3 ms·
> Does that mean that ∫f(x)dx is f.(dx, dx, …) = f(x_0)·dx + f(x_1)·dx + f(x_2)·dx + … for all x in the domain? I think that that is what is meant, except that
by JadeNB 11y ago
> Does that mean that ∫f(x)dx is f.(dx, dx, …) = f(x_0)·dx + f(x_1)·dx + f(x_2)·dx + … for all x in the domain?
I think that that is what is meant, except that it's not clear what you mean by "for all `x` in the domain"—`x` occurs bound on both sides. Of course this interpretation requires that one understand it as a philosophy rather than a calculation; for example, as your explicit version points out, one really needs tag points spaced `dx` apart to define the inner product, and (absent infinitesimals) the result will be only an approximation to the true integral.
stephencanon (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9620263 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9620263) gives another interpretation that is unimpeachably mathematically correct, but (a) it is so nearly circular that I think it must be not what bandrami (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9616961 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9616961) meant, and (b) (perhaps more importantly) the unit there is built into the definition of the inner product itself, rather than being part of the second "inner multiplicand".
- bandrami 11y agoNo, stephencanon's comment is what I mean, and this may be an example of what my prof. meant that my students would not then be able to teach calculus. By that point (this course was "differential operators", 700-level stuff) we all had a decent intuition of what inner and outer products are. The prof's comment was that looking at f(x) as an infinite-dimensioned vector, there is a unit *-cube g(x)=1 of compatible dimensions that can produce an inner product f|g (I'm not going to hunt through my character map for the dot or the integral sign). That inner product is the same as Integral(f(x), dx). This was in analogy to the differential operator being the exterior ("wedge") product of a function and its field. The real point of the definition was relating y' and Integral(y) to div y and grad y: in y' you're going from vectors to tensors, and in Integral(y) you're going from vectors to scalars. Or, Integral(y) is a projection of y on some unit cube, and y' is finding the function of which y is the projection on an appropriate unit cube.