5 ms·
4) The reason why they did it is actually completely irrelevant. "I killed him because he slept with my wife" doesn't change the fact that you committed murder.
by zamalek 11y ago
4) The reason why they did it is actually completely irrelevant. "I killed him because he slept with my wife" doesn't change the fact that you committed murder.
Doesn't GPL have to say something about this? Wouldn't this mean that the adware would need to be open sourced?
Edit: The difference between murder and manslaughter has now been explained, multiple, multiple times. Manslaughter is still a crime and in that way it is still the same. The comparison was used as a device to elaborate why the reasoning was unimportant, the difference between murder and manslaughter isn't important within that context. Suffice to say, now that I have been corrected repeatedly over this nonsense, this would have been a better anecdote:
> "I killed him because he slept with my wife" doesn't change the fact that you killed someone.
- striking 11y ago(not totally relevant but) technically that would be a crime of passion murder, and in some cases would result in a charge of "Voluntary Manslaughter" rather than "First Degree Murder". [1] Reason does matter, sometimes. Although in this case, Sourceforge just needs to stop. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_(United_States_law)#Degrees_of_murder_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_(United_States_law)#Deg...
- zamalek 11y agoYeah the main point was that the justification doesn't change what was done.
- userbinator 11y agoDoesn't GPL have to say something about this? Wouldn't this mean that the adware would need to be open sourced? No. The adware is part of the installer, and is considered separate by the GPL: http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.en.html#GPLCompatInstaller http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.en.html#GPLCompatInstall...
- dalke 11y agoThe adware is not part of the GPL'ed code. It almost certainly counts as "mere aggregation". See http://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-2.0-faq.html#MereAggregation http://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-2.0-faq.html#Me... or http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.html#MereAggregation http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.html#MereAggregation .
- zamalek 11y agoAh, pity. It would have been nice to have a legal reason for them to take it down.
- dalke 11y agoThe main way I know of would be through trademark infringement. That's why there's GNU IceCat/IceWeasel - Firefox contains trademarked material. I believe Mozilla uses trademark precisely to prevent third-parties from including user-unfriendly components in "Firefox".
- qbrass 11y agohttp://slashdotmedia.com/terms-of-use/ http://slashdotmedia.com/terms-of-use/ (Sourceforge's TOS) "By sending or transmitting to us Content, or by posting such Content to any area of the Sites, you grant us and our designees a worldwide, non-exclusive, sub-licensable (through multiple tiers), assignable, royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable right to link to, reproduce, distribute (through multiple tiers), adapt, create derivative works of, publicly perform, publicly display, digitally perform or otherwise use such Content in any media now known or hereafter developed. You hereby grant the Company permission to display your logo, trademarks and company name on the Sites and in press and other public releases or filings. Further, by submitting Content to the Company, you acknowledge that you have the authority to grant such rights to the Company. PLEASE NOTE THAT YOU RETAIN OWNERSHIP OF ANY COPYRIGHTS, TRADEMARKS AND SERVICE MARKS IN ANY CONTENT YOU SUBMIT."
- dalke 11y ago
- coldtea 11y ago>4) The reason why they did it is actually completely irrelevant. "I killed him because he slept with my wife" doesn't change the fact that you committed murder. Hate, well, love to be pedantic, but it actually it does matter. Courts and society alike take the reason for a murder (e.g. self-defense, revenge because of having been abused, being crazy or intoxicated etc.) into consideration for less harsh sentences or even acquital.
- ulisesrmzroche 11y agoSelf defense maybe, though good luck, but the rest won't help you any of you get into that much trouble. especially intoxication, you certainly can't use that as your defense for murder.
- coldtea 11y agoYou'd be surprised: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intoxication_defense http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intoxication_defense
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoSelf defense, manslaughter, second degree, first degree... Intent and reason is quite important. It is the difference between receiving no punishment and receiving the death penalty (in places that still have it).
- zamalek 11y agoNotwithstanding that the intricate technicalities of killing someone was what I was going for at all, how did you miss the two other comments that repeated this information nearly an hour before yours? I get it. The anecdote had technical issues. Not-with-standing that being technically correct is not what anecdotes are about in the first place.
- true_religion 11y ago> how did you miss the two other comments that repeated this information nearly an hour before yours? One way this happens is.... people open HN, click on a few links to open them up in tabs, then get distracted by work or other things. An hour or two later, they don't refresh the page and just make comments based on what they see. I'm guilty of it too sometimes.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>how did you miss the two other comments that repeated this information nearly an hour before yours? Honestly. I respond as I read. I tend not to keep reading and then go back to respond. >Not-with-standing that being technically correct is not what anecdotes are about in the first place. This is more than a mere technicality. The whole issue of mens rea is that one's state of mind is a factor is how someone is judged for their actions. Your point, even without the analogy issue, is that the reason is irrelevant. That is simply not the case. Putting a security flaw in place to give the FBI a backdoor is vastly different than putting a security flaw in place due to poor coding. You may say they are both the same in that they both compromised security, but only one of these is backdooring and the damage to one's reputation is going to be different. Now, in this particular case, the reason isn't sufficient to warrant a different judgment. But that is because of the details of this case.