4 ms·
> it's very likely this will result in raising prices for all commodities. Why is that? There wouldn't be any more money in circulation. It's not like a state
by alkonaut 11y ago
> it's very likely this will result in raising prices for all commodities.
Why is that? There wouldn't be any more money in circulation. It's not like a state would print money to supply basic income. It would have to be tax funded, so most likely other public spending would have to be reduced, and taxes would be increased.
If the basic income represents a progressive transfer from high-income to low-income (most likely) then you will see an income in spending simply due to the fact that high-income earners would probably save/invest the last $1000 rather than spending it on essentials such as food, but if the same money was distributed it is more likely to be spent. This is normally considered a good thing, (one of the most positive aspects of a progressive tax system).
- ekianjo 11y ago> Why is that? Because the market adjust prices based on an equilibrium between what people usually earn and how much they are willing to spend. If you increase the money supply (not talking about nation-wide, but individual base) then there is nothing preventing manufacturers from raising their prices up and take advantage of it, while still being fair ("after all, everyone has minimum income now so they should be able to afford it anyway"). Unless, you know, you have to fix the prices of commodities. And then, penuries and shortages occur. History likes to rhyme.
- conanbatt 11y agoPricing is decided mostly by supply and demand not by will. Your rent doesnt increase when you get a payraise and your landlord finds out about it. Food is a very competitive industry, and unless you are suggesting that to keep it balanced we need some people to not eat, its unlikely that people spending more money on food will raise food prices to a point where it is unattainable. I dont get this "prices go up" argument at all, is there a name to it? (dont say its inflation because that is related to money supply, not market supply/demand)
- MCRed 11y agoYes, it's called demand. And inflation is an example of it, you increase the money supply, then there are more dollars chasing a given commodity-- more demand for that commodity per dollar, or looked at the other way, more supply of dollars relate to that commodity. If we paid for this basic income via inflation -- increasing the money supply-- the result is that, for instance, food would go up. Not so much that it is "unattainable" as you point out, but it will go up a bit more than the net effect of the basic income, wiping it out, plus a bit more due to inefficiencies that always happen when you try to distort the market.
- learc83 11y ago>If we paid for this basic income via inflation -- increasing the money supply No one here is arguing that a basic income should be paid for through inflation. There is a difference between inflation and income redistribution. >but it will go up a bit more than the net effect of the basic income, wiping it out Yes, if we paid for it by inflation, but the argument is to pay for through some kind of income/wealth redistribution. Food should have basically the same effect, and you'll note that they haven't driven up the price of food a bit more than their net effect.
- MCRed 11y agoCurrently the government is spending via inflation far more than it takes in from taxes. So, if you want to add $3.6Trillion to the budget-- more than doubling it-- in order to give everyone in the USA $12k a year, it's going to have to come from somewhere.... and I don't think you can get that much by raising taxes. Since income from taxes is around $1.4T [1] you're talking about more than tripling those taxes. For many people who are on a lower income that alone will wipe out much of the improvement from basic income. And for people who have a lot more money, tripling income taxes will produce all kinds of consequences that lead to reduced tax income. (Laffer curve and all that.) For instance, I would simply move to another country, form a corporation there, and earn all my income thru that corporation. And I'm not even rich, but I'm currently giving up %20 of my income-- you start taking %60 and I consider that slavery. So, whether you intend to or not, you're talking about inflation... because you can't pass something like that size of a tax increase. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_budget#/media/File:U.S._Federal_Receipts_-_FY_2007.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_budget#/... Edit- I see you edited. Yes, food stamps have driven up the price of food, this is one of the things that's making it hard for people to make ends meet-- food is too expensive, and even for poor people their taxes are too high, not just income but all the built in taxes that show up in the price of food, etc, because the companies have to pay taxes, they have to pay their employees more so their employees can pay taxes, etc. Raising taxes raises prices too, because it raises costs for everybody. Price increases come from many factors, including supply vs demand, but also cost of production. And all income and corporate taxes, as well as burdensome regulations, increase the cost of production.
- nothrabannosir 11y agothere is nothing preventing manufacturers from raising their prices up and take advantage of it, while still being fair Yes, there is: Competition. Bread is now $1 a loaf. If everyone starts selling bread at $2 a loaf, and I can keep it at $1, I'll be making bank. Sure, for $0.01 to $0.02, that doesn't count. But UBI is not a lot of money; $1k / month, without any other welfare programs. It's not like everyone wins the lottery.
- MCRed 11y agoThe competition will not need to undercut to make bank... there is increased demand relative to supply, causing prices to rise, and the competition will like the higher prices as well. If premium breadco sells for $2.10 a loaf now and generic bread for $1.89, then possibly the new equilibrium will result in prices of $3.10 and $2.89. There's competition... but the new price has gone up. If generic bread kept its old price the demand would be so high that they couldn't supply it--- AND their costs are going to go up as well so they wouldn't be able to keep their old price anyway. We've seen this over and over as the government has inflated the dollar over the years. In fact, I think the argument could be made that the entire lack of recovery in the past 8 years is due to the level of inflation wiping out and gains from winding down the housing bubble.
- alkonaut 11y agoOn some products, there may be increased demand, but the idea is that the basic income should be small enough that those products are very essential (basic food, housing, ...). We would have to assume that people eat both before and after BI reform. From my perspective (inside an expansive welfare state) the idea of basic income is a simplification rather than an expansion of the welfare state. The de-facto minimum income in Sweden today is probably higher than the would-be unconditional basic income. Today, the "minimum income" in Sweden is earned by people on minimum pensions, or those who have been unemployed longer than the unemployment benefits last. The income they actually receive is a very complicated combination of at least four or five different programs (social assistance, minimum pensions, disability, unemployment benefits, housing support, government child support, ...). The total for a single parent is around what a full time US (federal) minimum wage job pays, and I don't even want to think about what the administration overhead cost is on that.
- tinco 11y agoAlthough I really like the idea of minimum income, elkanjos point has to be addressed. Just yesterday there was an article about trailer parks ownership. They will simply increase rent to what their clientele can afford. In the end you'll still be filling the deep pockets. Perhaps instead of providing minimum income or in addition to minimum income government should just compete in basic needs market. I.e. government provided low income housing with capped rent.
- learc83 11y agoThe lack of competition that allowed the trailer park owners to do that was caused by local government restrictions on building new trailer parks. Local governments artificially restricting the supply of affordable housing isn't necessarily going to be fixed by a basic income. However, in a normal market increased demand will drive up the price, and developers will move in to build more housing. The increase in supply will then drive down prices until they reach an equilibrium.
- alkonaut 11y ago> They will simply increase rent to what their clientele can afford I may be crazy but wouldn't one of the ideas of basic income be that, for example, more people would afford to not live in freaking trailer parks? Depending on how it was funded, there should be less demand for large houses and more demand for small houses and apartments, meaning more such housing should be built (thereby reducing the demand for trailer parks).
- tinco 11y agoIf anything it would increase the demand for trailer parks. The average rent of a trailer now if I read that article right is $400-$500, that's already half of your basic income. The income of someone who lives there is also around $1000/mo, so the only thing that would change is that there'd be more of them, so demand would increase and the rent would go up. I can't tell you why trailer parks are a thing in the U.S. In The Netherlands poor people simply live in apartment complexes. Though those are equally depressing. I can't remember ever seeing a serious apartment complex in the U.S. though. Only downtown with rich people in them. Perhaps I'm biased and have only seen richer parts.