultimate control over that data though is valid. Github might be able to mitigate some of these concerns with something like Google's "Data Liberation Front", providing a contractual agreement with users to make their data easily exportable if they choose to do so. Of course, even that may not be enough for some projects and for them it's a totally valid option to avoid github (and similar closed SaaS options).
- sytse 11y agoGitLab CEO here, we want to give people options to prevent lock in. GitLab CE already has a one click importer for all your GitHub.com repo's and issues. We're working on automatically importing your pull requests and wiki's too.
- thedaniel 11y agoDo you provide an export function as well, to prevent lock in?