3 ms·
Will these have your branding on them? Because if they don't, then how will people confirm the credibility of the reviews? Kind of defeats the purpose of open h
by chrischen 17y ago
Will these have your branding on them? Because if they don't, then how will people confirm the credibility of the reviews? Kind of defeats the purpose of open honest reviews and not letting owners delete reviews if users don't know that.
With yelp, people know that these are reviews on a third-party site.
Also, I'd like to add that since users are embedding these reviews on their own sites', visitors will not know if owners tamper with the reviews with additional javascript. Having reviews on a third party site has its advantages.
- mattmaroon 17y agoI don't know what you've read about Yelp, but they certainly are not a model of credibility. Between rampant self-reviews (restaurateurs have been caught using dozens of fake accounts to give themselves glowing endorsements) and their protection racket sales tactic,s Yelp is no more credible than the customer testimonials in every PR article. Any advantages that could possibly come from the reviews being on a third-party site are outweighed tenfold by the inconvenience of having to go there.
- apsurd 17y agoThanks Chris for your feedback. Yes I plan to have a small logo for that exact reason, which would be linkable not to my home page, but to a clear outline of the program policy and assurance of at least "intended" credibility. Matt addressed some of the concerns about why relying on yelp is probably getting to be a bad idea. I do not intend to outright accuse yelp of anything since I don't have empirical evidence, but whether or not its true at least brings up the potential drawbacks in letting another company manage your reputation. Matt also brought up that its a tougher sell to have users give you feedback on a third-party site which IMO is especially true of yelp. Yelp is actually a reviewing "community" so you have to set up and account and jump through the usual hoops. Not all businesses cater to web-savvy "i-want-to-be-a-prolific-reviewer-online-" types of people. There are plenty of traditional businesses who's customers rarely go online, but if asked to submit a review through an email, would probably be ok do doing it. Hard to see an older 50-80 year old demographic signup for a "yelp" account, yes?