3 ms·
Not necessarily statistically significant, but of the past 1000 articles submitted: 8 (bbc.co.uk) 9 (techcrunch.com) 10 (arstechnica.com)
by ColinWright 11y ago
Not necessarily statistically significant, but of the past 1000 articles submitted:
8 (bbc.co.uk)
9 (techcrunch.com)
10 (arstechnica.com)
14 (nytimes.com)
14 (theguardian.com)
16 (washingtonpost.com)
16 (youtube.com)
18 (wsj.com)
32 (medium.com)
46 (github.com)
Of the past 10,000:
40 (kickstarter.com)
40 (reddit.com)
40 (theatlantic.com)
44 (forbes.com)
46 (bloomberg.com)
46 (securityaffairs.co)
47 (theverge.com)
56 (bbc.co.uk)
62 (washingtonpost.com)
68 (arstechnica.com)
69 (bbc.com)
70 (businessinsider.com)
74 (wired.com)
82 (wikipedia.org)
102 (wsj.com)
105 (theguardian.com)
157 (nytimes.com)
159 (techcrunch.com)
163 (youtube.com)
339 (medium.com)
485 (github.com)
In case you're wondering, I have a file of all submissions listing ID, userid, URL, and title. Then I did this:
$ tail -n 10000 records \
| gawk '{print $NF}' \
| sort \
| uniq -c \
| sort -n \
| grep -n . \
| tac \
| head -21
- Ntrails 11y agoCould we get some kind of simple mean/variance analysis on "upvotes" by site. Clearly the BBC isn't being spammed to generate upvotes
- kaolinite 11y agoWow, thanks Colin - really cool information. Where do you get the contents of 'records' from? Do you have a script that crawls occasionally? If we merge bbc.com and bbc.co.uk, we end up with 125 / 10,000. I suppose that isn't that many compared to others, but it's still higher than I think it should be. ArsTechnica (which often runs the same articles, such as this SpaceX one) only has 68 / 10,000 and the articles are written with a lot more technical detail. Nevertheless, I'm not really sure what can be done about it. We can't ban the BBC from HN, as with BuzzFeed, because that's over the top - there's some good content. A nice solution might be to remind people, on the submission page, that it's better to go to the source - or at least a good, technical write-up - rather than a news post that is written for the general public.
- ColinWright 11y ago> Where do you get the contents of 'records' from? I download the "newest" and "news" pages every 15 minutes or so, then collate the data. > If we merge bbc.com and bbc.co.uk, we > end up with 125 / 10,000. I suppose > that isn't that many compared to others, It's less than some, but not as many as, say, nytimes.com or techcrunch.com. But it's a major news site, so I'm not surprised people read it and go "Oh, that's interesting, I'll click the HN bookmarklet and submit it." > ... still higher than I think it should be. What do you think it "should be?" > A nice solution might be to remind people, > ... that it's better to go to the source ... I personally find it useful to read a non-technical overview, and then if interested, go and find the technical version. Often the article with technical details borders on unreadable.