9 ms·
America's entire justice system seems unfair to the poor. Or to phase it another way, I literally don't believe the poor get a fair or speedy trial, but do beli
by Someone1234 11y ago
America's entire justice system seems unfair to the poor. Or to phase it another way, I literally don't believe the poor get a fair or speedy trial, but do believe the rich can. Bail is a big problem. Plea agreements and their relationship to public defender's workload are another massive problem.
A lot of people without much familiarity of the legal system think things like "no innocent person would ever plead guilty!" but the way the US legal/justice system is set up right now, it is often the least-bad alternative to plead guilty to a crime you didn't commit than to fight it.
And I'd love to point my finger at one individual or set of individuals, but the reality is that the entire system is broken, and it isn't broken because of bad actors, it is broken because it is just poorly designed and implemented at its core (although moral prosecutors can help mitigate some of the problems).
The UK justice system is imperfect, but things like no plea deals, no monetary bail, and better pay for public defenders (although still too low, and they're still overworked) improve things a lot. Plus prosecutors aren't politically motivated and are interested in justice (elected prosecutors is another massive problem in the US).
The US criminal justice system is "scary." I feel bad for anyone who it victimises, in particular the poor.
- nickff 11y agoI agree with many of your criticisms of the US court system, but disagree with your characterization of the UK system. In the US (many, but not all) prosecutors are directly politically motivated, but in the UK they are largely bureaucratically motivated, as are a large number of US prosecutors who are in the lower ranks, and not subject to direct elections or high-level oversight. Some may regard bureaucratic motivations as more 'enlightened', 'nicer', and 'more impartial', but they are really just slightly different from political motivations. I would further argue that prosecutors' motivations are very similar in both countries. At the highest levels, the prosecutors are subject to political pressures and incentives whether due to direct elections, appointments, or oversight; at the lower levels, the lawyers are part of a bureaucracy with all that entails.
- jcromartie 11y agoAmericans also have a uniquely individualistic philosophy of life. They are big on "personal responsibility" and free will. I see lots of people with no sympathy for people who are caught up in the justice system, based on a belief that they "chose" to do whatever they did, and are inherently evil and deserve whatever they get. We love retributive justice here in the USA. That will be very hard to dislodge. It seems abundantly clear that there is no such thing as truly (i.e. supernatural) free will, and severe punishments do little to deter crime. The phrase "they are just x" gets thrown around a lot. They are just animals. They are just monsters. They are just evil. As if these qualities are discrete things that exist by themselves... What can we do to convince people that criminals are not, in fact, "just" bad people?
- Crito 11y agoThe non-existence of supernatural free will is largely irrelevant; despite it not existing it is abundantly clear that we can modify expected behavior by offering rewards or punishments. Supernatural free will is not necessary in the slightest to explain this. > "severe punishments to little to deter crime." I have seen some evidence that this is the case specifically for the death penalty. I've seen little to suggest that it holds true throughout more general cases. Nevertheless, even if we rule out deterrence as a possibility, we're still left with incapacitation (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incapacitation_%28penology%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incapacitation_%28penology%29). That undeniably does work, and it works damn well. The thought of being locked up in a cell may not deter a free man, and it may not cure a captured man, but it will prevent that man from victimizing innocent members of the general public again. You don't need silly concepts of supernatural souls or good and evil to benefit from incapacitation. No matter what we think of any of these issues, the fact of the matter is that Ted Kaczynski is unable to mail a bomb to people like you or I.
- nitrogen 11y agoWhile incapacitation is a valid need, the current American justice system appears to completely disregard the possibility of rehabilitation, especially for non-violent/victimless crimes. Incapacitation isn't so important when rehabilitation is possible, and accepting the lack of supernatural free will should help with acceptance of rehabilitation.
- Crito 11y agoIncapacitation is an essential part of rehabilitation, unless you believe that every criminal can be fixed with a simple out-patient procedure. While rehabilitation is in progress but not yet complete, incapacitation is essential. As I see it, one of the biggest problems with the American justice system is pre-mature release. We are releasing criminals before they are known to be rehabilitated. If we're going to go with rehabilitation, then we need to scrap the idea of determining how long somebody will be incapacitated (imprisoned) during sentencing. The duration of incapacitation should be determined solely by how long rehabilitation takes. A doctor continues treatment for as long as treatment is necessary. You don't hear them say things like "Okay Mr Johnson, looks like you've got cancer. We're going to do chemo for 6 months, then you'll be done!" Rather, you get "we're going to start chemo, and we'll continue to monitor your progress." We also need to set sane expectations for our own abilities. What is the false-positive rate for rehabilitation? Does that false-positive rate, when considered with the severity of the crime, work out to a risk that we are willing to accept? What if 1% of captured and rehabilitated murderers go on to murder again? Is that an acceptable risk? What if it's 5%, or 10%? Are there crimes so awful that no false-positive rate is acceptable?
- netfire 11y agoI think its a symptom of some bigger issues. Specifically that many of the decisions in the US are being driven by fear and the increasing role that money plays in politics (and elections in particular). Instead of addressing problems in a way that would be most effective for the individual and society, we are so afraid of having "bad" people on the streets, that we lock them away, sometimes for years, without a lot of evidence that we are doing any good (in fact, there is evidence that once someone enters the prison system, they are likely to commit crime once released) On the political side, we are unnecessarily removing transparency from the government and sacrificing constitutional rights in the name of protecting ourselves from terrorists and people involved with criminal activity. The potential for abuse with this type of action is huge, especially if you get the wrong people in power. I don't think we'll fix these sort of problems until we change our mindset and get money out of politics.
- maxlybbert 11y agoYou may have a point. But bail bondsmen existed long before the current political climate.
- will_brown 11y ago>Plea agreements and their relationship to public defender's workload are another massive problem. Whether a case is criminal or civil more than 9 out of 10 times a case will not go to trial. This is not necessarily indicative of any problem in either criminal or civil...in fact in most contexts it makes a lot of sense. For example, as a criminal defense lawyer, if the Gov has a really shitty case against my Client (not saying they are necessarily innocent), guess what it will never go to trial, b/c either the case can be won on pretrial motions or I can have a case broken down to a lesser charge and it makes sense to work that out (plea) rather than risk the conviction on the original charge. Further, your statement "no innocent person would ever plead guilty", also inaccurately depicts a system where there is only two options guilty/not guilty, over looking a withholding of adjudication which is going to be applicable in the majority of misdemeanor cases and even some felonies. On the other hand if the State has a slam dunk case against my Client, it again makes no sense to go to trial and expose my Client to the maximum sentence when I can work out a plea at the minimums (or close to) under the law, this serves the interest of my Client as much as society (saving tax payer dollars on unnecessary trials, think arbitration/mediation in the civil context). Only in those cases where the plea offer is equal to the maximums under the law, or where the Gov has a shitty case but the facts are so egregious the Gov would rather take it to trial and lose than give a minimal plea does it make sense to go to trial. Unfortunately the World is simply comprised of haves and have-nots, where the poor (as you call them) get the short end of the stick...certainly this is true in the justice system as you note, but it is no more true in law than anywhere else (medical care, transportation, education, employment, ect...). Only the potential Gov abuses in the justice system have higher consequences, and that in part is why in 1963 SCOTUS ruled defendants have a Constitutional right to a lawyer who otherwise could not afford one(establishing the first PD office). Talk about scary...we have a Constitutional right to a criminal lawyer, but not to see a Dr. if we are sick.
- nitrogen 11y agoFor example, as a criminal defense lawyer, if the Gov has a really shitty case against my Client (not saying they are necessarily innocent), guess what it will never go to trial, b/c either the case can be won on pretrial motions or I can have a case broken down to a lesser charge and it makes sense to work that out (plea) rather than risk the conviction on the original charge. Isn't this (plea to lesser charge) a part of the problem the parent post was describing, that the sheer might and vindictiveness of the criminal justice system intimidates innocent (or even guilty) defendants into pleading guilty? If justice would be served by a lesser charge or a lesser sentence, how is it fair to increase the charge or increase the sentence because the defendant wants to exercise their constitutional right to a trial?
- LordKano 11y agoIt's just an extension of the fact that life seems unfair to the poor. Having less money means that you end up with lower quality food, water, air, sanitation, housing, education, medical care, legal representation, law enforcement, transportation and probably a dozen other things that didn't immediately come to my mind. Societal problems don't spontaneously develop overnight and it won't be quick or easy to address them without causing a lot of other problems. Still, we should be aware of them and their causes.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y ago> Or to phase it another way, I literally don't believe the poor get a fair or speedy trial, The poor never get trials. The vast majority of cases are pled down. Prosecutors and other officers of the court punish those who refuse to waive trial and plead guilty, and this forces most (innocent and guilty alike) to take the bargain. Plea bargains are sometimes useful to prosecutors, allowing them to serve justice at times when there is real risk that a criminal would be acquitted. But it's a tool that is prone to outrageous abuse. I propose that prosecutors be prohibited from offering plea deals to more than 3% of their cases in any given calendar year, and that any excess of such be sufficient to disbar them or even carry criminal penalties.
- rayiner 11y ago> A lot of people without much familiarity of the legal system think things like "no innocent person would ever plead guilty!" but the way the US legal/justice system is set up right now, it is often the least-bad alternative to plead guilty to a crime you didn't commit than to fight it. On the flip side, I think a lot of people with only passing familiarity with the legal system think innocent people regularly plead guilty. I have lots of friends who are public defenders. My impression is that they rarely encounter people who aren't clearly guilty of what they're charged with. When they rage about injustice, it's about how extreme the penalties are, the lack of sympathy for juvenile offenders, etc.
- pcwalton 11y agoAs an outsider, what Ken White says [1] sounds reasonable to me. "I think the federal guilty plea rate is in the 90-95% range, with the remainder being trials and the occasional dismissal or other resolution. How many of those are actually guilty? I don't know. Many of them did something. But a not-insigificant [sic] percentage of them didn't do what the government says they did." [1]: http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/1aokls/iama_federal_criminal_defense_attorney_and_former/c8zbr4w http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/1aokls/iama_federal_cr...
- rayiner 11y agoI'm talking about the sort of cases handled by public defenders for people who have trouble making bail. Robbery suspects caught with the stolen goods, drug dealers caught on the street making a sale, etc. Not complex federal crimes where everyone can agree on what happened but disagree on what crime, if any, was committed.
- mentat 11y agoIt is absolutely not this cut and dry even for "simple crimes". Have you sat on a jury for anything substantial?