3 ms·
New Zealand. We went through a very painful era in the late 70s when agricultural subsidies were removed, it ended a lot of farms that were unsustainable withou
by EdwardDiego 11y ago
New Zealand. We went through a very painful era in the late 70s when agricultural subsidies were removed, it ended a lot of farms that were unsustainable without them, with some farmers committing suicide and some very painful impacts on rural communities, but our agricultural sector is much the better for it. The fact that we can compete effectively in the EU and USA against subsidised and tariff-protected local farmers despite the tyranny of distance is an indication of it.
Unfortunately, our current government is leaning towards indirect subsidisation of aspects of the agricultural sector via funding for irrigation works and omitting action on the environmental externalities of intensive dairying, but we'll never again be in a place where people are being paid just for owning animals or growing a certain crop.
- saalweachter 11y agoJust out of curiosity, what were the agricultural subsidies like in NZ before they were abolished? In the US, the direct subsidies are something like $0.25 / bushel for most grains, with price guarantees of around $2 / bushel. Market rates tend to be $4-15 / bushel, depending on the grain. There are, of course, indirect subsidies through the beef and ethanol industries, but that gets more complex. I'm curious if the NZ subsidies were more distorted than that -- in the US, the subsidies will definitely encourage over-production (which I consider a good thing), but I'm not intrinsically bothered by a $0.25 / bushel subsidy on $4-7 / bushel corn.
- vram22 11y agoInteresting, is the term "bushel" still used? I'd have thought it was somewhat archaic by now (having only read it in that context in children's stories, as a kid), but what do I know.
- saalweachter 11y agoIn the US, bushels are the standard measurement of grains, at least as far as farmers are concerned. Whenever I hear about relief being sent to a place with a famine, it is always tons of grain, so it definitely isn't a universal measurement. But prices and yields are still discussed in bushels. Hilariously, while the bushel started out as a volume -- 8 dry gallons, which are totally different from liquid gallons -- they are now a measurement of the weight of a specific grain at a specific moisture content. So to measure a grain, you need to measure its weight and its moisture content, convert it to its weight at the specific moisture content, and then divide it by the standard weight for the grain. So if you have a thousand pounds of corn at 20% moisture, it is just under 17 bushels, but if it were soybeans, just over 15.