12 ms·
Why Should We Support the Idea of an Unconditional Basic Income?
- AreaGuy 11y ago$12k per year x 320M people = $3.84 trillion, which is 22.9% of annual GDP. That's a pretty steep price tag for a thousand dollars a month.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- akhatri_aus 11y agoI see all the arguments for it, but I always find this to be the argument against it which I believe would be the issue myself. If one had basic income why would they need to work? The incentives favour against the need to work. That income could be saved up and used in countries where the PPP value is much higher. Or just live and not work (which would decrease tax revenues forth). If people started to work less the basic income scheme would not have a source from tax and it spirals down GDP. I keep bringing this up, but no one here likes to give a decent explanation as to why this will not be the case.
- c22 11y agoWhy do people work at non entry-level jobs now?
- akhatri_aus 11y agoI'm not looking at it from that point of view, people need to obviously get good jobs. Take away all those 'entry level jobs' and this will decrease GDP no? If the GDP decreases this will decrease tax revenue? And will this not decrease resources available for next years BI? If they have less BI next year there's less spending & less GDP next year too.. and it continues spiralling down. This is far from the claim that BI will have no chance of decreasing GDP It's all well and good to make lives better, what about the long run? This would solve it for a year or two what then?
- conanbatt 11y agoPeople stopping to work does not necessarily mean GDP reduces. Precisely because they still have money to spend, GDP will almost surely go up. Maybe you are thinking of amount of hours worked, that would go down, but that does not mean productivity, or quality of work, or amount of services and goods. If only 10% stop doing minimum wages and go to school, and pursue a typical corporate carrier, and make 10 times minimum wage, the offset of the 90% not working minimum jobs anymore would be completely offset. Not to mention that people needing to get a job within 2 or 3 days pick terrible jobs with no future, so those that dont go to school will still be able to pick jobs better.
- learc83 11y agoThere's no way to answer these questions through thought experiments, you have to look at the available data. There have been several direct basic income experiments, and many other situations that provide relevant data (Native American casino profit distributions for example). Obviously we need more experiments, but the data we have shows that unemployment tends to go down not up. >Take away all those 'entry level jobs' and this will decrease GDP no? Most of the entry level jobs your talking about are being automated away regardless of whether we have a basic income. But lets remove automation from the equation and assume no increased automation over the next few decades. You're ignoring the second order effects of a basic income. People who make less than $12,000 a year will definitely make more money, and people who make less than $50,000 or so (whatever the break even point is) who keep working the same amount will also make more money. People in lower income brackets tend to spend their money directly on consumption--this will directly increase GDP. The data shows that the increase in GDP due to increased spending among the lower income people who make more money each month will likely offset any decreased spending from people who are making less money each month as a result of a basic income plan (either as a result of working less, or paying higher taxes).
- baddox 11y agoBecause they are much more enjoyable jobs and because they pay more.
- conanbatt 11y agoTHe incentives work against crappy jobs and low paid work, otherwise working is extra money: that's a pretty big incentive. EVeryone that makes more than 1k dollars a month now would keep working to not see their income substantially diminish. Those that get abuse from work, and minimum wage might consider doing something else. Which is a step forward.
- akhatri_aus 11y agoWho would do those jobs? And who would pay for the tax revenue lost when the production those jobs create disappears to fund the BI going forward? Also, because you'll say people will work on better jobs and make more production how do you know they'll do this: If they have the income they need why would someone work and say not save it and spend it in a 3rd world country where everything is cheaper? Its so likely it creates a cycle of poverty.
- conanbatt 11y agoLikely the same people, but with a large salary bonus! If you agree or find reasonable that the incentive to "not work" of BI affects the lowest paying jobs the most, lets go around a few cases. 1) Automatable-minimum wage jobs: today they are not replaced by machinery because its either expensive or through social concern (i.e. Walmart doesnt fire all the cashiers and replace them with automatic ones because of many political, social and some economic measures). In the world today such automation is not pursued because of its consequences and the marginal profit. If these people stop working, we would quikcly start finding automatic solutions. Bartending, cashiers, some construction, product assembly etc. I would expect these jobs to dissapear from human hands. 2) Non-automatable jobs: if the minimum wage people drop jobs that are too hard to automate or require a human touch (retail sales, nannies/child care, cleaning?, Garbage management, etc.) lots of people would drop out, which would reduce supply. So income would increase a lot for those that still do those jobs. TLDR; decreased supply would increase wages and let this work still happen but it would be more expensive for businesses, and it would push automation.
- c22 11y agoIt's possible that any jobs that no one would do under these conditions are jobs that are not necessary. If the jobs are necessary and still no one is willing to do them then they're probably currently vastly undervalued.
- IanCal 11y ago> If one had basic income why would they need to work? Because people want more than $12k/year can buy? Many people here do contract work, how many of them stop once they've earned $12k/year? Did you read the article? There is a section on this. You may disagree with the analysis, but we should really start from what's actually being argued.
- akhatri_aus 11y agoI read the article and the reddit posts and follow /r/basicincome. I see how it can help someone this year and next year but I clearly see this vicious cycle it can create over a decade where things get much worse and probably actual poverty instead.
- fizzbatter 11y agoI'm not going to pretend to know the complexities of this type of issue, so don't infer too much from my following comment.. With that said, specifically replying to your comment: I would work, because the income levels i've seen in this thread ($1k/m) would barely be enough to live on. Hell, my existing debt alone (car), and current housing cost, keep me working. The idea of having to sell nearly everything to survive on the base income is not something i enjoy. Furthermore, even if i did end up at the base income after selling most of my more expensive cost-laden possessions, most people enjoy having money to purchase technology, entertainment, etc. With that said, i still love the idea of a base income. Knowing that if you fell out of work, ill, or whatever - you could still live? That you wouldn't go homeless? That really feels like a .. positive, proud of my country sort of thing. Again, i'm not claiming that any of this would work, or that i know anything. I'm simply replying to your question, from a personal standpoint. :)
- akhatri_aus 11y agoI would like basic income too! It is awesome I'd have more money in my pocket. $1000 a month is lots of money to live off elsewhere. It's easy to save by living a bit shabbily for a while. Not everyone will see it that way they should work more. I'm content with very little. I don't want to be homeless or stuck when I'm sick. But I also don't want to be living in poverty in 20-30 years time which is potentially a big problem with BI due to the vicious cycle it would create with decreasing tax revenues.
- nightski 11y agoI'd probably use it to work on personal projects for 12 months at a time after doing consulting rounds.
- Atropos 11y agoThe "not going homeless" already exists in European welfare states, you do not need Basic Income for that. The main difference with basic income is that it would be paid to people who could work, but choose not to. This might not make a difference in most cases, but the edge cases could be really expensive: If you are 63 and can retire at 65, wouldn't basic income give you an incentive to travel the world for 2 years? Same for a high school student delaying college for 1 or 2 or 3 years...
- bandrami 11y agoIf one had basic income why would they need to work? Why do you want people to work? Is there a stack of widgets going unmade that desperately needs to be made? Are we fighting a two-ocean war and I missed it? Right now half of the country is trying to work and there aren't enough jobs for them. It's 2015. What the hell was the point of the past century of technological improvement if we all still have to have jobs our whole adult lives?
- spotman 11y agoAgreed. more and more jobs are being automated and going away. Both in big ways and smaller ones. Heck sometimes as a programmer I have bad feelings about making things more efficient for humans, thereby requiring less of them. In my career there has many projects that fit that description. This is a complex idea, not without a large amount of challenges. However as a citizen and programmer, I would rather see more things being automated, and instead of more unemployment, people could either not work, or find work they are more passionate about. Just imagine if everyone that decided they want to not sit around all day, actually was working on something they were passionate about.
- bandrami 11y agoThat's how I feel too. If there were a social dividend (which I think is a better term for a minimum income), then people would find a lot more useful things to do with their time than either the market or a government program could find. I just completely don't buy the "people wouldn't work" thing. Yes, you'd probably have to pay some menial work more to motivate people to do it (or, even better, spur technological development to automate that), but that's a feature, not a bug.
- IanCal 11y agoI don't think we can claim that distributing money amongst people would definitely decrease spending on goods and services.
- nightski 11y agoGDP is value added. If there are less people working, I'd hope that value added would go down.
- learc83 11y agoWhat about a situation where fewer people are working more productively?
- nightski 11y agoWouldn't that be orthogonal to basic income? i.e. You'd get that anyways so it would cancel out?
- learc83 11y agoNo way to know without looking at the data, but I can see a few methods where a basic income would increase productivity. One talked about in the article is that workers who choose to work, tend to work harder/more productively than workers who are forced. The whole point is almost moot though because the data in basic income experiments show that employment rates tend to go up not down.
- hurin 11y agoIf you'd actually bothered to read the article you'd see that in the pilot project productivity went up. Unemployment dropped as well, from 60% to 45%, and there was a 29% increase in average earned income, excluding the basic income grant. Also from the wiki link posted by OP: As published in a recent report, "All those dollars low-wage workers spend create an economic ripple effec. Every extra dollar going into the pockets of low-wage workers, standard economic multiplier models tell us, adds about $1.21 to the national economy. Every extra dollar going into the pockets of a high-income American, by contrast, only adds about 39 cents to the GDP." There could be statistics that support the argument that you are making as well but I don't think that: > "I'd have to imagine..." without any references to support your statement contribute anything meaningful to the discussion.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vlasev 11y agoPlease take a look at the FAQ[1] on reddit and perhaps at this article[2] about calculating whether USA can afford BI. [1]: http://en.reddit.com/r/basicincome/wiki/index http://en.reddit.com/r/basicincome/wiki/index [2]: http://www.economonitor.com/dolanecon/2014/01/13/could-we-afford-a-universal-basic-income/ http://www.economonitor.com/dolanecon/2014/01/13/could-we-af...
- conanbatt 11y agoDepends on how that income gets taxed. At a certain level of income, the gains of basic income are lost to extra taxation. However you always know that if you get fired you have a safety net, so it provides value to you even if you get 0$ net effect.
- IanCal 11y agoThat is a rather trivial analysis that assumes a system where everyone, regardless of income, got $12k more than they would otherwise. It would be easy to set a tax system such that people got $12k as a minimum, but those who earned (say) $20k received $6k and by $50k there was no increase. I'm not suggesting a curve with those figures, that is purely for an example.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hypersoar 11y agoFirst of all, you're only going to pay the adults. That eliminates about a quarter of the population. Second of all, you're still going to collect taxes, so many people will just have the income taxed back. Say, only people below median income end up keeping the money. This cuts the figure down to 1.44 trillion. This is still a lot (we currently spend about $850 billion on social security, which would presumably be replaced by basic income), but it's not unmanageable.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rmc 11y agoA lot of that money will be spent, going back into the economy.
- graycat 11y agoBecause with more automation, if we don't, then the population will shrink, in principle to zero.
- cm2187 11y agoI always found the idea interesting, at the condition that we suppress all other forms of benefits. It is a simple and elegant way to solve the welfare trap and it also would be easier and cheaper to manage than the layers of benefits from various gvt agencies. To me there are only two real risks. First the idea that this will lead more people to stop working instead of less, which would be counterproductive. And I find it worrying that the counter-argument is "people are working too hard anyway". It is impossible to guess what would happen but as all former communist countries know, it is not fun to have grand economic ideas experimented on a live population. The second risk is that this could work in a closed society like Japan. But most western countries have mass immigration and such a system wouldn't survive very long the abuse it would inevitably trigger in an open society.
- hurin 11y agoYou couldn't actually not work in former socialist countries though. At least in the Soviet Union this was actively persecuted. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parasitism_%28social_offense%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parasitism_%28social_offense%2...) But I do think think that countries which offer a great deal of socialized benefits (such as Finland, Sweden etc.) have a significant problem with a unemployment in the youngest generation of the labor force.
- cm2187 11y agoCall me old fashion but a system that relies on coercion to get people to work isn't viable in my mind.
- proveanegative 11y agoThat is not old fashioned at all. What systems to get people to work do not rely on coercion? Even nature, which got us to work on the first place, did so by coercion. The only way we can make a society more accommodating is to change the type of coercion to a more gentle one. I.e., instead of working to avoid starvation and being eaten by wild animals people now work to avoid going into debt, losing their preferred place to live and having to rely on food stamps (at least in the US). In a society with basic income they would be coerced to work though social pressure and the desire to have nice things. (Edit: The latter may seem like an intrinsic motivation but in a society with advertising it is one that is actively generated. Advertising may actually gain a new, vital role in getting people to work if a basic income program is implemented.)
- cnsbwkf9385 11y agoThe question is whether the money comes out of existing spending or is in addition to it. There's no reason that it couldn't be entirely sourced from existing spending (~36%+ of GDP in US, $6.2T).
- jakozaur 11y agoOne of the better article on subject. It's affordable, though it implies new huge tax. Like tax on land. Though not sure if people would support that, once they saw the bill for their land. Changing status quo is hard. Though I would suggest that universal free healthcare is some form of basic income. Maybe let's do it first? Another less hardcore version is to expand http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_income_tax_credit http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_income_tax_credit E.g. Tax rate is negative on initial amount. E.g. You earn $2k and get additional $200 tax refund.
- sampo 11y ago> it implies new huge tax There are countries (especially Northern Europe) that already spend a large amount of money for unemployment and social benefits. In those countries the basic income could be implemented in a cost-neutral manner, just refactoring how the the sum of money equal to the present benefits, is allotted.
- jakozaur 11y agoYes, but in USA it wouldn't be possible. E.g. Total welfare spending in 2015 is $454.3 bln / 318 mln population ~= 1428 $/person/year. That's equivalent of basic income 119 $/month. Want to get to 1000 $/month? Need to increase welfare spending 10 fold. http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/us_welfare_spending_40.html http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/us_welfare_spending_40.h... People who get larger number use also pension or health care money. Though I don't think it is a good idea or other people would support that.
- sampo 11y agoWow your math sucks. First let's take only adults, so it's 230 million, not 318 million population. And then, let's say for people who earn more than $30 000, or something like that, per year, we increase their taxes the amount equivalent to what basic income would increase their earnings. Now, I am unsure how to estimate the size of this population, because for some reason I easily find only US household income distributions, not distributions per people. But let's guess this removes 60% of the adult population. So we are left with something like 90 million. And now we do your calculation: $454.3 bln / 318 = $5000/person/year, or $420/month. Want to get close to 1000 $/month? Need to increase welfare spending 2-fold
- Qantourisc 11y agoThe only risk in my opinion is if to little people still pick up a job to satisfy the need for all. Also the basic income should need to be basic, so there is some insensitive to work (at least a little). Can be adjusted of course to compensate. IMPORTANT: legal and medical support has to be free for this to not cause epic issues. (And maybe some others I forgot.)
- jbb555 11y agoGive me $1000 a month and I'd be able to retire. I wouldn't be rich but with savings and so on I'd be able to manage. So it would cost perhaps $30000 more than that in lost income taxes too as well as lost productivity. I imagine very many people would do this. The whole whole idea is stupid.
- sjtrny 11y agoAnd someone younger than you without savings would step in to fill your role. Youth unemployment in first world countries is very high right now.
- zxyzzxxx 11y agoI imagine the idea is great and most people are not like you. But that is just my imagination. On the other hand, the article presents very good arguments for the system and why would it work.
- noonespecial 11y agoI would too. I'd do so immediately. And what would I do with all that leisure time? I'd teach the local children robotics with Arduinos and RasPis, just like I do now with every scrap of my meager free-time only then I'd get to do it every day. Imagine how impoverished the world would become if thousands like me took to a life of such mooching!
- dbenhur 11y agoThe more of you who take this deal, the better I and everyone else is. You're so uninvested in what you do for a living you'd stop for $1K/mo? Good riddance. You're a drag on anyone who's actually trying to get shit done. The rest of us will be more productive, and happier, not fucking with you. We'll happily pay higher taxes to get you out of our way.
- conanbatt 11y agoSo you want it or you don't? Also if you make 1000 a month now, you probably dont pay much taxes.
- lloydsparkes 11y agoI'm generally a fan of this idea, as long as its implemented correctly. At the moment lots of western countries, spend billions on welfare entitlement, and billions more administering a complex system, so that politicans can change particular benefits to win votes from certian groups of voters. Under this system, all benefits are replaced with a single, universal level, so politicans can give rises either to everyone, or no one. (The only additional benefits should be for those with serve disabilities). You also lose the withdrawal issues of going from out of work, to in work, you can get rid of things like minimum wages, as their not needed any more, and you can support a more flexible labour market. Politicans cannot fight over, how particular benefits can change, say increase pensions, but cut unemployment. If you also merge this into the tax system, with a flat tax as a negative income tax, it is even more efficient. And eventually you also get what alot of people on the right want - a smaller, more efficient goverment, while doing what alot of people on the left want.
- kalvin 11y agoI think if you could see close-up how these systems work now, you'd be convinced that it's completely not worth the vast cost (in time, energy, money) to try and figure out who "deserves" each of the many, many special benefits/allowances/exemptions available (plus it's incredibly difficult for potential recipients to figure out what they're eligible for, plus it imposes those costs on the people who aren't eligible, but end up having to jump through all the same hoops.) Based on my experience in the last year working on healthcare.gov etc., I think it's become increasingly clear that the implementation of well-meaning policies intended to separate the deserving from the undeserving ends up adding an incredible amount of complexity and overhead, along with unintentional side effects, edge cases, and bad incentives. That said, there's no way politically a basic income is going to fly in the US anytime soon. So since this is HN... is there any way to get to an MVP without having a sovereign state to experiment with? Or is this solely in the realm of public policy? (I asked this a while back on another BI thread, trying again)
- IanCal 11y agoIn addition, every rule to catch the "undeserving" will catch some people who really do need the help and who you were trying to help in the first place. > So since this is HN... is there any way to get to an MVP without having a sovereign state to experiment with? Or is this solely in the realm of public policy? Possibly a daft idea, but what if a company paid by the hour worked (or some other measure of work produced), but had a minimum that was always paid even if you didn't work. Rules: 1. Nobody gets fired for not working. 2. You can get fired if you attack / something else normally fireable not related to your work itself. 3. No other jobs on the side? Less sure about that one. Could be interesting to support people trying something new but with the ability to do work on the side for you or come back. Paradoxically, I think that knowing you can leave but come back reduces the chance you'll leave forever. Quite a few careers allow sabbaticals of a year for this reason. Sort of similar to: 1. Everyone gets BI 2. You don't get it if you're in prison 3. You can't go and live in another country and still receive it
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoThere's been a few aid projects towards impoverished villages in Africa that have a BI setup. There's also Alaska and some other natural resource based payments. In general I think BI is the social safety net equivalent of Greenspun's Tenth Rule: Any sufficiently complicated social welfare program contains an ad hoc, informally-specified, bug-ridden, slow implementation of half of Basic Income. So getting there may be a case of slowly making existing benefits more universal, more cash based etc. I think one suggestion was to just keep lowering the retirement age as BI and state pensions are roughly analogous.
- bayesianhorse 11y agoOne reason why I am currently not so much in favor of UBI is immigration. I have three uncommon beliefs about immigration: First, I don't believe the idea of human rights allows a state to tell people where they are allowed or forbidden to live. Secondly, I don't believe immigration controls are ultimately feasible. In the US this is obvious in the big population of illegal immigrants, other countries are also discovering that they can't really stop people from entering and that hunting down and deporting hundreds of thousands of people is harder than it looks. Thirdly, I don't believe a society can save money by withholding social welfare to someone who lives among them. The cost in health care, crime, and lost potential may very well outpace the savings. I also believe a UBI would force countries to try and tighten their immigration controls. The problem is not so much that the immigrants wouldn't ultimately benefit that society, but the upfront payments and increased financial risks are just scary as hell.
- oskarth 11y agoI agree on 1 and 2, but don't see how 3 follows. If you live as an "illegal immigrant" you are playing life on a higher difficulty level already. UBI wouldn't apply to non-citizens. Of course you might argue that it very well should, but that to me is a different argument that comes at a way later stage. EDIT: I believe this argument is confusing how the world should be with how the world can feasibly be at this point in time. Baby-steps :)
- bayesianhorse 11y agoThe biggest problem with paying welfare to immigrants is that it has to be paid upfront, long before there is a profit or cost reduction compared to not paying it. The problems with not paying are manifold: They are an underclass, without most rights and very poor. A proper healthcare system can't refuse them treatments, for all sorts of reasons, and poverty and lack of rights just increase health care costs. Then there is the lost potential: Those people do have children, often naturalized, or not, living in the country, but not getting the care, food and education they need, which also means they don't fulfill their potential benefits to society. I think refusing children basic welfare is about the stupidest thing a society can do. Both for financial and for humanistic reasons. It is completely irrelevant whose children they are.
- jboggan 11y ago"And the Gods of the Copybook Headings, I notice, outlast them all."
- Meekro 11y agoIn the Carboniferous Epoch we were promised abundance for all, By robbing selected Peter to pay for collective Paul; But, though we had plenty of money, there was nothing our money could buy, And the Gods of the Copybook Headings said: "If you don't work you die."
- jmnicolas 11y agoIn principle I like the idea, but : - the System (corporations / politicians) will never allow it - we're on a planet with limited resources and all economic theories fail to acknowledge that
- bayesianhorse 11y agoI'd say that simple understandings of economic theories fail to acknowledge limited physical resources. But most "theories" I know don't even talk about limited physical resources. Economic growth is about "value", not necessarily "consumption of physical resources".
- zxyzzxxx 11y agoThe planet offers basically unlimited resources. Assuming the population stops growing, as it is predicted, and settles at some reasonable number, then only limit is the expiration date of the sun.
- jmnicolas 11y agoI read somewhere that the max number of sustainable human pop on earth is around one billion ... And unlimited resources, you have to be ready to wait about 500 millions years to get oil to renew !
- conanbatt 11y agoThe basis of economics is to study unlimited needs with limited resources, so all economic theories take that into account.
- cturner 11y ago"In Russia, they thought everyone should have bread. That was a decision made by those in power, and they then tried to make that happen, whether everyone wanted bread or not. This did not work so well, and there were shortages." So they produced bread, but then there were shortages? This doesn't make sense. There is something that we could call "The Central-Planner's Dilemma". People need shoes. Hence, there are people who will be looking to get into the business of supplying shoes. If you find a way to get shoes, and then sell them for more than it cost you, you can buy nice things and that impresses the ladies. You get entire firms dedicated to small problems like shoes for kids, business shoes, variations that suit people with wide feet. Market economies are like the mold on your bathroom ceiling - they just happen. In Russia, the government went to great lengths to stifle that dynamic. They said: all people will need shoes, so the government will supply shoes to meet their need. Everyone will work together to give the government all the resources to do this. If you try divert resources from our project by getting into the shoe business, we'll shoot you. So it's a new game. Now if you want to get the ladies, you need to become the resource allocation guy. But let's assume that you are the planner, and that your motives are pure. You're a really good guy, and you do this for the sheer love of people having shoes. Here's the Dilemma: how do you convert the need of the people to the reality of the goods you're getting to them. This is crazy difficult. To start with, how do you get signal about what the people need? This is hard. You could have a shot at it, by judging birth rates in regions, and getting height variation. You could send out teams to measure foot dimensions and then run statistical variance on sizes. Then you'd needs to communicate that intent to the factories. And then the factories need to execute at producing the things that they should be producing. And then you need to somehow get the goods from the different factories through to the correct regions. You're doing all this through a fog of politics, because jobs in resource-allocation are the only game in town, and everyone wants a piece of it. The Alan Greenspan biography includes a neat section where he got to meet /the/ Russian central planner after the thaw. As in - the guy who sits in the room and decides how many shoes to produce. He describes a complicated mechanisms he set up to plan things. It's a good read.
- conanbatt 11y agoI agree that the Russia bread story makes no sense. There's actually not enough bread in either Capitalist America either, since people also starve.
- oskarth 11y agoThis video is a must-see for people interested in UBI - Milton Friedman, in 1968, on a negative income tax: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xtpgkX588nM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xtpgkX588nM
- Kiro 11y agoHave the economic consequences been studied on a deeper level? There are so many complex correlations in economics that I'm afraid Basic Income can lead to some kind of disaster that's not so obvious at a first glance. How does it affect the national export/import, monetary value, growth, tax income, GDP, housing market, demand/supply on jobs/goods in different sectors etc etc? This article touches those things, which is refreshing compared to most things written about BI, but I would still like to see a real study.
- jberryman 11y agoNot trying to be glib, but you can probably find lots of papers over the past few decades that try to tackle those questions https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=basic+income&btnG= https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=basic+income&btnG...
- SwellJoe 11y agoIf you'd told me ten years ago I would ever support a basic income, I would have laughed. My thought would have been, "People getting paid without doing anything? Absurd!" But, in the past few years I've thoroughly changed my mind on this, and a number of other fronts. I now fully support a basic income (though I think a debate needs to happen about how much that basic income ought to be and how it ought to be funded, I'm well past the point where I think we should be discussing whether it ought to happen). Partly this has been because I did some traveling (a lot of traveling; fulltime for four years, in a motorhome). I spent a lot of time in places that aren't Silicon Valley or other thriving metropolis. Detroit, Slab City, New Orleans, a variety of rural places. There are people who have been completely pushed out of the legitimate economy or merely scrape by at the very bottom, for a variety of reasons. And, it's not a small number of people. It is huge swaths of the population (as much as 39%, based on the poverty line, but more or less, depending on how you define it). That's not sustainable, ethical, or efficient. The CEO to worker pay gap has also contributed to my changing view on this. When a full-time (or part-time who holds another job) Walmart worker doesn't earn enough to rent a tiny apartment and pay for basic expenses, while the CEO makes orders of magnitude more, it becomes apparent there needs to be other ways to push the income down. If corporations won't behave ethically by choice, there needs to be outside pressure. Increasing efficiency and increasing revenue has not resulted in improved quality of life for workers; and that is mostly reflected across the board. It is not merely egregious examples like Walmart. Even many "good" companies have horrible pay gaps and little loyalty to their employees (while expecting loyalty and dedication in return). And, that doesn't really even begin to address the changing nature of work. Many skilled work roles, those jobs that the American middle class was built on, have disappeared from the US economy in my lifetime, and this hasn't been reflected in a subsequent increase in pay or benefits for lower-skilled labor jobs that replaced them (and some of those jobs were not replaced...they just don't exist anymore). All while real estate prices and rents have gone through the roof. So, again, large swaths of the population, the kind of people who could have been middle class home owners in previous generations with reasonable retirement savings, are now renters who live paycheck to paycheck, or worse, live on credit. There's certainly room to talk about why the real estate market is as lopsided as it is. And, there may be room to talk about increasing skills in people who currently work low-skill jobs (though, evidence indicates there are many categories of job that are simply not going to exist in the future). Again, it's not sustainable, ethical, or efficient to have so many people living in poverty. Finally, we already spend a couple trillion dollars on welfare programs. The increased cost for extending that type of benefit to everyone, while removing the bureaucracy of maintaining the existing programs (eligibility compliance and case workers, etc.), is actually not as dramatic as it first seems.
- scrrr 11y agoOh well, looking at history and drawing parallels from the 19th century, we will probably get something like a basic income, or perhaps a massive police state. Either way, something will have to change. At least assuming that satisfaction with current administration and economy is not going to increase. It is good that we start to discuss such ideas.
- 205guy 11y agoI like the idea of a basic income on principle, and this article has some great arguments for it. (Though I agree it is far from being paid for--and a land tax essentially means it only gets paid to the landless, so you'd need to exempt "reasonable" owner-occupied land). But let's simulate how it would look in the real world. I think mindless consumerism would go way up, especially in the lower classes. Advertising in all media would simply encourage this. The well-off would buy stock in Walmart and low end electronics makers with their extra income, thus capturing the income of the less savvy. Without local manufacturing, much of the distributed income would go to China. Paternalism and its religious affiliates would rise up again to capture the income of the not-yet-emancipated (by that I mean women and children). With perceived abundance and linear income, the birth rate would rise. So I think we need to solve some of these issues first. Education should be the beneficiary for the first trillion in new taxes. Hopefully that could mitigate the consumerism and prompt more entrepreneurialism, as well as reduce the paternalism and birth rate. As mentioned, doing universal health care right would amount to the same thing as a universal income as well (more security, less worry, more productivity). So I wonder if those two aren't bigger priorities.
- rjaco31 11y agoOn the other hand, the article choose a pretty high monthly value ($1k). Going with $600 or $800 should greatly alleviate this problem.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoIn the UK the government has recently being trying to increase the birthrate by giving more money to those who have kids, so its interesting to see you suggest this would be a problem with BI. I assume this is a general problem with advanced economies as I read an article recently that said kids in school were being given better info on how to get pregnant in some countries, in another attempt to lift the birth rate.
- vixen99 11y agoThis is simply wrong & it is not government policy moreover UK is the most densely populated country in Europe after Malta. There is a benefit payment given in respect of all children under 16 who have parents earning less than around 60K pounds pa.
- momavujisic 11y agoThe appeal to UBI for me has always, apart from being a good way to stop welfare traps and increase income equality now, is that it marks the beginning of the new phase in our economic system: one from a cash-work model to a material-existence model. I do subscribe to the total job automation theory being every so increasingly talked about, and what these proposals tell me is that government and to a larger extent society is beginning to see that we can indeed provide for everyone using our productivity gains. The cash part of the deal I think is just a carry-on from our ageing economic system that will be replaced by some other form of value transfer mechanism which honestly, I can't imagine what would look like.
- lucaspiller 11y agoOne thing I've always wondered about the basic income is wont it just mean prices go up because people are greedy? Take the article about trailer parks that was on here a week ago: The business owners said that they had to be careful when raising prices to make sure tenants can still afford it. If their tenants suddenly get an extra $1000/month, what's to stop them putting the rent up by $1000/month?
- zxyzzxxx 11y agoPeople that wouldn't work wouldn't have to live in highly contested areas with a high rent. Workers could afford them, others would live outside of those expensive areas, keep their guaranteed income and decide what to do with their lives.
- jberryman 11y agoThere's some discussion here: http://www.reddit.com/r/basicincome/wiki/index#wiki_wouldn.27t_basic_income_just_cause_inflation.3F I have no idea, but I could imagine in your scenario: when people living in mobile home parks have more buying power, the market for serving them becomes more attractive leading to more competition. So maybe Joe opens up a competing park next door and undercuts Bob. Also tenants of all sorts would presumably have more mobility with the extra income.
- alexqgb 11y agoWhat's to stop them? Generally the same thing that stops people from price gouging elsewhere - competitors offering better service and / or price. Unless someone is being forced to pay, getting greedy isn't a great way to stay in business. Indeed, it's a pretty reliable way of getting driven out of business. After all, nothing attracts competition faster than fat and easy profits.
- learc83 11y agoThe reason trailer park owners can keep raising prices is because cities won't allow new trailer parks to be built. This artificially restricts demand. Local governments artificially restricting the supply of affordable housing isn't necessarily going to be fixed by a basic income. However, if people have an extra $1000 a month, many of them can afford other types of housing. Increased demand for this newly affordable housing will drive up the price, and developers will move in to build more housing. The increase in supply would then drive down prices until they reach an equilibrium.
- wiz21 11y agoI was shocked by the "magic of markets" analysis. When there's no more bread, people make more bread ? Nope, bread becomes more expensive. Especially with automation : it's harder for new baker to start in the market, so those in the market get more powerful. That's concentration. Basic income will make less poor but more slaves. Slaves that will be dependent on those (I assume it's the state) who define the exact amount of that uncondional income. Since a huge part of the population will be out of the "producer", thus the producer will have more power. What must be done instead is to make sure power doesn't get concentrated. But this means less efficiency : one big optimised company is surely more efficient that ten smaller ones. With less power, the workforce can still negociate, the workforce can still share the remaining work, those who have no job still have a chance to get one if they want/need to. With basic income, there's no need to do that anymore... So I don't like that basic income. For example, there's a lot of unemployment in my country. People gets some allowance to live. The problem is that the lack of work is not acknowledged => those people are stigmatized. Anyway, they do get an allowance, kind of your basic income. The problem is that because of the unemployment, the employer are in a very strong position to pay people less (since many do want/need a job). So work valuation diminishes... Competition is the problem, if companies would compete less, then basic income could work. There would be more space for choice : do I work or not ? can I share my work ? Basic income means : let's detach ourselves from the consequences of competition.
- pvaldes 11y agoBasic income can also mean other things. Some people just are so unique that don't need to compete. Some examples of unemployed people that did not have an income other that the support of his family, friends or government in a part of (or all) his life: Vincent Van Gogh, too clumsy to farm John Steinbeck, housed by his father that provides also paper and material Harper Lee, sabbatical payed by friends J.K. Rowling, writing whereas on welfare. ... and many others Take in mind that you don't have just competition, there is also collaboration, and teaming, and life-changers. Some people just born in poverty. This would not be his choice if they could. Some born in a poor rural environment somewhere in Misissipi, other in a manger in the middle of nowhere. Some of those people are between the most influent people in the history of the humanity. People seem to worry about that basic income could lead to a lot of people scratching his bellies all day (and this is true) but don't always notice that this will also reveal a hidden minory of fine gem crafters in art, music, literature or poetry that are just roting now and could be free to create huge economic values instead.
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoI am interested in this idea. As I understand it, it's a long-held idea with some support from the center, left, and right. Having said that, last week I read through an analysis piece -- 6-8 page pdf -- that I found on a financial site. I found out some interesting things that supporters don't emphasize. The problem, as I understand it, is that UBI is fine in theory and as a high-level idea. Once you start actually thinking about applying it? The words could mean dang near anything. Is it across the board? Are there exceptions? Would you use a reverse income tax, direct payments, or other mechanism to deliver it? What sorts of incentives does it provide to the working poor? If you really wanted to eventually replace hourly occupation, wouldn't it make more sense to begin providing it to those who have worked their entire lives? Begin direct payments to retirees and then slowly decrease the retirement age as the years pass? Those are just questions I made up after reading the article. Apologies if I botched it. But I was impressed with the fact that there is a ginormous gap between the slogan of UBI and whatever it actually might end up becoming. A big enough gap that politicians could say they support it and actually give you pretty much anything. There's also not a huge amount of real-world data here. So my position is "cautiously optimistic". Let's do some limited experiments with this to see how the real-world politics play out and what the difference between the PR package and the actual deliverable is. In the U.S., the states have traditionally been the "laboratories of democracy", but if folks don't like that, there has to be other ways to do a bunch of limited trials. What I am not in support of is some huge national movement built around a slogan where I'm forced to make a yes-no decision for the rest of the citizenry. Here's hoping it doesn't play out like that.
- alkonaut 11y agoThere are basically just two important sides to this: In an expansive welfare state (say a Nordic country) there are large transfers tax money between people. Some of these transfers are unconditional, for example every child (parent) is given around $150/month, regardless of family income. These transfers are pretty expensive. The reasoning behind giving it to every child is that it is supposed to be directed to the child, and there shouldn't be any stigma associated with it. You could argue that if this money was directed only to parents below a certain income , the same amount of money could do a lot more good This is the core of this issue: unconditional basic income is a very expensive kind of transfer. Even the vast bureaucracy required to ensure money goes to those who need it in a regular welfare state is a lot less expensive than a basic income reform.
- timClicks 11y agoI thought it was actually relatively cheap intervention as there is only a minor admin overhead. Do you have links to more detailed analysis? Am interested in learning more.
- barbs 11y ago(2014) ?
- dcw303 11y agoIf there's $2.98 trillion per year to spend, put it into space travel. We should be colonizing other worlds. With more resources available, there's more work available. More work means more demand for jobs - and life is infinitely better when you are being paid for the value you provide to society than what is really quasi-welfare.
- zxyzzxxx 11y agoI think the incentive to keep the income would greatly reduce minor crimes. Just imagine what positive effect would that have on the society
- Atropos 11y agoWould the basic income only apply to high income countries or worldwide? Because I feel that it would be extremely unfair and maybe even unethical to give every US citizen a basic income for life, while people elsewhere die from hunger.
- Singletoned 11y agoMy worry about this would be that in order to prevent mass fraud of the system, we would have to have a national ID card system, which is something I've always instinctively opposed.
- 4ydx 11y agoSadly I think that UBI supporters tend to the false impression that everybody would be: 1) Frugal. 2) Responsible. I just don't have that much faith in (roughly) half the population. What happens when people have too many kids and are still too impoverished? Is there going to be a "reasonable limit" to the number of kids you can have? Women could have as many as 20 kids or more. Is that really going to work? What happens when they are drug addicts (or worse free-to-play video games addicts) who cannot control their spending? For me personally I love the idea of UBI, but I just don't think that it can work on a practical level. The examples that explain how to generate the required money to pay for it don't seem very feasible to me. You cannot add VAT. That is borderline "perpetual motion machine" logic right there. At the most basic level you will just have to tax the wealthy more one way or another. That is it. The only option. The question is: are they ok with that?
- dopkew 11y agoUBI will likely encourage unsustainable population growth. So, population growth dis-incentives need to be part of the package.
- pratyushag 11y agoIf you like the idea of giving such an income (or cash transfer) to people but the idea of an unconditional basic income seems too far away, you can contribute to newincentives.org which is providing cash transfers to poor pregnant HIV mothers. Achieves two goals: reduces HIV and puts money in very needy hands.
- orlandob 11y agoAt some point, intelligent members of society (read: YOU PEOPLE) will realize that there is no such thing as zero-sum fiat monetary system. You don't need to tax someone for the government to create a new spending program. There is no scarcity in USD (its fiat money, there's infinite supply). When there are economic resources untapped, the ~50% unemployed & underemployed, the Government MUST step in and provide stimulus. The multiplier on the economy has been well studied and would benefit society greatly. IN FIAT MONEY SYSTEMS (USD, CAD, JPY, AUD, CHF, etc.) FEDERAL DEBT IS PUBLIC INCOME. FEDERAL SURPLUS IS PUBLIC DEBT.
- known 11y agoUnlike Capitalism, Globalization is Zero-sum WITHOUT http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income
- known 11y agoTax Corporate Revenues, Not Profits;