2 ms·
I don't see why, if you can torture someone into saying words, you can't also torture someone into playing a game. People can be coerced into doing anything th
by derefr 12y ago
I don't see why, if you can torture someone into saying words, you can't also torture someone into playing a game.
People can be coerced into doing anything they would do normally (unlocking a lock; supplying their fingerprint; phoning their conspirator and saying to go ahead with the plan.) True coercion-resistance, I would think, implies that the mechanism has the ability to differentiate a stimulus supplied under coercion, even under the assumption that Mallet could have fed Alice some anti-anxiety drugs to regularize detectable symptoms of stress in her behaviour. (Coincidentally, "truth serums"—i.e. low-dose dissociative anaesthetics, ketamine or PCP being just as workable as sodium pentathol—also have anxiolytic effects. I can't imagine a state actor wouldn't take advantage of this if the goal is coercion rather than torture-for-the-sake-of-torture.)
As far as I know, there is one single useful mechanism for coercion-resistance: precommitment with counterparties. If Alice and Bob are supposed to have no further contact once the plan is in motion, and Bob knows this, then it is useless to torture Alice into contacting Bob—Bob will take the contact itself as a signal that Alice has been compromised.
You can automate this; if Alice (or her device) must attend regular KEx parties to get a new key (i.e. participate in a protocol with a security ratchet), then capturing her or her device prevents her from doing this, and so expires her key material (kicks her keys out of the keybag, basically.)