3 ms·
It's good that you posted this, unfortunately most people remain blissfully unaware of this information despite this paper dating from 2013 and other public dis
by contingencies 11y ago
It's good that you posted this, unfortunately most people remain blissfully unaware of this information despite this paper dating from 2013 and other public discussions also having taken place.
Dan Farmer, the author, wrote the original SATAN host security scanner. I had some emails with Dan about IPMI circa 2013. His paper is a good restatement of many of the problems of IPMI.
However, in my mind the biggest problem with IPMI, which is not really well elucidated in this paper, is that it turns every machine in to two machines, and compromising either one means you can automatically compromise the other: ie. own the host, own the BMC by flashing it with vendor tools. Own the BMC, own the host by any number of ways including memory manipulation, old-school keyboard input, presenting fake devices to the running kernel, etc.
Unfortunately, it's therefore impossible to ever be completely sure you've got control of a system. In the face of any suspected attack you cannot ever regain control with any confidence whatsoever, even by flashing firmware.
- spotman 11y agoYeah, so true. Just had to retire a server a couple weeks ago, because of a new vulnerability discovered in its IPMI firmware. It's a bummer, because if your support contract runs out, sometimes you have to pay to upgrade, which leaves you in a bind. In my case it made more sense to just replace this one server. But, ultimately I guess my point is that even if IPMI is patchable, there is another hurdle, you can't as easily maintain it yourself as you can a linux host.
- jlgaddis 11y agoI have a few old servers that don't get IPMI firmware updates anymore. Fortunately, the IPMI interfaces are on their own small, isolated VLAN that's behind a proper hardware firewall and only accessible from a handful of management hosts.
- zantana 11y ago"...is that it turns every machine in to two machines..." That is a bit of hyperbole. Using the same logic virtual machines and containers turn single machines into dozens of machines.
- contingencies 11y agoUhh... no. They have their own physical machine ('the BMC') with unaudited low level access to your physical machine. It's therefore two machines.