8 ms·
Supreme Court Rejects Attempt to Expand Patent Liability, but Limits Defenses
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoThis is a fairly bad ruling. Patents should be thought of as invalid by default, especially considering the rubber stamp methodology used by the USPTO. None of this is addressing how trivial it is to get trivial patents, then use them for monetary gain against those who actually build things. 70 year olds making tech policy is just scary. This is a major boon to "troll" companies and probably sets back any reform movement several years if not decades.
- Zigurd 11y agoThe presumption of validity is ingrained in the patent system. Otherwise, what would a patent grant mean? I've been involved with my own patents and other patents long enough to see the patent office become relatively less rigorous than when I first started patenting things. The response could be to weaken the meaning of a patent grant. Maybe the answer is for the government to offer a bounty to overturn grants of patents. But that implies the patent office would be any better at filtering challenges to patents than they are at filtering applications.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>Otherwise, what would a patent grant mean? Exactly what it is: a government protected idea untested by the courts. If its still untested, it should be assumed invalid. I don't see what's wrong with that. If there is ever a bounty system, it should be via a 3rd party mediator, not the very same USPTO that gives out invalid patents, many often with trivial prior-art or questionable logic like appending "on a touchscreen device," to an ancient computer science concept.
- alienasa 11y ago> Exactly what it is: a government protected idea untested by the courts. If its still untested, it should be assumed invalid. I don't see what's wrong with that. On that assumption, why bother having the USPTO at all? If something "untested by the courts" is invalid, you're effectively appealing to the court as the arbiter of all innovation. However, the court system is not equipped to be evaluating innovation claims, either in terms of time or expertise. I suspect the outcome would be worse.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>why bother having the USPTO at all? Because 18th century economic theory dictated a patent process because back then information moved so slowly it was easy to copy a design and market it as your own with consumers unaware that it was a copy. How this remotely connects to software in the information age is beyond me. I don't see a need for the USPTO at all, outside of trademark protection.
- Retric 11y agoIt's a barrier to entry. Even if the court assumes the patent is invalid without the USPTO it would be easy to bring unlimited trivial nuisance suits with a clear incentive for 3rd party's to settle. It also acts as a clear timestamp. The USPTO patent being assumed invalid is simply to avoid spamming patents until something gets though.
- rayiner 11y agoRelevant: http://patentlyo.com/patent/2014/06/proper-presumption-validity.html http://patentlyo.com/patent/2014/06/proper-presumption-valid... ("According to Justice Breyer’s concurrence, joined by Justices Scalia and Alito, the presumption of validity only provides protection against factual elements of an invalidity challenge. That concurrence, and the Supreme Court’s recent opinion in Nautilus, Inc. v. Biosig Instruments, Inc., suggest that the presumption of validity has no application to purely legal bases for invalidity.")
- anomaly_ 11y agoAssumption of validity isn't the only path. In Australia there is no assumption of validity; the court essentially re-examines the patent when a suit is brought. This doesn't necessarily increase costs/time either, the Federal Court (has patent jurisdiction in Australia) exercises pretty decent case management to ensure that frivolous suits are quickly dealt with.
- monochromatic 11y agoThe USPTO is far from perfect, and examiners make bad calls sometimes... but it is by no means trivial to get a trivial patent issued. And the idea of a presumption of invalidity (as opposed to, say, no presumption one way or the other) is so ludicrous that it doesn't bear response.
- Retric 11y agoIt seems reasonable for courts to avoid injunctions or punitive damages for periods prior to a patent being tested in court. Calling this invalid or no presumption is more or less the same concept.
- monochromatic 11y agoNo, it isn't. The presumption goes to how hard it is to assert a patent in court.
- Retric 11y agoThat's a good thing in this case. Start with 100 junk patents to the USPTO > one gets though. Now take that one and threaten a company. Company says the is a BS patent. Take company to court demand injunction + damages. Company responds it's invalid! Q: Does the court force an injunction anyway? If it does there is huge incentives to settle even if it’s a BS patent.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- PythonicAlpha 11y agoOf course it is not trivial to get a patent application threw, but that is the reason, big corporations have highly paid lawyers for that. The whole thing is a shadow-industry of it's own (starting at the patent office, that earns money by issuing patents).
- jimrandomh 11y agoThe most important text in this Supreme Court ruling is this: > District courts have the authority and responsibility to ensure that frivolous > cases—brought by companies using patents as a sword to go after defendants for > money—are dissuaded, though no issue of frivolity has been raised here. > Safeguards — including, e.g., sanctioning attorneys for bringing such suits, see > Fed. Rule Civ. Proc. 11 — combined with the avenues that accused inducers have > to obtain rulings on the validity of patents, militate in favor of maintaining > the separation between infringement and validity expressed in the Patent Act. > Pp. 13–14 In the past, the district courts have failed utterly to fulfill this responsibility, and I question whether they have the de facto authority. The cited Rules of Civil Procedure - https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp/rule_11 https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp/rule_11 - are not a sufficient tool for the courts to fulfill this responsibility with. While this ruling makes it clear that they must do something, it seems as though it obligates them to invent new legal theories.
- monochromatic 11y agoThe most important text in the opinion is dicta?
- Mithaldu 11y ago> District courts have the authority and responsibility Foreigner here. Interpreting that bit literally makes me think that district courts, having the responsibility, can be held responsible for not fulfilling their responsibility. Is this correct, or is the above just waffly moral wording? If it is correct, what would be the means and path of holding a district court responsible?
- PythonicAlpha 11y agoVery sad, that there is still no courage, to effectively limit weak patents. Weak patents are a hindrance to innovations. In a better world, the patent offices should care for that -- but because they earn money from issuing them, standards have been continuously reduced in the past decades. It also looks better in the "innovation news" of the past year, when more patents can be listed ... but it is just eye-washing.
- higherpurpose 11y agoFirst everyone at the top needs give up on the idea that patents = innovation, therefore more patents = more innovation. I remember until 2-3 years ago even Obama basically said the same thing in his speech, when he passed that new legislation that gives the patent to whoever files for it first. I don't know if he still believes that now, but many still do in the government. If anything, more patents = increased ability to restrict competitors from coming into the market or doing more rent-seeking = less innovation.
- PythonicAlpha 11y agoWe have the same thing in Germany. The problem is not, that the politicians are to ignorant or adhere to wrong believes, but for example our chancellor first met with the big corporation bosses -- and they told her, what "innovation" is in their opinion. And of course, the big corporations have a total different view of innovation than others. It is like asking the dinosaurs, who the most fittest species on earth is.
- guelo 11y agoWhy was the government involved in this case and on the side of patent trolls?
- sectro 11y agoIn general the government is interested in anything that increases the government's power. Stronger patents make them a more powerful tool.
- rhino369 11y agoThe Solicitor General can essentially argue in any SCOTUS case he wants or SCOTUS can invite him to (which is treated as a command, he never declines). While the plaintiff in this case was a troll this isn't a directly troll related case. It applies broadly to all patent holders.
- aaronvonbaron 11y agoI deal with patents day in, day out. With millions of patents issued and many more examined, there is bound to be some real stinkers. Whether or not a patent is allowed depends on the examiner assigned to the case, the art unit (technology category), the prior art patents the examiner finds (they define the outer limits of the patent claims), the skill of the attorney/agent, the name of the company seeking a patent, and, of course, the amount of money thrown at the examination. Some examiner are push-overs. Some examiners are impressed with the assignee name (Google, Apple, and such), and may be more likely to allow. Some examiners seem to take pleasure in rejecting the application, even if they cannot find appropriate prior art. There is variability in the quality of examination. However, there are methods to correct mistakes at the Patent Office. I am often involved with post-grant review procedures to invalidate issued patents. If a patent is truly overly-broad, then it should be possible to find prior art somewhere in the world that can be used to invalidate the patent. The presumption that a patent is valid only applies in court. There is no presumption during reexamination or an inter partes review process. In fact, it is very difficult to defend a patent in post grant review. The patent owner is very likely to lose its patent or find it severely weakened. Also, someone here has pointed out an example or two of terrible patents. Even though issued, these patents could be near useless, because the claims are extremely narrow and are easily designed around, if anyone cares to even do this. Most of these patents are like bees without stingers - still buzzing and spinning around, but harmless and soon to die. One more thing, it irritates me when people in the software world say the patent system is broken and should be abolished, when they may just be looking at it from just a software point of view. There are many true innovations in every field, and at least a few copycats that are waiting for a product to hit big, so they can create a duplicate completing product. Look at the X-Hose getting knocked-off by PocketHose. There should be some protection for those who have created something novel. You can argue that some people would create innovations without the patent system, which is true; but there are many more who would not bother without the prospect of patent protection. One more benefit of the patent system is that, in exchange for a patent, the applicant must fully disclose how to make and use the invention. Instead of sitting in some notebook or Word file, the information is shared. The maintenance fee system (where a patent owner must pay a fee at 3.5, 7.5, and 11.5 years to keep its patent in force) weeds out many patents, as the owner decides that it is no longer worth the money to keep it alive.