2 ms·
I don't know why you're being downvoted. I truly enjoyed Jaynes' book, but I think you hit the mark. His theory is not falsifiable, and that's the biggest flaw.
by the_af 11y ago
I don't know why you're being downvoted. I truly enjoyed Jaynes' book, but I think you hit the mark. His theory is not falsifiable, and that's the biggest flaw. I don't think there's a single experiment we could make that could refute it, short of travelling back in time and... and I'm not even sure that would help. How would you check, upon meeting the ancient Greeks, whether they are bicameral? Definitely not by chatting with them, or even dissecting their brains!
I love the book, though. Even if you disagree with the premise, I really recommend you read it. It's an amazing (if inconclusive) thought experiment.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoThe trouble is that even if Jayne is right, none of the people who experienced life like this still exist. We've contaminated the pool of test subjects, 100%. This isn't the same as being non-falsifiable, we understand what resources would be required to test it... we just don't have them available. > How would you check, upon meeting the ancient Greeks, whether they are bicameral? Interviews. Observation. There would be communication anomalies. Some would no doubt claim these were merely translation errors, but it would become increasingly apparent that explanation was insufficient. It would probably filter through our preconcpcetions such that they were universally (and profoundly) mentally ill or defective. The big trouble here is, having met them, we might only have a few years to study them. I suspect that our form of consciousness might be contagious, especially to their younger demographic. So by the time we would almost start understanding it, it would be gone.