4 ms·
Banks are the only industry where tax deductibility actually makes sense, because a bank is essentially a wholesale broker of debt. You lend to the bank with yo
by cm2187 11y ago
Banks are the only industry where tax deductibility actually makes sense, because a bank is essentially a wholesale broker of debt. You lend to the bank with your current and saving account, it lends to the economy. Tax deductibility will not really result in the bank leveraging less, as the bank is not the ultimate payer of the interest. It will only make it more expensive to borrow from a bank. And the tax will be paid twice (first by the bank, then by the ultimate payer of the interest).
- XorNot 11y ago"Double taxation" is a fallacious argument, concocted by lobbyists for the rich to complain about the taxes that impact them personally. This comic summarizes it perfectly: http://i.imgur.com/Lw61YGs.gif http://i.imgur.com/Lw61YGs.gif
- ars 11y agoThat comic is idiotic. The dividend is not a payment for a service or purchase. It's simply a transfer of income someone earned. Taxing dividends would be like taxing ATM withdrawals. Tax the income not the withdrawal.
- rahimnathwani 11y agoInterestingly, the UK didn't used to tax dividends twice. This practice only started in 1999. Prior to that, dividends issued by UK companies were treated as if the recipient had already paid income tax on the amounts received. Only if the recipient was a higher rate taxpayer, were they on the hook for (just) the excess. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advance_corporation_tax http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advance_corporation_tax
- rahimnathwani 11y agoI'm not sure I understand your point. Let's say I run a lemonade stand as an individual, and this year the stand makes a profit of $100,000. Let's say individual income tax is 30%. I'd pay $30,000 tax, right? So I'd be left with $70,000 in my pocket. What if I had decided to set up the lemonade stand as a corporation instead? The corporation would pay some sort of profits tax (say 20%, so $20,000). There's now only $80,000 for me. But I have to pay personal tax of 30% of the $80k, so in this scenario I walk away with only $56k. Why should the total tax take in the two scenarios be different? How could I change the second scenario, to preserve the corporate structure, but maximise the money in my pocket?
- EliRivers 11y agoWhy should the total tax take in the two scenarios be different? Why shouldn't they? They are two different situations. Different situations can lead to different outcomes.
- rahimnathwani 11y agoThe two situations are economically identical. The economic activity is the same. The same amount of profit has been made in each case. EDIT: Yes, I realise that corporations have specific legal attributes/benefits. However, taxing their profits twice doesn't seem (i) fair, or (ii) likely to provide good incentives.
- EliRivers 11y agoA corporation is not just a label. A corporation carries a number of legal obligations and protections. If you want those legal obligations and protections, you pay the price for having them. If you don't want them, don't become a corporation. The fact that the situation appears economically identical is irrelevant, and actually they're not economically identical. Doing business with a corporation is very different to doing business with an individual, because of those obligations and protections. As another contrived example, stealing ten dollars from someone is economically identical to having that person gift you ten dollars, but they're not remotely the same thing.
- rahimnathwani 11y agoYou are right that we must pay the price for any legal protections afforded to corporations. I agree that, today, double taxation is part of that price. However, I believe that double taxation should _not_ be part of that price. The two examples I gave should be taxed in the same way. Sure, the corporation scenario may have some additional administration and filing fees, but I don't believe the poor shareholder should pay almost twice as much tax, just to get the protections afforded by a limited liability structure. You are right that the situations are not economically identical. That was not a useful over-simplification on my part.
- rahimnathwani 11y agoThere's nothing special about a bank's business model that requires its profits to be taxed differently from those of other companies. Incidentally, your characterisation of banks as wholesale brokers of debt is not strictly true. Sure, banks do broker lending transactions between parties. Sure, they do sometimes act as servicers for paper which is held by other investors. However banks are, in the main, risk machines. They borrow money (on their own account) and lend it to others (on their own account). Depositors are their suppliers, and borrowers are their customers. In this activity, they are not brokers. They are wholesalers/retailers, just like other trading companies.
- cm2187 11y agoBut in this activity the interest they receive on their assets (their lending) is not a revenue. What is revenue to a bank is the different between the interest received and the interest paid plus any other fee. And by wholesale broker I also included retail deposits.
- rahimnathwani 11y agoWhat you have written is incorrect. For a bank, interest it receives on its assets IS revenue. The difference between the interest received and the interest paid is their _profit_. With regard to retail deposits, bank absolutely do not act as brokers. They are not middlemen. Depositors lend money to the bank. The liability shows up on the bank's balance sheet. If banks were acting as brokers, who is the principal on the other side of the deposit transaction? EDIT: Don't confuse the terms 'Revenue' and 'Net Revenue' when reading a bank's accounts. 'Net' has a meaning! EDIT 2: The words 'income' and 'revenue' are generally interchangeable. EDIT 3: I don't think we agree on the definition of the word 'broker'. When I say 'wholesaler', I mean someone who buys something with the intention of selling it at a higher price. When I say 'broker', I mean someone who brings together two parties, and is paid a commission by one or both parties, for his/her part in helping the two parties making a deal between themselves.
- cm2187 11y ago