2 ms·
There's nothing special about a bank's business model that requires its profits to be taxed differently from those of other companies. Incidentally, your chara
by rahimnathwani 11y ago
There's nothing special about a bank's business model that requires its profits to be taxed differently from those of other companies.
Incidentally, your characterisation of banks as wholesale brokers of debt is not strictly true. Sure, banks do broker lending transactions between parties. Sure, they do sometimes act as servicers for paper which is held by other investors. However banks are, in the main, risk machines. They borrow money (on their own account) and lend it to others (on their own account). Depositors are their suppliers, and borrowers are their customers. In this activity, they are not brokers. They are wholesalers/retailers, just like other trading companies.
- cm2187 11y agoBut in this activity the interest they receive on their assets (their lending) is not a revenue. What is revenue to a bank is the different between the interest received and the interest paid plus any other fee. And by wholesale broker I also included retail deposits.
- rahimnathwani 11y agoWhat you have written is incorrect. For a bank, interest it receives on its assets IS revenue. The difference between the interest received and the interest paid is their _profit_. With regard to retail deposits, bank absolutely do not act as brokers. They are not middlemen. Depositors lend money to the bank. The liability shows up on the bank's balance sheet. If banks were acting as brokers, who is the principal on the other side of the deposit transaction? EDIT: Don't confuse the terms 'Revenue' and 'Net Revenue' when reading a bank's accounts. 'Net' has a meaning! EDIT 2: The words 'income' and 'revenue' are generally interchangeable. EDIT 3: I don't think we agree on the definition of the word 'broker'. When I say 'wholesaler', I mean someone who buys something with the intention of selling it at a higher price. When I say 'broker', I mean someone who brings together two parties, and is paid a commission by one or both parties, for his/her part in helping the two parties making a deal between themselves.
- cm2187 11y agoThat not the way I read a bank income statement. If we take the example of JPMorgan (p3): http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/ONE/239936797x0x820074/8e505f0e-2634-43f4-9831-18a285d6dfc6/JPMC-AR2014-Financial-Statements-Notes.pdf http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/ONE/239936797x0x82007... Revenue is defined as Non interest revenue (fees) plus interest income minus interest expense. This is typical for banks. And there is a reason for that. A bank is effectively a wholesale buyer (lender) and seller (borrower) of debt, through loans and deposits. The interest paid and received is essentially pass-through.