12 ms·
> The increased cost for extending that type of benefit to everyone, while removing the bureaucracy of maintaining the existing programs (eligibility compliance
by ekianjo 11y ago
> The increased cost for extending that type of benefit to everyone, while removing the bureaucracy of maintaining the existing programs (eligibility compliance and case workers, etc.), is actually not as dramatic as it first seems.
You are missing one part, though. If you start giving cash for everyone, it's very likely this will result in raising prices for all commodities. And there you go for a another downward spiral, where you have to readjust the basic income every couple of years to make up for the inflated prices.
Ever heard of minimum wage? Yeah, that one did not work as expected either (and created massive unemployment when the threshold was set too high as well).
- SwellJoe 11y ago"Ever heard of minimum wage? Yeah, that one did not work as expected either (and created massive unemployment when the threshold was set too high as well)." Citation needed. Your assertions do not match my understanding of the facts about the result of the minimum wage. (Though I would have agreed with you ten years ago, a better understanding of it has altered my opinion significantly.)
- blumkvist 11y agoOr perhaps you read a bunch of pretty words that seem to make sense? They got citations and proper syllogisms and all that jazz. Communist rhetoric always makes sense. It makes sense to your feelings, at least.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoDon't equate communism with a minimum wage, that's just intellectually dishonest.
- blumkvist 11y agoSame rhetoric used by the same people. liberty, equality, fraternity and all that jazz. You just don't know human nature. Especially the low part of its spectrum.
- ekianjo 11y agoYou should not need a citation for anything here. Look at what unions do in general when they get powerful enough in a specific company - they enforce high salaries, protect jobs and protest against any reduction of personnel, making it very expensive for the management to keep the current staff, and very hesitant to hire more (increased costs vs fixed returns, and lack of flexibility to adjust the workforce vs the ups and downs of the company's economic activity). There's enough case studies out there about the pernicious effects of such policies - they should serve as a warning that you don't solve ANY economic issue with a single bullet.
- tinco 11y agoAre you a troll? Besides the sentence "you should not neer a citation" should never be uttered, you deflect criticism on an unfounded argument with another unfounded argument. Tour first comment was unduly down voted but this one is just blabber.
- MCRed 11y agoWhen you raise the minimum wage, you don't change any of the other aspects of the business affected by it. So, say you have 15 employees making $10 an hour to keep your company afloat. (Just to keep things simple ,this is about the logic of it.) Now the minimum wage goes up to $15. What are you going to do? You would be losing money with a %50 increase in your costs. Most likely what you will do is lay off 5 employees (The weakest 5) and keep the remaining 10-- but now they have to do the work of 15. Remember the alternative is closing the business and they all lose their jobs. Plus if some don't like the workload there are many people who just got laid off (you laid off 5) who would happily take their jobs. When you set a minimum wage- or engage in any kind of price fixing- you distort the market and historically that has always hurt the poorest people the most. Looked at another way, minimum wage is the wage below which you will be unemployed rather than allowed to work. A minimum wage is a penalty that keeps workers unemployed if they don't have sufficient marketable skills to overcome it. Imagine if the minimum wage was $100 an hour. How many of us would be unemployed? People seem to imagine that there's just a lot of money out there and the only reason that anyone might not have enough is that people are being greedy. This is zero sum theory, and it is not true in economics. It's nice to imagine that you're "foreign the rich people to give up the money they are hoarding"... but you're hitting businesses that are on the margins. What's the average margin for a business? IT's not the %50 that intel enjoys-- a grocery store maybe makes %3. What do you think a business that is clearing %3 net is going to do when you increase labor costs by %50? (in this example.) Edit: You can disagree with my position, or even find an error in my argument, but I'm tired of spending time explaining things and giving examples like this only to be downvoted for ideological reasons... constantly. Is a circle jerk what you really want HN to be? I don't think any rational person can say that my comment wasn't a quality explanation for the position.
- chrisbennet 11y agoI don't disagree with your argument. On the other hand... Currently, employers that pay a less than living wage are subsidized in effect - the government (tax payers) makes up the difference in the form of food stamps, healthcare, etc. Is it right that businesses should get subsidized labor?
- timClicks 11y agoThe economy is more dynamic than that. Sure, there will be short-term effects as the policy is rolled out, but new producers will enter the market to meet the increase the quantity demanded in the medium term. Also for pure commodities, producers are all price-takers. That means that price doesn't necessarily get driven upwards.
- alkonaut 11y ago> it's very likely this will result in raising prices for all commodities. Why is that? There wouldn't be any more money in circulation. It's not like a state would print money to supply basic income. It would have to be tax funded, so most likely other public spending would have to be reduced, and taxes would be increased. If the basic income represents a progressive transfer from high-income to low-income (most likely) then you will see an income in spending simply due to the fact that high-income earners would probably save/invest the last $1000 rather than spending it on essentials such as food, but if the same money was distributed it is more likely to be spent. This is normally considered a good thing, (one of the most positive aspects of a progressive tax system).
- ekianjo 11y ago> Why is that? Because the market adjust prices based on an equilibrium between what people usually earn and how much they are willing to spend. If you increase the money supply (not talking about nation-wide, but individual base) then there is nothing preventing manufacturers from raising their prices up and take advantage of it, while still being fair ("after all, everyone has minimum income now so they should be able to afford it anyway"). Unless, you know, you have to fix the prices of commodities. And then, penuries and shortages occur. History likes to rhyme.
- conanbatt 11y agoPricing is decided mostly by supply and demand not by will. Your rent doesnt increase when you get a payraise and your landlord finds out about it. Food is a very competitive industry, and unless you are suggesting that to keep it balanced we need some people to not eat, its unlikely that people spending more money on food will raise food prices to a point where it is unattainable. I dont get this "prices go up" argument at all, is there a name to it? (dont say its inflation because that is related to money supply, not market supply/demand)
- MCRed 11y agoYes, it's called demand. And inflation is an example of it, you increase the money supply, then there are more dollars chasing a given commodity-- more demand for that commodity per dollar, or looked at the other way, more supply of dollars relate to that commodity. If we paid for this basic income via inflation -- increasing the money supply-- the result is that, for instance, food would go up. Not so much that it is "unattainable" as you point out, but it will go up a bit more than the net effect of the basic income, wiping it out, plus a bit more due to inefficiencies that always happen when you try to distort the market.
- belorn 11y ago> raising prices for all commodities If one takes a look at prices in each century, prices for each type of commodity vary a lot. For example, in the 1960 you could rent a house where I live for the same price you paid buying 5L milk. Since then the cheapest rents has gone up by factor of thousands, but milk has only gone up by factor of 8. During that time period, many reforms has happen including minimum wages, the strong middle class, and many efforts to reduces poverty.
- ekianjo 11y ago> in the 1960 you could rent a house where I live for the same price you paid buying 5L milk. Really? Then your 5L milk must have been seriously overpriced, or nobody wanted to live wherever that was.
- learc83 11y agoYou're forgetting about competition. Let's say that every low wage worker becomes suddenly 10% more productive so they start making 10% more money. Would prices all suddenly rise 10% so that none of the workers would see any benefit? This isn't the same as inflation, and will be handled by competitive forces in the market.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> You are missing one part, though. If you start giving cash for everyone, it's very likely this will result in raising prices for all commodities. Only if you aren't taking cash from someone to pay for it; UBI doesn't conjure money from nowhere, it redistributes it. The things disproportionately demanded by those who are better off with UBI will have some rise in prices (but not enough that they fail to be more affordable to those purchasing them in normal cases) and the things disproportionately demanded by those who are worse off will have some decline in prices. > And there you go for a another downward spiral, where you have to readjust the basic income every couple of years to make up for the inflated prices. What you probably want to with BI isn't target a particular standard of living, but target just below the inflation tipping point set by production technology and market factors, where BI is just below the level where it would lead to runaway inflation because of people leaving the workforce reducing supply (the real inflation danger, rather than redistribution of income spiking demand). This is sort of a fiscal version of what central banks do for monetary policy in managing interest rates. (BI is essentially self-limiting to this point in the long-run, in that if you don't tail-chase by increasing nominal amount inflation will drive the value of BI down to the sustainable level. But there's lots of disruption in that adjustment, so if you are going to have BI, you want to actively manage it to avoid overshooting by too much and to correct more quickly than inflation would correct it.) The resulting standard of living that is sustainable with BI probably won't be what most BI advocates would like to see anytime soon, because production won't support it; but it should rise with advances in technology.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIts not a foregone conclusion that commodities will rise in price if everybody has a bit more money. The rich have a whole lot more money. So the influx may raise prices, but never as much as to make the BI useless. In fact they'd have to go up infinitely to make any money useless, right? And its entirely likely the money will be conjured up from nowhere - minted for the purpose. This solves two problems. One is that taxes need not be raised to cover the cost. The other is, it becomes a small builtin inflation that serves to redistribute wealth. That's a good thing in America at the moment. And if the BI isn't universal, if its means-tested, then you're missing the point entirely. The testing of means is flawed, very expensive, and inaccurate. Its always gamed to disincentivize folks from getting a job, which is probably a bad thing. And it turns it into a patronizing system again, where big brother decides who's worthy.