4 ms·
Wickard v. Filburn is one of the federal government's great Godel contradictions, allowing it to prove anything thus rendering the law meaningless. Under the d
by mindslight 11y ago
Wickard v. Filburn is one of the federal government's great Godel contradictions, allowing it to prove anything thus rendering the law meaningless.
Under the dubious justification of the Tsarnaev case, shoplifting candy from the corner store is under federal jurisdiction since in the age of social media it could incite people in other states to do the same.
- tptacek 11y agoYou're implying Filburn gives the federal government unfettered power to regulate commerce, but it doesn't; there are limits both in Filburn and in subsequent SCOTUS cases. See for instance the syllabus for US v Lopez (95).
- mindslight 11y agoThose limits were created by the federal government itself. It can always revise them as needs change, and is thus in reality unconstrained. This is akin to kids establishing rules while playing make believe.
- tptacek 11y agoThose limits were held to exist by SCOTUS, not by statute.
- mindslight 11y agoAnd?
- tptacek 11y agoIt's not very interesting to argue that a state might change its mind on some question, because that's always true, and there's no way to rebut or even engage that argument. On the other hand, I thought maybe you were suggesting that Congress could pass a law relying on the "Godel inconsistency" of Filburn to usurp state authority. Well, no, they can't; they're bound by the judicial precedents that fence Commerce Power authority in.
- mindslight 11y ago> a state might change its mind on some question, because that's always true The entire idea of a written constitution is to independently limit a state's otherwise arbitrary power. This is not done through a formal process (as that would be part of the government itself, by definition). Stating that there are laws the government itself is bound to is a direct inducement to enforce those laws through informal methods (eg whistleblowers, insubordination, civil disobedience, revolution). So, it is important for everyone to be independently judging whether their government is still bound by its original charter or if it has broken free and is essentially lawless. I don't expect that we'll agree on this judgment (it's a distributed consensus). My practical aim is to highlight that SCOTUS is not the final arbiter of the law lest this ultimate check be categorically forgotten.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Those limits were created by the federal government itself. Sure, by SCOTUS. If you are just arguing that SCOTUS can reverse itself, why even invoke Filburn? Its superfluous to the argument.
- mindslight 11y agoSCOTUS claims its power by purporting to stick to a set of rules. As such, they cannot simply make arbitrary decisions but must come up with some plausible justification. They base these justifications on previous justifications, forming a DAG where each edge is constrained in unreasonableness, but paths clearly aren't (every entity desires more power for benevolence). Highlighting an important node of that structure is useful in illustrating one aspect of how we got from "powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people" to the current behemoth.