4 ms·
We've been over this before. If you communicate, by any signal, including the lack of sending a signal, or any prearranged protocol, that you received a warran
by SilasX 11y ago
We've been over this before.
If you communicate, by any signal, including the lack of sending a signal, or any prearranged protocol, that you received a warrant when you were ordered not to talk about it, then you are in violation of the order.
No amount of technical trickery changes that; courts are run by humans.
The page includes a note about warrant canaries never having been tested in a court of law, but you shouldn't be hopeful.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI've been in the fight against corrupt government a long time and I totally agree. Winning in court means convincing a judge you were acting consistently with the law. Tipping people off about law enforcement action usually leads them to rule against you. Stopping stuff at the Patriot Act level means you need to be immune to such laws or have strong leverage on them outside the legal system. There's no easy win in a police state where government holds most of the cards and can look at yours most of the time. It's why the public must change the laws first. Not holding my breath.
- peteretep 11y ago> courts are run by humans Not only that, courts are run by humans who have the ability to imprison you indefinitely if they think you are disrespecting the spirit of their rulings http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contempt_of_court http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contempt_of_court
- MCRed 11y agoWhich is a violation of due process itself.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- serf 11y agoIf you communicate, by any signal, including the lack of sending a signal, or any prearranged protocol, that you received a warrant when you were ordered not to talk about it, then you are in violation of the order. ( in some regions, in certain courts of law, under certain conditions, maybe. ) Thankfully 'global laws' and 'global court' aren't a thing yet. Let's not lump everyone into a big US/UK legal blackhole, please. The canary concept is valid for more than just a US based legal adversary.
- SilasX 11y agoIn no jurisdiction can you circumvent a gag order by working out a special omission or protocol that communicates the gagged information, as that would defeat the purpose of a gag order.
- spiritplumber 11y agoIn no jurisdiction can you be compelled to lie, either. Not say something, yes (gag order). Say something true, yes (or get a contempt of court charge). Say something false, no. As of May 2015 anyway.
- vacri 11y agoNo gagged information is transmitted when the canary is removed. It just means that a gag order has been received. What for? Can't say. Just that a gag order has been received.