3 ms·
"Webster remembers one industry Cassandra, Maurice Oberstein – who ran CBS and then Polygram in the UK – making a similar point. “He was the only one who went:
by jerf 11y ago
"Webster remembers one industry Cassandra, Maurice Oberstein – who ran CBS and then Polygram in the UK – making a similar point. “He was the only one who went: ‘We’re making a huge mistake. We’re putting studio-quality masters into the hands of people.’ And he was absolutely right in that respect. Once you made a CD with ones and zeroes it was only a matter of time before that was converted into something that was easily transferable.”"
Emphasis mine.
Well, the Loudness War fixed that problem right up, didn't it? Now CDs aren't "studio-quality masters" anymore.
- mark-r 11y agoOnce you had digital mastering and digital manipulation, the loudness wars would have happened no matter what the output medium. What I don't understand is how this appeals to the bean counters. Were any of the best-selling albums of all time noticeably louder than their peers?
- DanBC 11y agoLoud works for radio, which used to drive sales.
- 6581 11y agoMost radio stations use all sorts of sound processing anyway though (including ridiculous dynamic range compression) to make the station sound "better".
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoLoud on radio comes from boxes, not from a disc. If you have unremastered CDs of the top 100 selling albums of all time that were built before CDs, they have a lot of air in 'em. "Goodbye Yellow Brick Road", "Hotel California" and the Led Zep catalog all show this. There's just no good reason to overmodulate a CD. You have a volume control; use it.
- bsder 11y agoThe loudness wars were about CD changers. Radio always normalized anyway. You didn't want your CD sticking out as "quiet" when put in a 5 CD shuffle.
- lamby 11y ago> CDs aren't "studio-quality masters" anymore Well, not sure many studios are still using 16-bit 44.1kHz either... ;)
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoWow, I had never heard that about anyone in the music business. Amazing. But there is no way they were gonna pass on reselling all the back catalog one more time - at from $15 to $20 a pop retail. 16/44.1 is a studio quality master. The best practice to send a mix in is to use the same format as the end product unless the mastering engineer wants something different.
- gregsq 11y agoFilm is 24/48 so 16/44.1 isn't what you'd call a studio master in general. A lot of music used in film originates from 44.1k CD's but then you have up sampling to add to the workflow. 16/44.1k is becoming something of an anachronism.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoIt is certainly difficult to find 16 bit hardware. I bought a new 16 channel interface in 2013 and it basically doesn't work at 16 bit. I wonder if the drivers aren't broken. MP3s generally have a base sampling rate of 44.1 still. It is unfortunate that both CD and film were not at the same sampling rate. 24 bits is fine for tracking but it's overkill for the end delivery format. This is especially true since most audio on even Blu-Ray is lossy-encoded anyway. You can't hear it often, but the irony of "HD audio quality" is amusing.