4 ms·
> In turn, that makes it feel odd that the prevailing opinion in these parts is often that the police enforce things too harshly, but the cure for every economi
by pas 11y ago
> In turn, that makes it feel odd that the prevailing opinion in these parts is often that the police enforce things too harshly, but the cure for every economic and social ill is always more Government micro-managing...
Show a principle that is broader than introducing new micro-regulations but would result in better outcomes. Considering the complexity of our reality, I doubt it's possible. Edge cases, functional requirements of life are numerous, and sure, there are a lot of old policies on the books, simply removing them would also cause too much perturbations. And no one cares enough about abstract efficiency, elegance and such to propose and fight for a plant to gradually deprecate them. (Minor examples are various tax exemptions, major example is the whole social security problem looming on the horizon. And the whole problem of healthcare economics fits here. People are rational, but have nasty time-dependent preference inversions, just to point out a problem with going with a simple and general solution.)
And this not too surprisingly has nothing to do with too harsh enforcement of some laws. (You just guessed the war on drugs. And general over-militarization of the police and the hostility of the criminal justice system.)
- BurningFrog 11y ago> Show a principle that is broader than introducing new micro-regulations but would result in better outcomes The alternative to regulating what, how and when everyone should do everything is to let people do what they want, but allow anyone to sue if they damage people or property. If it results in better outcomes is of course debatable, but it has a long and defendable track record.
- LLWM 11y agoThis system has a long and defendable track record of encouraging assholes to commit small violations that are not worth suing over, while penalizing those that are considerate of others.
- acdha 11y ago> but allow anyone to sue if they damage people or property. That's the same as saying the only people who should get justice are those with the wealth and free time to file lawsuits for everything. Consider, say, the case of a company over-billing you – are you going to take time of work, pay to hire lawyers, maybe retain an expert witness to attack the credibility of their billing system, etc. or will you just write it off and pay the extra $50? Companies which do things like that tend to do them on a scale where they can afford to pay for tons of attorneys to make that job as hard as possible. (Oh, wait, bad news will spread and the invisible hand will correct that! That's sure worked wonders for Comcast…)
- BurningFrog 11y agoThe sarcastic answer is that the current system favor those with the wealth and free time to purchase enough lobbying to get the regulations they want. But you're of course right that perfect automatic justice doesn't arise in either system. I'm a big fan of the "loser pays" system for lawsuits that's very common outside the US. That means that it's economically risk free both to file suits and to be sued if the court rules in your favor. Your Comcast story is more about class action law suits, which I think can be a worthwhile feature of a legal system.
- acdha 11y agoI like the idea of loser pays for certain classes of abuse but you need some mechanism to counter the innate tendency to deter the non-rich from filing a lawsuit in all but the most certain of cases. Some sort of a good faith exemption would be nice but it'd have to be very carefully constructed. This becomes particularly obvious when you look at things which aren't extremely clear-cut cases. Say the company across the street is polluting. With a remotely-competent regulatory system, you can contact the local government and they [hopefully] have funding to investigate. With a lawsuit-driven system, you'd have to be prepared to pay for all of that out of pocket while trying to demonstrate direct losses for something which is rarely be more precise than a statistical likelihood in the hope that you'll eventually be compensated. With loser pays, you now have the risk of having to pick up the tab for the company's top-notch legal team, too, which gives them powerful leverage to push you towards a settlement if the case isn't going 100% your way – after all, it's only your house that's on the line. If the company loses, it's not like the CEO has to pay for it personally. The reason why we have the regulatory agencies we have is because we've already proven that the “do whatever you want and sue if it goes wrong” approach doesn't work well. The better question to debate is how to make those regulators more effective and responsive