5 ms·
I don't think this article is representative of current serious thought about black holes. I'm a bit out of date on this stuff, and I was never any sort of exp
by amluto 11y ago
I don't think this article is representative of current serious thought about black holes. I'm a bit out of date on this stuff, and I was never any sort of expert, but let's see:
1. This reality splitting thing sounds wrong. I've never heard of it. Ignoring quantum effects, if you fall into a black hole and survive crossing the horizon, Anne will see you get closer and closer to the horizon, but she won't see you get there. She won't see you burnt up and she certainly won't collect your ashes. The only fundamental difference between what you see and what Anne sees is that by the time she gets bored of watching, you will only have perceived a tiny amount of time passing.
2. Free fall doesn't protect you from burnination. If the horizon is surrounded by enough fire and brimstone and you free fall through it, you're still going to burn to a crisp.
3. If I remember my old problem set correctly, a black hole big enough for you to live your life in would be truly huge. IIRC the supermassive black hole at the center of the Milky Way would give you about 0.1 ms before you hit the singularity.
- dvdkhlng 11y agoI think the "current serious thought about black holes" is about quantum theoretical effects at the event horizon. Seems there are some problems with reconciling quantum entanglement at the horizon with the fact that nothing can return from beyond the event horizon apart from Hawking radiation. This results in the "Firewall Paradox" [1]. One of the proposed resolutions of the paradox is the claim that directly at the event horizon, invisible to outside observers, a kind of ultra-thin particle inferno exists due to the breakdown of entanglement. This would make it effectively impossible to enter any black hole. (I don't really understand any of this, consult wikipedia and the referenced articles for more correct explanations). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firewall_%28physics%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firewall_%28physics%29
- jerf 11y ago"This reality splitting thing sounds wrong. I've never heard of it." It's a strange scientific truth filtered through at least one scientist filtered through at least one journalist filtered through at least one editor. The reality is stranger... even if there's no firewall, there's still only one reality, with all the observers seeing all the different things. As for your 2, yes, it is likely there isn't a single black hole in the universe that meets our criteria for being able to "safely" fall into it, but at least in theory such a beast could exist, and barring any other unexpected existence failures, such a beast may exist in the far, far, far future. There's a lot of future and most of it is pretty boring....
- derekp7 11y agoBased on your point 1, if time (on the outside) seems to speed up infinitely for the person falling into the black hole, and if the black hole will eventually evaporate due to hawking radiation, then wouldn't the black hole appear to completely evaporate prior to crossing the event horizon?
- amluto 11y agoIndeed. I never really understood how things ever actually make it through the horizon in the first place (as seen by far-away observers) in order to make the black hole grow. I /think/ what's going on is that, from the outside, you never really see a big black hole. Instead, you see what is, for all practical purposes, a big black hole, but really it's an exceedingly dense band of stuff, red-shifted to the point of invisibility, around the horizon. Of course, once you go close enough to inspect it for real, you get caught up in the time dilation enough that it looks more and more like a real black hole. If you go through the horizon, everything that ought to have preceeded you through the horizon already has, and it all makes sense. The math for this is quite hairy [1] and I suspect that we're mostly limited to numerical simulations. The closed-form steady-state black hole metrics are gnarly enough as is. [1] Terrible pun -- look up the "no-hair theorem"
- yellowapple 11y ago> If I remember my old problem set correctly, a black hole big enough for you to live your life in would be truly huge. IIRC the supermassive black hole at the center of the Milky Way would give you about 0.1 ms before you hit the singularity. Would that be from the point-of-view of the one crossing the event horizon or from the point-of-view of the observer? If that 0.1ms is from the POV of the latter, then - due to relativistic time dilation - that could easily add up to one or more lifetimes for the event-horizon-crosser, no?
- amluto 11y agoNo, not really. This is "proper time", i.e. time as measured by the unfortunate person in the space ship who's falling in. The observer outside never sees you hit the event horizon in the first place, so I'm not sure it's well-defined to talk about how long an outside observer thinks it takes you to hit the horizon once you've crossed the singularity. Incidentally, one thing the article got right is that time and space are kind of switched inside the black hole. Once you cross the horizon, the singularity is no longer something that's radially inward from you. Instead the singularity is in your future, kind of like tomorrow is in my future. This is part of why you can't escape. Once you're inside, it makes no sense to fire your rockets to push yourself backwards in time. In fact, firing your rockets just makes it worse. You'll accelerate, and the resulting time dilation will actually /reduce/ the perceived time before you hit the doom in your future. This is a big difference between GR black holes and toy classical black hole models. In a classical black hole (a point mass and an "event horizon" around it where the escape velocity exceeds the speed of light), you can try to throw something outside the horizon, and it might escape the horizon, but it's guaranteed to fall back in unless someone catches it or it has rockets and can continue propelling itself outward. In a real GR black hole, you can't cross the horizon from the inside in the first place. Despite this, if you squint a bit, the toy classical model predicts the Schwarzchild radius correctly
- rwallace 11y agoMy (also non-expert) understanding of current serious thought about black holes is that the event horizon is conjectured to be arbitrarily hot in the frame of reference of an observer hovering arbitrarily close to it. In the frame of reference of an observer falling into the black hole it's just empty space, and in the frame of reference of a distant observer the firewall is redshifted out of existence and only the Hawking temperature of the black hole is visible. But the existence of the frame of reference in which the event horizon reaches the Planck temperature suffices to justify the Schrodinger's cat style resolution of the paradox.