4 ms·
Sigh "The 5-mile test track is estimated to cost about $100 million, which Hyperloop Transportation Technologies hopes to pay for with its initial public offer
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Sigh
"The 5-mile test track is estimated to cost about $100 million, which Hyperloop Transportation Technologies hopes to pay for with its initial public offering (IPO) later this year, according to Navigant's blog."
Run away, run far far away. They might as well do a kickstarter. Seriously, what sort of "business" is a 5 mile test track?
Lets say you charged $25 for a "5 minute ride on the hyperloop!" and you got 8 people in it, and you had perfect efficiency, and you ran non-stop for 10 hrs a day, 7 days a week then $100M is 414 days. And that isn't including the cost of running the ride in the first place. I guess I'll find out why they think I should think about investing in their S-1 but for right now, I am totally not seeing it.
- gargarplex 11y ago$/mi will reduce with scale.
- jacquesm 11y agoThat's an interesting one. This is actually contrary to most conventional wisdom regarding such projects, rail for instance does not have a reduced cost / mile if the distances get longer. (Airtravel does, however).
- pavlov 11y agoAs an IPO this sounds similar to most biotech/pharma startups. These companies routinely IPO in the $50-100 million range when all they have is a patent, some promising data but no approved clinical trials and no business. Of course it's different because there's a clear post-IPO acquisition market for biotechs. Not quite as clear who would buy Hyperloop if it's proven to work...
- bliti 11y agoIt seems to be related to how startups are suddenly valuated at billions without much of a moat or intrinsic value. Just for having "users".
- minot 11y agoMeh. If I give you $100 for a 1*10^-6% stake in your company with a guarantee that you will pay me back at least $100 before honoring any other debts or issue, are you really a ten billion dollar startup?
- zaroth 11y agoIt's most entertaining to subtract any preference off the top of the valuation. I wish it became a trend. Particularly for preferences with multipliers!
- pbreit 11y agoYou should not. But a lot of (more positively thinking) people might like the risk/reward. After all, Elon is 4 for 4 in making people fabulously wealthy off very-hard-to-do projects (I know he's not officially involved but some of his people are like Sacks and Pishevar are).
- ChuckMcM 11y agoFor me, it isn't a positive / negative thinking thing. What I struggle with is the series of steps that this company goes through which have it justifying a valuation of even $100M (which it won't because nobody IPO's all of the equity, so for a $100M raise they are probably assuming a $1B valuation). If you have some thoughts on how that would work please share them. I'd like to learn. I'm guessing (and I will know more when I read their S-1) that they build their test track, they prove out the concept, then win a contract to build a larger one from one of the states? So how far does that $100M get them? Does it get the 5-mile track built and operating? Looking at other complex projects, say the London Eye, which cost $100M in 1999. And it's just a Ferris wheel. I don't know of a 5 mile rail project that has cost less than about half a billion but I would certainly grant you that those tend to be bid on by cost+ contractors. So I'm just trying to connect the dots on how they "go to market" as it were.
- stephengillie 11y agoThis reminds me of the Seattle Monorail, which continues to operate today. For a few dollars, you can ride swiftly and smoothly from one part of Downtown Seattle to another part of Downtown Seattle. Some day, scientists hope, the value of the monorail will be seen. That day, we expect to extend the rail line to other communities. Meanwhile, we just pulled a tunneling machine out of its boring hole, continue to expand the Link Light Rail system, and are developing various trolley-based solutions such as the ones in South Lake Union and First Hill.
- Shivetya 11y agooh, that 600 million dollar per mile tunnel? not a great use of transportation dollars, think of how many EV buses they could buy, which on the whole buses tend to go where people want and do it more often than light rail which not only costs a fortune to build but maintain as well
- stephengillie 11y agoWe had a mayor (McGinn) that wanted to connect neighborhoods with light rail and trolleys. We voted him out to get the crazy tunnel plan. And after spending all this money, we're going ahead with light rail and trolleys. Everyone's been hearing about Bertha and the tunnel calamity, but almost nobody's heard about the trolley that connects 6 neighborhoods, was installed in about 6 months, and it's already done.
- goodcanadian 11y agoI won't defend that project specifically because I know nothing about it, but I would like to offer a couple of comments: As a passenger, I have always found the experience of riding rail to be far superior to riding a bus for a lot of reasons including but not limited to speed and comfort. A train generally has much higher capacity than buses, and if well utilised, a lower operating cost per passenger. An ideal transport system will use trains for the high traffic trunk routes and a tightly integrated bus system as feeders for the train line. It should never be expressed as an either/or proposition. Both are necessary.
- digikata 11y agoThe purpose would be to learn more about the inevitable practical problems that come up between a system concept that pencils out to be more efficient and a real operating system. I think we stand on the shoulders of giants giving an incredible science and tech foundation to work upon. However, all that knowledge can give us a false sense of how difficult it is to cross into unknown territory (e.g. when assembling a new system from well understood elements, like hyperloop).
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI understand the purpose, but what I don't understand yet is why would you ask retail investors to fund it at this level of risk? Remember, these guys aren't associated with Musk in any way [1], they are just taking the ball and running with it. So huge risk, probably going to flame out, very small chance they become the folks with the 'expertise' in building Hyperloop type systems and thus the primary engineering contractor for building them. Since they aren't one of the big engineering infrastructure companies (Halliburton, Bechtel, Etc.) its unclear what they can do if they run into hiccups (like say nobody can fabricate the parts they need). So do a $100M series A? Sure I could see that, a collection of billionaires wishing to bet on them making something that can work, but we should have trained people in the 90's to not buy stock in companies that have no hope of revenue in the forseeable future. (and say what you will of the recent Tech IPO's they have all had revenue) [1] "Now, the company Hyperloop Transportation Technologies Inc. (which is not affiliated with Musk or Tesla) has inked a deal with landowners in central California to build the world's first Hyperloop test track"
- digikata 11y agoAs long as the investment context is disclosed, why shouldn't there be long range, high-risk investments available in the market to interested buyers? Edit: I agree with you that the risk is very, very high. But, it at least gives a non-zero potential for investment return - which on that level is better than, say, Kickstarter.
- danielweber 11y ago
- jonknee 11y agoWell obviously the end goal for Hyperloop Transportation Technologies isn't to run a 5-mile test track amusement park. It's a test track, quite simply a test to work out the kinks and try and make hyperloop a real thing. It almost certainly won't work, but at scale it would be big dollar territory (California's high speed rail effort alone is $68 billion and China is spending many times that).
- ropman76 11y agoI want this to succeed. I want to engineering team(s) to crush all the issues that people have raised here and elsewhere. That being said most cutting edge engineering projects like this don't make money for a very long time and I wouldn't invest any money I want to see a return on.
- rhino369 11y agoPresumably for the IP and institutional knowledge that is generated by actually designing a working prototype. Then HTT could propose actually building one with them running the project. I doubt it will work, but it's not a stupid plan.