3 ms·
I often read how household spending being down is bad, but why is that? Do we need so much stuff? If my wife and I have a one bedroom apartment, ride a bicycle
by CalRobert 11y ago
I often read how household spending being down is bad, but why is that? Do we need so much stuff? If my wife and I have a one bedroom apartment, ride a bicycle and a scooter to get around, and generally lead a relatively simple life does that make the world a worse place? We do spend money, but it usually goes towards plane tickets to interesting places and going out for a pint or two - things we both enjoy.
I just don't see what's wrong with not buying more crap. Our parents have giant houses, multiple cars, hot tubs, and all sorts of stuff, and that's great for them, but it gets old hearing that our lifestyle is bad for America.
- misterbwong 11y agoYou need to go one step further and ask WHO is it bad for. Is it good for us as individuals to spend less, save more, and live a generally less materialistic lifestyle? Arguably yes. Is it bad for the economy as a whole when all consumers act this way? That's a different question :)
- BenoitEssiambre 11y agoThat is not what this is about. More spending doesn't necessarily mean more consumer spending and less saving. Yes you can increase aggregate spending through consumer goods spending, but you can also increase spending and aggregate demand by having people buy more investments. You can spend and save at the same time. There are many ways to spend and save at the same time. You can buy something you are only going to need later, you can buy stocks in a business that will use the money to buy equipment and employ people, you can lend to a business that will buy equipment and employ people. This is all the economic equivalent of investing, the I in the GDP equation C+I+G+(X-M) The only thing you need to prevent is people and organisations sitting on idle cash or cash like investments. That's what destroys the economy. Anyways fiat is a fictitious form of saving on the aggregate. It doesn't produce anything and people accumulating it doesn't increase the amount of stuff they will be able to buy in the future on the whole. The point is to move the economy away from idle fiat and into consumption or investment.
- brc 11y ago>The only thing you need to prevent is people and organisations sitting on idle cash or cash like investments. That's what destroys the economy. Not true. Cash kept in banks is reinvested in the economy. If companies like Apple keep billions in the bank, it has the effect of lowering interest rates and therefore encouraging investment. Clarity in economic thought comes when this incorrect bit of Keynesian relic thinking is discarded.
- BenoitEssiambre 11y agoBanks are organisations, I include them in this, you need to prevent banks from not lending. >"it has the effect of lowering interest rates" Not when we are already at the zero lower bound. At the ZLB you need higher inflation targets for things to function properly.
- deelowe 11y agoIt's bad for MACROeconomics. A consumer based economy suffers when consumer spending is down. More saving and less spending may be good for the individual, but it's bad for the economy. It results in lower sales volumes for business, less lending for banks, and an over all "liquidity trap" where increases in cash simply go into investments which don't stimulate the economy. Over a long enough time period, this leads to deflation, which believe it or not is actually MUCH WORSE than inflation as it can be near impossible to recover from (see the great depression for examples).