6 ms·
Tax-Free Debt: The great distortion
- melling 11y agoDoesn't the market just build in the tax deductions into the prices?
- pkaye 11y agoIf that is the case, there is no disadvantage to removing the tax deductions.
- justinzollars 11y agoIf this is the case, we should phase these deductions out.
- sksk 11y agoI would recommend that people actually read the referenced Economist articles instead of the blog: http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21651213-subsidies-make-borrowing-irresistible-need-be-phased-out-great-distortion http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21651213-subsidies-mak... and http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21651220-most-western-economies-sweeten-cost-borrowing-bad-idea-senseless-subsidy http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21651220-most-western... For those who don't have the patience to read more on this topic, the key argument is that debt creates perverse incentives. If you follow Basel II or III regulations, you will know how hard it has been for the regulators to convince the banks to increase their tier-1 capital. The banks are happy to pile on more debt rather than raise more equity capital (the purest form of capital) as debt is cheaper and comes with nice tax benefits. The financial crisis of 2008 was exacerbated because of leverage (another way of saying lots of debt). While this can certainly reduce leverage in the banking sector, the author raises the question of start-ups vs. big companies. Big companies have massive balance sheets and will generally be able to borrow at much better rates whether or not there is tax incentive. If an up and coming start-up is amazing, I am sure there will be 100s of equity investors who will be willing to throw money at it. I wouldn't worry about this impacting them. That said, this will not fly in the US. So much for logical reasoning.
- cm2187 11y agoBanks are the only industry where tax deductibility actually makes sense, because a bank is essentially a wholesale broker of debt. You lend to the bank with your current and saving account, it lends to the economy. Tax deductibility will not really result in the bank leveraging less, as the bank is not the ultimate payer of the interest. It will only make it more expensive to borrow from a bank. And the tax will be paid twice (first by the bank, then by the ultimate payer of the interest).
- XorNot 11y ago"Double taxation" is a fallacious argument, concocted by lobbyists for the rich to complain about the taxes that impact them personally. This comic summarizes it perfectly: http://i.imgur.com/Lw61YGs.gif http://i.imgur.com/Lw61YGs.gif
- ars 11y agoThat comic is idiotic. The dividend is not a payment for a service or purchase. It's simply a transfer of income someone earned. Taxing dividends would be like taxing ATM withdrawals. Tax the income not the withdrawal.
- rahimnathwani 11y agoInterestingly, the UK didn't used to tax dividends twice. This practice only started in 1999. Prior to that, dividends issued by UK companies were treated as if the recipient had already paid income tax on the amounts received. Only if the recipient was a higher rate taxpayer, were they on the hook for (just) the excess. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advance_corporation_tax http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advance_corporation_tax
- rahimnathwani 11y agoI'm not sure I understand your point. Let's say I run a lemonade stand as an individual, and this year the stand makes a profit of $100,000. Let's say individual income tax is 30%. I'd pay $30,000 tax, right? So I'd be left with $70,000 in my pocket. What if I had decided to set up the lemonade stand as a corporation instead? The corporation would pay some sort of profits tax (say 20%, so $20,000). There's now only $80,000 for me. But I have to pay personal tax of 30% of the $80k, so in this scenario I walk away with only $56k. Why should the total tax take in the two scenarios be different? How could I change the second scenario, to preserve the corporate structure, but maximise the money in my pocket?
- ksar 11y agoTax-deductible debt as it relates to financial engineering is what is tough to rationalize. For example, the primary function of a PE-fund is to buy ownership of a company by levering it up and then capturing tax shields (US debt subsidy in this article). This is where 99% of the value generated by a fund comes from. In my view, this is more or less a direct transfer of wealth from the taxpayer to the PE-fund.
- theseatoms 11y agoIs this true?
- ksar 11y agoYou could argue that the 'discipline of debt' imposed on the management of PE-bought companies improves operational efficiency - because they need to generate steady cash flow to delever the company. However, these guys lever to the hilt with tonnes of cheap debt for a reason, though it's cheap it still results in huge tax shields.
- jessaustin 11y agoHaving worked at a company in the throes of private equity management, I can affirm that such "improvement" is not a universal phenomenon. PE funds take baths too.
- hessenwolf 11y agoWhat does take a bath mean in this context? I keep hearing it.
- XorNot 11y agoWell when a company fails we also say it's "going under"...
- jessaustin 11y ago
- Animats 11y agoIt's significant that The Economist is endorsing this concept. It may now go mainstream. This is more of an issue for businesses than for individuals. Businesses get to choose how they obtain capital, and that decision is often driven by tax considerations. All the ways companies pay for capital - interest, dividends, and stock buybacks - should be taxed at the same rate. Right now, there's a huge tax bias in favor of debt. Borrowing for stock buybacks is a huge fraction of US corporate borrowing, and it's driven by tax considerations. That's effectively a very expensive subsidy program. Eliminating the tax benefits of debt has systemic advantages. When a company financed by equity goes under, its stockholders suffer, but the potential loss is bounded. As we learned in 2008, debt-financed failures cascade. Much M&A, private equity, and hedge fund activity is fuelled by the tax advantages of equity to debt conversion. Eliminate those, and much unnecessary financial activity goes away. The hedge fund industry will scream, but now that it's well known that hedge funds underperform the market while extracting huge fees, that's no big loss. This change shouldn't affect startup companies. Those are almost always equity funded. Nobody loans to a startup that will probably fail. (There are some startups with complex debt/equity/warrant deals which exist to get the tax benefits of debt with the potential upside of equity. That's a tax gimmick, not lending.) The overall effect is conservative. By removing a Government policy which distorts markets, we move back to a system where businesses are primarily equity-funded. It returns companies to their historical role as payers of dividends. It's a good time for this change to business financing. Interest rates are very low, so the tax impact is also low.
- MarkMc 11y agoOne thing I don't understand from the Economist article: Is there a difference between (a) borrowing money and (b) borrowing land or machinery? If a company cannot treat interest as a tax expense would that mean the cost of renting office space is also not allowed?
- saryant 11y agoI'm not an economist, but leasing an asset like land or machinery doesn't allow a company to lever up its balance sheet.
- tsotha 11y agoPersonally I don't see any reason to provide a mortgage interest deduction for homes, but any US politician who suggested removing it would be roundly ejected from office immediately, both because home buyers are used to the benefit and because it would align that politician against powerful interests (construction, banking, and the money managers in government). So as an intellectual exercise... yeah, sure. And there are probably deductions businesses take that could be curtailed. But politics is the art of the possible, and removing the mortgage interest deduction in the US ain't ever going to happen.
- olau 11y agoThat's why you need to be more sneaky about it. In Denmark you used to be able to deduct interest 100% as far as I'm aware. According to http://da.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rentefradrag http://da.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rentefradrag it's then been gradually decreased from 73% in 1987 to 32% in 2001. And there's a plan to decrease it further, although it is, as you point it, a really hot topic every time it comes up - "driving people from their homes" and similar headlines.
- olau 11y agoI should perhaps add that in Denmark there's an academic economic elite of researchers (with titles as "wise men", no kidding) that get a lot of attention from the press, and since the set of people elected to the parliament in many cases have a Master's degree in economic or state science where these people teach, their advice is taken really seriously. For instance, the current government which is nominally social-democratic did some pretty serious cuts to various tax-funded welfare programmes, on the advice of the wise men, to the dismay of their voters.
- tsotha 11y agoWe don't have group like that in the US. I'm not sure it would matter even if we did.
- hessenwolf 11y ago
- Marazan 11y agoA key thing missing from the blog post about the article is that to raise money instead of taking on debt companies would have more reason to issue equity instead or various types of convertible notes.
- cm2187 11y agoThe reason to do the same in the corporate world is that the debt bubble is not only a retail debt bubble. Companies and states are also overusing debt. LBOs are essentially leveraged tax arbitrage structures because tax deductibility gives a strong incentive to leverage, a large part of the economy is now overleveraged because of these structures. And we need to stop with this idea that more debt is a hammer for every problem.
- beefield 11y agoThe writer fails to understand that the debt interest costs are not comparable to business costs, but dividend payments on equity. Interest cost is a payment for capital, as is dividend. If debt is favored in taxation over equity, it causes the companies to be overleveraged, and I do not see what is the benefit for society from that. (Note that the capital structure of company does not in theory affect total value of business, see Modigliani & Miller)
- rahimnathwani 11y ago"Interest cost is a payment for capital, as is dividend." This is incorrect. Dividends are a distribution of money to those who already owned the money. There is no economic transaction taking place.
- dang 11y agoUrl changed from http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2015/05/28/economist-magazine-argues-against-tax-deductible-debt/ http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2015/05/28/economist-maga..., which points to this.