4 ms·
> ReCode will become part of Vox’s expanding digital empire, which includes the popular sports site SB Nation, as well as the technology site The Verge. ReCode
by danso 11y ago
> ReCode will become part of Vox’s expanding digital empire, which includes the popular sports site SB Nation, as well as the technology site The Verge. ReCode also will gain access to Vox’s publishing platform, Chorus, which has been a key in luring marquee journalists including Ezra Klein.
Just goes to show how journalists (either the journalists described, or just the NYT author here) are charmed by the mystique of the CMS. I don't care if Chorus is made in Angular 5.0 [1], the robustness of a CMS is not one that makes much difference to the content producers, particularly writing-focused reporters...And the parts that need to be really nice UI/UX (such as slideshow/gallery/quiz creators) aren't necessarily intrinsic to a CMS. A CMS makes a huge deal in ease of publishing...but for most writers, they don't see much difference other than the rich-text editor. It's certainly at the far bottom of reasons to join an organization as a reporter.
[1] it's Rails 3.x IIRC, but perhaps Chorus also encompasses their suite of static publishing tools such as Middleman:
http://product.voxmedia.com/2014/5/29/5759244/vox-media-ruby-rails-upgrade-chorus http://product.voxmedia.com/2014/5/29/5759244/vox-media-ruby...
https://source.opennews.org/en-US/learning/evolution-news-apps-teams/ https://source.opennews.org/en-US/learning/evolution-news-ap...
- jakelear 11y agoWe're on Rails 4 now for the general "Chorus" codebase (but you're right, we include a number of varied apps under the same umbrella when talking about our platform)
- lambdaelite 11y agoI don't understand the obsession with journalism CMS. Articles about Vox Media never seem to fail to mention Chorus. As a news consumer, I don't give a crap about how the sausage is made: I want accurate reporting. I find Vox Media, of all the new media groups, to have a most embarrassing level of sloppy and inaccurate reporting. I can't tolerate blatant and lazy errors. The focus on tools seems misplaced to me. They desperately need a quality system.
- brown9-2 11y agoJournalists focus on the tools because so much of the initial Vox PR was about their tools. It's become a part of the established lore, even if it really doesn't make all that much sense.
- alexqgb 11y agoSaying you don't understand journalism's obsession with CMS is like journalists saying they don't understand HN's obsession with programming languages. "But it's what you do that matters, not how you get it done!" Yeah, sure.
- NeutronBoy 11y agoIt's more equivalent to caring about what language HN is written in.
- lambdaelite 11y agoThat's accurate. I think the obsession with programming languages on HN is also misplaced. Choice of programming language is far from the most important aspect of the SDLC, as I see things. I'm admittedly an atypical HN reader.
- gone35 11y agoFor me it's worse: all I see are constant overheads between trivial prefix-free equivalents... But then I also love C and hate everything Python with a passion, so go figure.
- hueving 11y agoThe CMS they use doesn't force them to use a different language. A better equivalent would be people arguing over emacs vs vim
- alexqgb 11y agoAh, but when every publisher has their own system, going from place to place can make for some pretty rough transitions. The question comes down to whether you work for the system or if the system works for you.
- smcnally 11y agoMany of the people involved are doing more than rich text editing. They're curating and packaging stories. They're promoting these packages within and outside of their site. They're enriching stories with images and meta data. Sometimes there are editing and approval workflows. It's not all as simple as it seems. When you've got a bunch of specialists, integrating the pieces is the challenge. Usually, you've got people responsible for broad swaths of the process: journos learning marketing; marketers learning copy editing; editors learning SEO. The CMS is where a lot of this gets created, integrated, and published.
- govindkabra31 11y agoWouldn't high-quality-CMS be important to bring down the cost of publishing-- to the point of determining the sustainability of the publication itself? The established media companies are struggling, if I had to describe in one line, because contemporary revenues cannot sustain their traditional cost structure. You would otherwise need staff to coordinate between photographer, and onsite attendee and social media curator finding tweets to go with that story, and generally different parts being curated by different team members. You also want to optimize the "review" workflow, to maximize the page views by landing the story quickly vs. other publications.
- nl 11y agoSo maybe the best CMS in the world saves you 10% in costs over an averagely competent CMS. It's not really a material difference in terms of sustainability. You are correct in stating that established media companies are struggling because of their cost structures. But those cost structures are mostly salaries (and capital investments in buildings etc) rather than something that a magic CMS can fix. Put it like this: when a "new media journalist" uses their mobile phone to take a picture for their story (instead of a staff photographer) that has made a bigger difference in terms of cost structure than the worlds-best CMS can make.
- venomsnake 11y agoA low friction, high power CMS is hard to do - I maintain from time to time our in house and it will probably get lowest possible scores on any usability ranking. Considering what Vox.com has turned into lately - not sure that mentioning Ezra is good thing. The old Wonkblog was classes above that crap.