4 ms·
I invented a puzzle some time ago I haven't solved yet: Calculate how often on average oldest person in the world dies. Assume whatever is necessary to give t
by scotty79 11y ago
I invented a puzzle some time ago I haven't solved yet:
Calculate how often on average oldest person in the world dies.
Assume whatever is necessary to give the answer. For example that population pyramid is constant over time and known.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Someone 11y agohttp://math.stackexchange.com/questions/349155/how-often-does-it-happen-that-the-oldest-person-alive-dies http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/349155/how-often-doe...
- simcop2387 11y agoWhat i find interesting there is that multiple approaches seemed to arrive at about the same result, 2/3 of a year between deaths. That makes me think it's highly probable that it's the right answer for the current time period at least.
- scotty79 11y agoAwesome. But forgive me not reading the answers. I want this to remain puzzle for me. I don't want to learn the answer. I want to invent it some day. Same way I feel about Rubik's cube. I still have fond memories about finding out precise recursive equation, implementing it in LOGO for Atari and waiting minutes to find out the answer to how many times you have to try to burn all matches in a box by picking them from the box one by one at random, lighting them and putting them back in the box before picking next one.
- gwern 11y agoNote that one of the answers there is based on the GRG data used in OP. Different graph but same conclusion - average tenure has dropped, Calment was a monster.
- pwoeir 11y agoSaying "one of the answers" is a very modest way of referring to your own answer ;)
- pwoeir 11y agoOh, neat - I wrote the top answer there (over two years ago apparently!) I stand by the modelling, although it's embarrassing to read my two year old code.
- Rainymood 11y agoReminds me of the guy who answered some question about Python how to put two strings together, and then 3 years later commented 'Oh look here I am asking the same question I answered' lol
- Someone 11y agoI found that model somewhat overkill. I would have cut some corners there: assume that the oldest person alive is 110 or older (reasonable, given a world population in the billions and the data we have) and compute his (more likely her) hazard rate from the curve you fitted. For hazard rates at old age, taking life expectancy equal to 0.5/hazard rate isn't an extremely bad approximation (I have no education in actuarial science and gave that little thought; corrections welcome), so one gets: age h(age) life expectancy 109 0.473 1.058 110 0.503 0.993 111 0.536 0.933 112 0.570 0.876 113 0.607 0.824 114 0.645 0.775 115 0.685 0.730 116 0.728 0.687 Again, we get in the range of that 2/3-ish.
- bandrami 11y agoIt's just a Poisson process
- TheLoneWolfling 11y ago...Except that: * Birth rates are changing * Mortality rates are changing * For any one person, the chance of dying (generally) increases as they grow older * Deaths are correlated. For instance, things like the 2003 tsunami.
- scotty79 11y agoI could be satisfied by solution that doesn't take into account three of your points. But the 3rd one is something I can't ignore.