2 ms·
Its not a foregone conclusion that commodities will rise in price if everybody has a bit more money. The rich have a whole lot more money. So the influx may rai
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
Its not a foregone conclusion that commodities will rise in price if everybody has a bit more money. The rich have a whole lot more money. So the influx may raise prices, but never as much as to make the BI useless. In fact they'd have to go up infinitely to make any money useless, right?
And its entirely likely the money will be conjured up from nowhere - minted for the purpose. This solves two problems. One is that taxes need not be raised to cover the cost. The other is, it becomes a small builtin inflation that serves to redistribute wealth. That's a good thing in America at the moment.
And if the BI isn't universal, if its means-tested, then you're missing the point entirely. The testing of means is flawed, very expensive, and inaccurate. Its always gamed to disincentivize folks from getting a job, which is probably a bad thing. And it turns it into a patronizing system again, where big brother decides who's worthy.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Its not a foregone conclusion that commodities will rise in price if everybody has a bit more money. Yes, it pretty much is. If everyone has more money at t1 than at t0, and nothing else changes, then you've got more dollars chasing the same goods and you would expect that the price of goods would increase. > The rich have a whole lot more money. That's not relevant to anything. > So the influx may raise prices, but never as much as to make the BI useless. That's what I said: "The things disproportionately demanded by those who are better off with UBI will have some rise in prices (but not enough that they fail to be more affordable to those purchasing them in normal cases)" > And its entirely likely the money will be conjured up from nowhere - minted for the purpose. Every UBI proposal I've seen has called for it to be funded by some combination of replacing existed tax-funded programs and increased progressive taxation. So, as actually proposed, it would not be funded by money conjured from nowhere. (If it is, however, the expected effect on market-specific price levels is still the same as a tax-based funding mechanism, after you adjust for the increase in overall price levels resulting from the overall increase in the money supply in the "mint new money" approach.) > And if the BI isn't universal, if its means-tested, then you're missing the point entirely. That's fine, I didn't suggested doing that, so I don't see the relevance.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoThink about it like this: if you give everybody some money, but they already have 1000 X that much money in the bank, then prices don't go up much. The rich have a lot of money, and they're buying stuff too. They matter as much as anybody; no, they matter 100X as much as everybody else. All tax plans are of course entirely fictional of course. And as for means-testing, the line about limiting it to folks above/below a certain income certainly sounds like meanstesting. What else could that have meant? OH! I meant to respond to the parent comment. Sorry for the confusion!