4 ms·
> This is a clear case of free association. MIT does not wish to have any association with Lewin... Ha! Yes, I suspect you're right. But this isn't the reaso
by jessriedel 11y ago
> This is a clear case of free association. MIT does not wish to have any association with Lewin...
Ha! Yes, I suspect you're right. But this isn't the reason MIT gave. They said it was for the danger he posed.
> Remember, free speech ....is foremost a prohibition on government restraint on speech.
This is a very neutered and ahistoric conception of free speech. The actual reasoning that led folks to endorse things like the first amendment is certainly not restricted to just matters of law or government. It is a normative claim that applies, in particular, to private citizens dealing with each other. If this idea is foreign to you, I highly recommend reading John Stuart Mills' classic work on this, which is about a hundred pages and available free online.
http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/34901?msg=welcome_stranger http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/34901?msg=welcome_stranger
> Lewin actively sought out many women who were self-learning using his videos, including joining in with Facebook groups.
Very interesting (and creepy)! I didn't know. All the same hypotheticals go through, though.
> Ahmadinejad is not a professor at MIT
Neither Lewin nor Ahmadinejad should be professors at MIT -- Lewin even more so.
> Again, this is a free association question.
Again, I think you misunderstand the deep justification for the principle of freedom of speech, and how it interact with MIT's mission. After all, freedom of association would apply just as well to Ahmadinejad.
If MIT was in some business other than the pursuit of knowledge, your point could be fine.
- dalke 11y agoYes, they don't want to be associated with someone who might use that association to emotionally harm others. I don't see the contradiction. I don't understand your point about being 'ahistoric'. Private organizations are allowed to prohibit certain types of speech. That is part of what freedom of assembly means. Quoting Mills, it's the "freedom to unite for any purpose not involving harm to others". Or earlier in the same paragraph, "the principle [of expressing and publishing opinions] requires liberty of tastes and pursuits; of framing the plan of our life to suit our own character; of doing as we like". If we don't like someone else's opinion, we don't have to express it for them. Like I said, freedom of speech is on par with freedom of assembly. There can be a tension between them, certainly, but it's certainly not the case that freedom of speech historically trumps freedom of association. Otherwise, a Perl conference will be forced to accept talks about C#, Google would be forced to accept and forward unsolicited commercial email, etc. Quoting now from the Supreme Court in THOMAS v. COLLINS (1945): > It was not by accident or coincidence that the rights to freedom in speech and press were coupled in a single guaranty with the rights of the people peaceably to assemble and to petition for redress of grievances. All these, though not identical, are inseparable. They are cognate rights, cf. De Jonge v. Oregon, 299 U.S. 353, 364 , 57 S.Ct. 255, 259, and therefore are united in the First Article's assurance. Cf. 1 Annals of Congress 759-760. [323 U.S. 516, 531] Similarly from N. A. A. C. P. v. ALABAMA, (1958): > Effective advocacy of both public and private points of view, particularly controversial ones, is undeniably enhanced by group association, as this Court has more than once recognized by remarking upon the close nexus between the freedoms of speech and assembly. De Jonge v. Oregon, 299 U.S. 353, 364 ; Thomas v. Collins, 323 U.S. 516, 530 . It is beyond debate that freedom to engage in association for the advancement of beliefs and ideas is an inseparable aspect of the "liberty" assured by the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, which embraces freedom of speech. See Gitlow v. New York, 268 U.S. 652, 666 ; Palko v. Connecticut, 302 U.S. 319, 324 ; Cantwell v. Connecticut, 310 U.S. 296, 303 ; Staub v. City of Baxley, 355 U.S. 313, 321 . Of course, it is immaterial whether the beliefs sought to be advanced by association pertain to political, economic, religious or cultural matters, and state action which may have the [357 U.S. 449, 461] effect of curtailing the freedom to associate is subject to the closest scrutiny. How about you clarify to me what the freedom of assembly means, and its connections to the freedom of speech? Since the historical record seems to say they are aspects of the same sense of liberty.
- jessriedel 11y ago> Yes, they don't want to be associated with someone who might use that association to emotionally harm others. I don't see the contradiction. OK. I don't know how else to explain it. > Private organizations are allowed to prohibit certain types of speech. That is part of what freedom of assembly means. Sure, they are free to do this and no one should force them otherwise. However, if your mission is to pursue knowledge, then you should often engage publicly with people whose views you find repellant. (In other words, we are talking about a hypothetical imperative rather than a categorical one.) This is indeed MIT's mission, which is why MIT (and most universities) sometimes make the conscious choice to engage with despicable people in this way, even if they have a freedom of association not to. The connection to Mills is not that he thought people were required to always associate with unsavory individuals, it's that he thought two things: (1) People shouldn't punish others merely for having bad views, including non-violent forms of punishment like boycots. (2) Empirically, human brains are led to the best and most robust beliefs by engaging with bad ideas rather than by being shielded from them; insofar as exposure to bad beliefs leads them to be adopted by human, this is a failure of their reasoning and preparation, not a failure of someone else to prevent exposure. > If we don't like someone else's opinion, we don't have to express it for them. I never meant to imply otherwise. The rest of your comment seems to think I did. Sorry if I was unclear. > How about you clarify to me what the freedom of assembly means, and its connections to the freedom of speech? No time right now, unfortunately.