7 ms·
This is actually rather disturbing on multiple levels. Is there any actual basis for this science, or is the guy a crackpot? The article kinda seems vague on it
by DiabloD3 11y ago
This is actually rather disturbing on multiple levels. Is there any actual basis for this science, or is the guy a crackpot? The article kinda seems vague on it, which makes me think the guy straddles that fine line between insanity and genius.
I mean, I'm sitting here rather terrified that I can't comprehend such a state without saying everyone back then was 100% schizoid (or whatever you'd call this in modern psychological medicine), and could be fixed with a few pills (in theory, anyways).
I know HN frowns on macro memes and all, but http://goo.gl/5FQ0kI http://goo.gl/5FQ0kI, this is the only way I can currently describe my mental state.
- voidz 11y agoIt is not disturbing, you are disturbed. Ironic to me and others who do know the subject of this article. Maybe one day you will have the mind to comprehend, but, since you asked, as an example: "[...] in the case of problem-solving, creative or otherwise, we give our minds the information we need to work through, but we are helpless to force an answer. Instead it comes to us later, in the shower or on a walk. Jaynes told a neighbor that his theory finally gelled while he was watching ice moving on the St. John River. Something that we are not aware of does the work." Maybe you are trying too hard to grasp a concept that is not really about grasping, but rather about being. Sorry you had to ask your question in such a judgemental tone, though.
- jacobolus 11y ago> straddles that fine line between insanity and genius That sounds about right. In any case, I highly recommend reading Jaynes’s book for yourself. Daniel Dennett: “I think first it is very important to understand Julian Jaynes’ project to see a little bit more about what the whole shape of it is, and delay the barrage of nitpicking objections and criticisms until we have seen what the edifice as a whole is. After all, on the face of it, it is preposterous, and I have found that in talking with other philosophers my main task is to convince them to take it seriously when they are very reluctant to do this. I take it very seriously, [...]” http://www.julianjaynes.org/pdf/dennett_jaynes-software-archeology.pdf http://www.julianjaynes.org/pdf/dennett_jaynes-software-arch... Richard Dawkins: “either complete rubbish or a work of consummate genius, nothing in between.” (in The God Delusion) etc. (cf. http://www.julianjaynes.org/julian-jaynes-theory-quotes-reviews.php http://www.julianjaynes.org/julian-jaynes-theory-quotes-revi...) > I can't comprehend such a state without saying everyone back then was 100% schizoid Sounds more like a problem with “modern” models of consciousness and sanity, rather than a problem with past people. This was recently on Hacker News: http://priceonomics.com/how-culture-affects-hallucinations/ http://priceonomics.com/how-culture-affects-hallucinations/ Semi-related, I like this blog post: http://www.meltingasphalt.com/personhood-a-game-for-two-or-more-players/ http://www.meltingasphalt.com/personhood-a-game-for-two-or-m...
- andybak 11y agoThis is where the term 'Neurotypical' can be useful. Some people with some forms of (what are labelled) 'mental health conditions' protest that it's not a deficiency at all - just a different way of being. Certainly it's easy to sympathise with this for conditions such as high-functioning Asperger's, ADHD and even some manifestations of bi-polar. (Stephen Fry famously said that he wouldn't change this aspect of himself even if he could).
- mtrimpe 11y agoOr that they are inevitable results of mild neurological deficiencies; similar to e.g. dyslexia but more strongly stigmatized. If you believe that attribution of consciousness to only yourself is a culturally developed feature (which seems plausible given the existence of many mystics who don't seem to do so) then it is very possible that in some people the machinery that is required to do so doesn't work properly resulting in varying degrees of schizophrenia.
- digi_owl 11y agoOn the topic of Aspergers, i found a part of the article interesting. "As Jaynes saw it, a great deal of what is happening to you right now does not seem to be part of your consciousness until your attention is drawn to it. Could you feel the chair pressing against your back a moment ago? Or do you only feel it now, now that you have asked yourself that question?" A year or two ago i ran into an article that looked at autism/aspegers as "intense world" syndrome. This in that people with it do no shut out inputs that "neurotypicals" do by reflex. I think for someone with that the idea of not being aware of the chair is borderline preposterous. It may only be valid when "in the zone", fully engaged and focused on some task, be it programming, gaming, or perhaps a good book.
- Nadya 11y agoYou are now aware your tongue has weight and you can't find a comfortable place for it in your mouth. I don't see how your your brain censoring unnecessary sensory information is preposterous. But once its drawn to your attention - it can be hard to stop thinking about it and get it "filtered" again.
- andreasvc 11y agoWhat is disturbing, and what state are you referring to? Jaynes' theory is more aptly described as fringe science, something far from the mainstream but without any of the obvious shortcomings of "crackpottery". Personally I am a bit surprised by how most people are so dismissive of his theory. We really understand very little about consciousness and the human mind, and there's no archeological evidence that falsifies his theory, rather, it seems to provide support. > saying everyone back then was 100% schizoid [...], and could be fixed with a few pills (in theory, anyways). Not in theory and not in practice either. Psychiatry attempts to make symptoms go away, and we understand very little about how it does so. We know about neurotransmitters and genes that are implicated, but we don't have much more than such correlations. I think it's possible that everyone back then was 100% hearing voices and that it was adaptive at the time.
- dragontamer 11y agoAncient Sumerians had battle-tactics and formations around 3000 BC. Which suggest that the soldiers of Bronze-Age Sumeria were _professional_ soldiers. Their Lapis Lazuli mosaics have stood the test of time, and we can see these artifacts 5000 years later. Sumerians were a society, a true civilization with specialized jobs, training, and technology. You can't have battle tactics without the "conscious" year long practice with your kinsmen. We may not know what the Acient Sumerian's battle tactics were exactly (those artists weren't exactly... good... at drawing what they saw). But we know that they had formations, and it sorta looked like a Phalanx. (Big Shield + Spear with everyone lined up) ------------ Another obvious "consciousness" bit is the Code of Hammurabi. Dated to 1754 BC (or roughly 4000 years ago), it demonstrates that the ancient Babylonians did in fact have law. Kind-of-crappy law, but its law nonetheless. The Code of Hammurabi assigned justice to slanderers, thieves and murderers.
- the_af 11y ago> "Another obvious "consciousness" bit is the Code of Hammurabi. Dated to 1754 BC (or roughly 4000 years ago), it demonstrates that the ancient Babylonians did in fact have law." I recommend you read Jaynes' book, because it specifically addresses this. There is an entire chapter devoted to Hammurabi and his laws. If I remember correctly, he argues quite convincingly that Babylonians were indeed bicameral (surprisingly, in Jaynes' theory you don't need conscience to have laws, and the hallucinated words of your chieftain were the first "laws", which later gave way to the "voices of the gods"). I think according to Jaynes, Babylonia was already stretching it and bicameralism was starting to break down when meeting other civilizations. War is possible and even likely between smallish bicameral cultures; complex trade relations are way more difficult. Jaynes' definition of "conscience" is quite technical, mind you. To him it's a relatively sparse act of "narrative introspection". I totally buy that you don't need conscience at all for the most part of your life! You don't need conscience to act, or even learn in some cases! I think Jaynes was a crackpot. But his theory is a fascinating read nonetheless.
- fsloth 11y agoThe observation that conscious mind forms only a thin layer on top of our daily cognition is a fact, more or less I think. The special position that language holds on human neurological activity is a valuable notion. But the conclusions that are drawn from these on the evolution of the mind are more interesting than useful, IMO. "and could be fixed with a few pills (in theory, anyways)." What would you specifically fix if this condition existed? Not all human brains are alike, and many people suffer when their neurological structure does not fit societies norms and are forced to modulate their self just to fit into a square box.
- digi_owl 11y ago> The special position that language holds on human neurological activity is a valuable notion. Dunno. Apes seem quite capable of language once offered alternate modes of expression, like picking symbols on boards or screens.
- the_af 11y agoAren't those findings on apes heavily contested? I know there were a few cases of hoaxes/deluded researchers. Apes are quite capable of something, true, but is it language as we understand it?
- learc83 11y agoYou're correct, most linguists agree that what apes are capable of is not language.
- bweitzman 11y agoI don't think it is a at all a fact that the conscious mind forms a thin layer on top of our daily cognition. We are in position right now where we are explaining behaviors left and right but we have made absolutely zero progress in the scientific study of consciousness. If anything, we are getting closer and closer to showing that we are not conscious. Wouldn't that be an interesting result.
- alextgordon 11y agoI don't believe it is true. You would see some evidence of it, among the many isolated and recently contacted tribes. There are lots of people in the Papuan rainforest who only joined civilisation in living memory. So we don't need to guess what life was like "before", we can just ask.
- andreasvc 11y agoDo we have comprehensive observations on consciousness in recently contacted tribes? I believe we don't have evidence for or against the theory from recently contacted tribes. I read a book about the Piraha tribe and the observation that their simpler language correlates with their simpler world view was quite suggestive.
- sebastianconcpt 11y agoTry to answer this question: why Qualia exists and do you have it? what proof do we have that you are not a well implemented automata? how can we be sure you are not a philosophical zombie? what proof do we have that you are actually experiencing things inside you?
- delinka 11y agoI don't think it's any wackier than faith in a supernatural creator/messiah/teacher. Most of today's theologists do indeed try to answer the questions posed by those with a more critical mindset, and those answers get pretty wacky, IMO. See [1] and [2]. If ancient civilizations believed in supernatural beings, then it stands to reason that perhaps their idea of a conscience was these beings speaking in their heads. I feel like the only exceptionally strange idea in this article is that humans weren't self-aware until these beings decided to STFU. My own opinion is that we couldn't have organized into societies without self-awareness. And at some point, someone decided that societies needed rules, "higher purpose" was a bit abstract, so let's create beings to be feared ... and oh, yeah, that little voice in your head telling you not to do bad shit? The gods! 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transignification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transignification 2 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transubstantiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transubstantiation
- kefka 11y agoTry working with the occult for a year. Specifically chaos magic. It focuses on using science to verify and disqualify claims and what can be done, given that your sample size is inherently 1; yourself. There's something there, that's for sure. Don't believe me? You don't have to. Try it out yourself.
- digi_owl 11y agoHow do one account for placebo in all that? It seems to walk willingly into the traps that double blind testing is set up to avoid.
- kefka 11y agoThere really is no good answer to your question. You'd have to go down that path and experience it for yourself. Or you could trust someone else who is sensitive to these things... but you'll be in the same boat.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago
- tormeh 11y agoThe bicameral mind sounds a lot like how artificial neural networks work in machine learning. It's basically the "about-ness" problem from the standpoint of psychology, rather than computer science. When does something that can learn and compute become conscious? When can it think about a problem rather than act on training and instinct?
- gus_massa 11y agoI wish to simplify your question: Is there any actual basis for this? Or in other framework: I there an experiment that can prove that this theory is wrong? I this theory falsifiable? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability From the article: > A psychology based on rats in mazes rather than the human mind, Jaynes wrote, was “bad poetry disguised as science.” Ok, let's forget rats for a moment. Try to apply this to a closer relative: chimps Does this theory imply that chimps are conscious xor they have gods? (Or chimps are too dumb for any of them?)
- andreasvc 11y agoChimps don't have language, so they cannot be used to test this theory.
- the_af 11y agoI don't know why you're being downvoted. I truly enjoyed Jaynes' book, but I think you hit the mark. His theory is not falsifiable, and that's the biggest flaw. I don't think there's a single experiment we could make that could refute it, short of travelling back in time and... and I'm not even sure that would help. How would you check, upon meeting the ancient Greeks, whether they are bicameral? Definitely not by chatting with them, or even dissecting their brains! I love the book, though. Even if you disagree with the premise, I really recommend you read it. It's an amazing (if inconclusive) thought experiment.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoThe trouble is that even if Jayne is right, none of the people who experienced life like this still exist. We've contaminated the pool of test subjects, 100%. This isn't the same as being non-falsifiable, we understand what resources would be required to test it... we just don't have them available. > How would you check, upon meeting the ancient Greeks, whether they are bicameral? Interviews. Observation. There would be communication anomalies. Some would no doubt claim these were merely translation errors, but it would become increasingly apparent that explanation was insufficient. It would probably filter through our preconcpcetions such that they were universally (and profoundly) mentally ill or defective. The big trouble here is, having met them, we might only have a few years to study them. I suspect that our form of consciousness might be contagious, especially to their younger demographic. So by the time we would almost start understanding it, it would be gone.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoIf it were true, pills wouldn't have fixed it... consciousness would be some sort of contagious cultural norm, taught to children and so forth. Not sure what's disturbing about it. Many times in my life I've met people who seem to be able to say the right things at the right time, but it feels like they're only some sort of clever parrot that recognizes that repeating that phrase is moderately relevant without actually understanding it. Has that never happened to you?
- juliangregorian 11y agoNot to bag on artists but, sounds like a pretty apt description of the art world.
- anigbrowl 11y agoThat's quite reasonable. There's definitely an analytical/technical dimension to art (of whatever kind), but the whimsical/inspirational component is important as well. That's why you hear so much about getting to a 'flow' state where your own consciousness goes into a more passive mode and you become a conduit for the muse. When I'm writing I'm often taken aback by what my characters say or do; I'll sit down and think 'OK, I've realized X went here to look for Y, so Z - you go there and look up Y in order to learn more about X.' Then instead of being sensible Y and Z get into a huge fight and both end up worse off than before. I don't mean of course that they exist objectively in some parallel dimension or derive their existence from Platonic ideal forms (although either possibility is interesting to consider); certainly they're projections of my self and my knowledge about narrative structure that I cobble together retroactive narratives to explain. But it's not unusual to 'know' more about a character than one can consciously articulate to oneself, in the same way that we can reach out and catch a thrown ball faster than we can articulate the ballistic calculations involved in such a feat. So just as an athlete needs to get into the habit of catching or hitting a ball rather than thinking about its trajectory, as an artist you need to get into the habit of moving your body and whatever artistic tools you employ in a sort of mindless, passive fashion. If you think about it too much it's either contrived or you get stuck. You know that situation where you watch a movie and everything flows along smoothly, but after you get up and walk around you realize the plot didn't make any sense - things happened at the same sort of pace they do in many good stories, but only because they were organized that way in advance rather than for fundamental reasons of character. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Centipede%27s_Dilemma http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Centipede%27s_Dilemma
- jotm 11y agoYou speak with yourself inside your brain, right? And show yourself pictures, video and audio files that you stored around in there, commenting on them each time? So how is this any weirder? :-)
- digi_owl 11y ago> And show yourself pictures, video and audio files that you stored around in there, commenting on them each time? As best i can tell we don't so much replay a video file as recreate it using random bits of sound and imagery we find strewn about. This in turn makes witness testimony much less reliable than the weight it is current given in court would suggest.
- ThomPete 11y agoConsciousness is one of those areas where you probably can't validate scientifically what it really is because it's more than the sum of it's parts. So instead of thinking about whether it's scientifically validated I think it's helpful to think about it as a perspective and then ask yourself whether thats a more useful perspective on consciousness than the others out there. I happen to think his views are a better perspective than most others only maybe rivaled by Bateson.
- s_baby 11y ago>This is actually rather disturbing on multiple levels. Is there any actual basis for this science, or is the guy a crackpot? The article kinda seems vague on it, which makes me think the guy straddles that fine line between insanity and genius. Here's what we do know: 1) It's a fact that pre-modern humans didn't just believe in deities but interpreted their world through them. If you were Ancient Greek and feeling love it was because Eros or Aphrodite was causing it. This is true across cultures. Judaism has a saying about how there is an "Angel" behind every blade of grass. The saying is implying that there is an anthropomorphic entity behind every object and action in the world. 2) You see this anthropomorphic interpretation of the world at the pre-operational stage of child development. Toddlers anthropomorphize the world in a similar way which suggests that this way of seeing the world is not socialized but a biological stage most of us go through. With that said I don't know what a "Bicameral" mind is. People will have different ways to interpret these data points.
- anigbrowl 11y agoNobody knows; the conjecture is really too big to test, and we don't have reliable markers for a lot of psychiatric problems right now. I came across it some 20 years ago and have read it 8 or 10 times since. I don't believe it, but but I don't disbelieve it either - it's become a permanent part of my mental toolbox. Yes, it's quite a disorienting read at first, and indeed on subsequent readings.