9 ms·
Which has seemingly been rejected by bishops, archbishops, cardinals, and the pope. http://www.usccb.org/news/2015/15-019.cfm http://www.usccb.org/news/2015/15-
by aaronbrethorst 11y ago
Which has seemingly been rejected by bishops, archbishops, cardinals, and the pope. http://www.usccb.org/news/2015/15-019.cfm http://www.usccb.org/news/2015/15-019.cfm
- tptacek 11y agoHe wasn't making an argument from religious authority (that would be a dubious rhetorical tactic on HN); he was trying to capture a historical justification for capital punishment, and it happened to come from a period of time in which the Catholic church played an outsized role in public policy. For anyone unclear on this: the Catholic church vigorously opposes capital punishment.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> For anyone unclear on this: the Catholic church vigorously opposes capital punishment. Its a little more nuanced than that: the Catholic Church holds that capital punishment by the competent authorities of the state can be justified by certain circumstances, however, for quite some time, the dominant view of the hierarchy has been that the circumstances in which it is justified are never, or nearly so, present in the modern world, and that as such, while capital punishment is permitted in the abstract, it is never, or nearly so, justifiable in practice in the modern world.
- tptacek 11y agoThe Church historically justifies capital punishment "if this is the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against an unjust aggressor", and for several decades the Church has taken the reasonable and strict interpretation of the words "only possible way". I think another way to say this would be that the words "capital punishment" have two different meanings, and in the meaning we use for public policy discussions, the Church opposes it categorically.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The Church historically justifies capital punishment "if this is the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against an unjust aggressor", and for several decades the Church has taken the reasonable and strict interpretation of the words "only possible way". I think it is a mistake to view the recent change as a change in the interpretation of the "only possible way", so much as a change in the understanding of what effective tools are available to the state. The opposition is generally not categorical in the way that, e.g., the opposition to direct abortion is categorical, but prudential in that it considers the actual conditions that obtain in the world and the options that are realistically available. A good example of this is Pope John-Paul II in Evangelium Vitae (1995): "It is clear that, for these purposes to be achieved, the nature and extent of the punishment must be carefully evaluated and decided upon, and ought not go to the extreme of executing the offender except in cases of absolute necessity: in other words, when it would not be possible otherwise to defend society. Today however, as a result of steady improvements in the organization of the penal system, such cases are very rare, if not practically non-existent." (emphasis added)
- tptacek 11y agoI think you mean 1995, not 1965 (PJP2 wasn't Pope in '65; PP6 was). Also I think we're on the same page. Since 1980 (really, 1974), it's been the position of the US Council of Catholic Bishops that Catholics are called on not just to personally oppose capital punishment, but to militate for its abolition in the US. There's not much subtlety to it.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> I think you mean 1995, not 1965 (PJP2 wasn't Pope in '65; PP6 was). Correct (and corrected). > Since 1980 (really, 1974), it's been the position of the US Council of Catholic Bishops that Catholics are called on not just to personally oppose capital punishment, but to militate for its abolition in the US. There's not much subtlety to it. The subtlety, such as it is, is in the rationale for the opposition (that capital punishment is not a priori wrong, merely wrong in actual factual conditions that obtain -- relevant to the USCCB position -- in the modern U.S. [and, in the context of Evangelium Vitae and other similar pronouncements of the universal Church, more generally in the modern world].) But, no, the opposition itself is not subtle.
- michaelsbradley 11y agoIn recent decades, certain Catholic persons, even ones in important leadership positions, have vigorously opposed it. But not all modern-day Catholics do so – as a Catholic, I do not. Here is what Pope Pius XII had to say in the middle of the 20th Century: "Even when it is a question of the execution of a condemned man, the State does not dispose of the individual's right to life. In this case it is reserved to the public power to deprive the condemned person of the enjoyment of life in expiation of his crime when, by his crime, he has already disposed himself of his right to live." – Address to the First International Congress of Histopathology of the Nervous System (14 Sep 1952)[1] See also Fr. George Rutler's article in Crisis Magazine, Hanging Concentrates the Mind (8 Feb 2013)[2], and Avery Cardinal Dulles' essay in First Things, Catholicism & Capital Punishment (Apr 2001)[3]. In short, there is more to the "Catholic view" than Evangelium Vitae[4], the 1997 Catechism[5], recent statements by Pope Francis[6], and statements by other Catholic writers and leaders repeating or expanding upon the same ideas[7] (all due respect being given to their persons and offices). The modern Catholic position, if you will, on the death penalty is something of an anomaly against the backdrop of what previous Councils, Popes, Doctors and Fathers of the Church have taught. As a matter of intellectual honesty, at least, I think it's important that Catholics "play with a full deck" when treating this difficult subject. Having dug into the matter, I concluded that the modern position is not sound, and so have adopted the Church's traditional view on the death penalty. [1] https://www.ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/P12PSYCH.HTM https://www.ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/P12PSYCH.HTM [2] http://www.crisismagazine.com/2013/hanging-concentrates-the-mind http://www.crisismagazine.com/2013/hanging-concentrates-the-... [3] http://www.firstthings.com/article/2001/04/catholicism-amp-capital-punishment http://www.firstthings.com/article/2001/04/catholicism-amp-c... [4] http://w2.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_25031995_evangelium-vitae.html http://w2.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/encyclicals/doc... [5] http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s2c2a5.htm#2267 http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s2c2a5.htm#2267 [6] http://visnews-en.blogspot.com/2015/03/pope-francis-death-penalty-is.html http://visnews-en.blogspot.com/2015/03/pope-francis-death-pe... [7] One example, there are many more: http://www.macatholic.org/sites/macatholic.org/files/assets/Statement%20on%20the%20Death%20Penalty%204.7.2015.pdf%20FINAL.pdf http://www.macatholic.org/sites/macatholic.org/files/assets/...
- tptacek 11y ago