4 ms·
>The market for most types of human labor is soft in advanced economies, and getting softer. We don't grow the economy by assembling a huge workforce to do/buil
by eli_gottlieb 11y ago
>The market for most types of human labor is soft in advanced economies, and getting softer. We don't grow the economy by assembling a huge workforce to do/build something, we grow it when (relatively) tiny teams build a new tool, create a new market or disrupt an existing industry.
As hip as this statement sounds, what quantitative evidence do we have for it? I'd blame financialization before I'd blame computerization, simply because high-tech products and services simply don't account for that large a portion of GDP.
On the other hand, the mechanization thesis does seem to suit something like what happened in manufacturing: output stayed the same or went up, but employment dropped consistently or was shifted to cheap-labor countries. There, at least, experts have examined numbers.
But again, the other big set of examined numbers is about financialization, which has showed that as the portion of the economy devoted to finance went up, and the "output" of the financial sector went up, the productivity and output of the non-asset economy stagnated.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoI love the scare quotes on "output" because that's exactly it - the paper wealth that's escalating is very ephemeral. Until you know exactly how Google is a real company, it doesn't much look like one. And my experience is that explaining this can be a challenge. But, say, a textile worker in the 1950s had about as much marginal production as they do now. So the textile work goes to where that's good enough - for now. Eventually, it gets automated. I think what's really decoupling is price and value-as-utility. My Dad, born in the 1930s, had three shirts, two pairs of pants and at most two pairs of shoes until he went in the the military. That wasn't unusual. Now, I can buy a decent shirt for what I make in minutes. I think it was Megan McCardle who noticed that in the "Little House on the Prairie" books, they could not afford a third tin cup for Carrie, the baby. Yet the Ingalls were middle class for their time and place. That time was right before the big productivity boom in farming - from mechanization.
- cam_l 11y agoYeah, I think of the financialisation of society in the 90s & 00s as being a massive share dilution of the middle class. the wealth of the economy as a whole didn't grow much, but the number of shares in that economy did and were taken by one sector - massively devaluing everyone else's share.