4 ms·
What amazes me about VCs is how passive they are about the whole process. Why sit and wait for talent to come to you? Why not go out and hire the best people an
by danieltillett 11y ago
What amazes me about VCs is how passive they are about the whole process. Why sit and wait for talent to come to you? Why not go out and hire the best people and then put them to work with adequate funding and see what they come up with? If every start-up ends up pivoting as soon as they get funding why not bypass the whole process and just put a great group of people together and let them come up with something fantastic.
- ido 11y agoThey call those "entrepreneurs". I worked in several companies bootstrapped by very wealthy founders.
- danieltillett 11y agoIf the founders are wealthy is the company really bootstrapped, or just privately financed? If VCs think the idea is worthless and execution is everything why waste time listening to pitches? Just hire the best people able to execute, give them the money and get out of the way.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoThat's actual work though, and that would also tie them directly with any of their failures. Can't have that.
- danieltillett 11y agoIt is true that it would take more work, but surely the rewards would make it worth trying. I can understand following the current modelled you are one of the tier 1 VC firms, but if you are tier 2 or 3 you need to do something different to succeed.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- acabrahams 11y agoSounds like what EF already do in London (joinef.com) with technical grads.
- danieltillett 11y agoSort of, but ef is acting like a pre-accelerator. The money (1100 pounds a month) for three months is not really serious either. My idea was more go out and hire all the great people (they are not that hard to find, just hire), pay them well (none of this 50% of the market wage in return for 0.0002% of the company), and put them to work with the minimium of outside friction. If you went to hire talent with an offer of good pay, total freedom in business direction, minimal VC politics, and solid financial support you would be able to put together some amazing teams. On top of this you could give up listening to crazy pitches from spotty 22 year olds.
- mildbow 11y agoIdentifying the great people to hire is the problem. Note also that the definition of great is a function of (atleast) timing and domain knowledge as well as raw ability.
- danieltillett 11y agoIt is not that hard to identify the great people to hire if you are hiring people with a proven track record. I agree it is hard to identify which people with potential will be a success (ie the new graduates), but if you widen your search you should be able to identify those people who have actually built something great.
- malchow 11y agoThe best investors actively do this all day long. I know one who hosts his/her own 'career sessions' for selected Stanford students -- mostly to identify and build new teams after seeing interactions.
- michaelochurch 11y agoThere are plenty of great Stanford students but they're going to come to you. The purpose of an elite education (these days) is to give people the confidence to go out into the world. This means that the overlooked talent is probably not going to fit the "Stanford Wallflower" bill, but be somewhere that most VCs wouldn't deign to look. Driving across the street to Stanford "to identify and build new teams after seeing interactions" to scout talent isn't being proactive. It's what the rest of Sand Hill Road is already doing. If you're really serious about finding the best talent, broaden your search. Don't count the white Stanford males out, of course, but look in the "flyover" states, or for older programmers, or for women, or for parents who might be interested in programming because of the remote-work possibilities. Look outside of the US, even. VCs are good at telling the 7s Who Look Like Them apart from the 5s Who Look Like Them, and that's about where it ends. That makes them better at assessing talent than a great many in the business world, but they're missing out on an incredible amount of information.
- javajosh 11y ago>VCs are good at telling the 7s Who Look Like Them apart from the 5s Who Look Like Them... I don't understand this quip. Assuming you're talking about ability rather than attractiveness, it's odd that you leave out <5 or >7. Does that mean you think VCs have a blind spot for both superstars and low performers?
- michaelochurch 11y agoI thought that it was obvious that I was talking about ability. Why should it matter if the founders are attractive? VCs can probably tell a 5 apart from a 3, but it doesn't matter because neither a 3 nor a 5 is someone you want to fund. They can't tell a 7 from a 9, is what I'm saying. If they're not dealing with people of similar pedigree and experience, they may not be able to tell a 9 from a 5, even.
- jonas21 11y agoThe problem is in identifying the best people, especially when there might not be a strong correlation between things like academic performance or and entrepreneurial success. It seems like screening for people who can build an MVP and a compelling pitch deck could be one of the best ways to do this.
- danieltillett 11y agoi was not suggesting just recruiting the young with potential, but those people with a proven track record of getting things done. Engineers and designers that have years of proven success of building great products.