4 ms·
The U.S. Navy’s Big Mistake – Building Tons of Supercarriers
- angersock 11y agoIt's unfortunate that the F35 boondoggle is now also pulling in and sinking the Navy. I am curious about phrases such as "interfering with its ability to meet emerging requirements and threats.". After all, has the mathematics of force projection and enterprise-scale conflict changed that much in the last 40 years? I could see the argument for, for example, reconfiguring carriers to be just drone carriers (starcraft, lol). But, I'm skeptical that somehow the job of take off, fly, loiter, bomb the shit out of something, return, refuel, rearm, repeat has changed that much.
- smacktoward 11y ago> After all, has the mathematics of force projection and enterprise-scale conflict changed that much in the last 40 years? Perhaps not, but the article notes that there was plenty of skepticism about the survivability of the carrier force 40 years ago, too: Soviet Adm. Sergei Gorchakov reportedly held the view that the U.S. had made a strategic miscalculation by relying on large and increasingly vulnerable aircraft carriers. The influential U.S. Adm. Hyman Rickover shared this view. In a 1982 congressional hearing, legislators asked him how long American carriers would survive in an actual war. Rickover’s response? “Forty-eight hours.” (Of course Rickover was the father of the nuclear submarine, so his opinions on the relative superiority of carriers may need to be taken with a grain of salt added. He certainly wasn't alone in that opinion, though; Elmo Zumwalt, for instance, wanted to move away from a few big carriers to larger numbers of smaller ones -- see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_Control_Ship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_Control_Ship) Arguably a flattop-heavy force was even more at risk back then than it is today, because back then there was a real risk that an attack by the most likely adversary (the USSR, obv.) would be centered around nuclear weapons, and it's hard to see any scenario where any surface fleet could survive in the face of that kind of attack. Today's anti-ship missiles and torpedoes are faster and stealthier, but they're also much less likely to be nuclear-tipped.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tsotha 11y agoFlattops aren't as vulnerable as most people think. It really depends on the scenario - it's actually quite difficult to land a hit on a US carrier in blue water. It gets easier the closer you get to land, which is why the Navy is so hot to get the new drone strike aircraft deployed. Part of the problem (if you can view it that way) is nobody's attacked a carrier battle group in a very long time. In theory we have counters for new systems like streaker missiles, submarines, and the DF-21D, but nobody knows how things would shake out in an actual battle.
- nullrouted 11y agoYou name all this theoretical great technology now how many countries have the resources to launch that type of attack and survive the repercussions? Maybe China and Russia who both have nukes anyway.
- dm2 11y agoThere is nothing stopping any nation with ICBMs from launching them at Washington DC, and with enough warheads one would hit, possibly all would hit. But it would be suicide for the country that launched them. Yes, anti-ship missiles and rail-gun rounds would likely devastate a carrier group. Part of any strategy against a country with that capability would be to take out those targets first (NRO keeping watch on those locations, CIA and NSA helping out). Trillions of dollars are spent specifically to keep track of missiles, foreign troops, to improve defenses, and to improve first-strike capabilities. Even a rail-gun and anti-ship missile can possible be countered, there are a lot of people working on making it happen. Part of the deterrent is that we have battle-tested long-range radar systems that can detect where missiles are launched from. The US has dozens of nuclear and non-nuclear VERY VERY large bombs in every corner of Earth that would be used to absolutely destroy whatever launched that missile at a super-carrier. http://static5.businessinsider.com/image/50f5450069bedde11500000d-960/071218-f-3539l-001.jpg http://static5.businessinsider.com/image/50f5450069bedde1150... The reason to have war-games is to find weaknesses in strategy and defenses. If nothing else, I feel safer with a dozen super-carriers on constant patrol. Having aircraft available in a warzone in a way that carriers provide is invaluable. It's the reason the Marines have invested in their own smaller carriers (and the sole reason the F35 needs a VTOL version).
- gnoway 11y agoWell it's a good thing you feel safer. I was particularly concerned by this: "The leader of the red team employed brilliant asymmetric tactics resulting in 16 U.S. ships, including two supercarriers, going to the bottom in a very short span of time. The Navy stopped the war game, prohibited the red team from using these tactics and then reran the exercise declaring victory on the second day." If true, that's not 'finding weaknesses in strategy and defenses,' that's 'sticking your head in the sand.'
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoThis is absolutely par for the course in training exercises. Several reasons occur immediately. The persons involved may want to cover their butts, and report a more positive outcome. OR, the value of training for failure is very limited in value; scenarios that allow everyone to practice their skills may fit the mission goals better. My son, while in the Army in Korea, led a 6-person team as 'insurgents' in an exercise against a company. After the scripted exercises they were allowed to do anything they wanted. Result: rear gate breached after a feint; company HQ tent blown up by 'suicide bomber' (only casualty on his side); and three quarters of the company killed by his roaming snipers. They only stopped the exercise when his 'insurgents' ran out of ammo. This exercise was of course never part of the after-action report :)
- mozumder 11y agoThe next generation carriers really needs to be underwater. I'm wondering how large a submarine can be made, one with a runway and hanger for dozens of aircraft (or drones..)
- techdragon 11y agoNow that's an idea. If you want traditional manned aircraft you have a large number of limitations on how you can work with them. But drones are flexible, in fact they can be extremely flexible. Submarine launched drone aircraft. I wonder if it's possible to get enough bandwidth to control them from underwater and if it's possible to fit a non trivial drone into a form factor that could reuse Trident/Polaris missile tubes, then there's the matter of how to do post mission retrieval underwater. It's an interesting idea.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tsotha 11y ago>The hubris of the “battleship Navy” was such that just nine days before Pearl Harbor, the official program for the 1941 Army-Navy game displayed a full page photograph of the battleship USS Arizona with language virtually extolling its invincibility. >Of course, the reason that no one had yet sunk a battleship from the air — in combat — was that no one had yet tried. This is why I can't trust anything from War is Boring. They have too many obvious factual errors, to the point that you wonder if the author has any familiarity with the subject. The British carrier HMS Illustrious made an air-only attack on the Italian fleet in November of 1940, damaging two battleships that were saved only by grounding and sinking a third.
- gmarx 11y agoTons of Supercarriers? Wouldn't that be a fraction of a supercarrier?
- thomble 11y agoThis reminds me of this old War Nerd piece, "This is How the Carriers Will Die": http://exiledonline.com/the-war-nerd-this-is-how-the-carriers-will-die/ http://exiledonline.com/the-war-nerd-this-is-how-the-carrier...