3 ms·
I think this is exactly it. I'm always annoyed when I hear people talking about how healthy something is because it's natural, purely because it's natural. Th
by kbenson 12y ago
I think this is exactly it. I'm always annoyed when I hear people talking about how healthy something is because it's natural, purely because it's natural. There are plenty of natural things that can outright kill you if you eat them, that doesn't make them any less natural. It's an excuse to not have to think critically about the problem.
I'll be the first to admit I don't always eat very well, but doing something as extreme as some of the fad diets that have popped up is (in some cases) like deciding to walk everywhere myself because I'm concerned about some unsafe driving habits I have. There is a middle ground with positive aspects and less negative consequences, it just takes some thought and effort.
- coldtea 12y ago>It's an excuse to not have to think critically about the problem. The way those people mean "natural" refers to things that people have been eating for millenia, not merely any natural thing. They very well know that poisonous mushrooms and rocks are natural but not edible. "Natural" in the context of food has a more constrained meaning than the main dictionary definition of "appears in nature". It means edible food products without additives or artificial preservatives. So this thing about those people "talking about how healthy something is because it's natural, purely because it's natural" is a huge strawman.
- kbenson 12y ago> The way those people mean "natural" refers to things that people have been eating for millenia, not merely any natural thing. No, it doesn't always mean that. Until recently I've mostly heard it in the context of "minimal processing". The whole paleo diet thing is much more recent interpretation of "natural", or at least it's more recent to the public at large (IMO). > They very well know that poisonous mushrooms and rocks are natural but not edible. Of course they know that some natural things are dangerous and deadly, it's this exact cognitive dissonance that I'm describing, and this is the problem. Adherence to a rule that we all know to be false (even those proposing it), while ignoring the times the rule isn't followed because it makes no sense, doesn't lead to useful results, it leads to dissatisfaction. I don't see this as any different than the many previous hopelessly simplistic strategies for dealing with food. Fat is bad, caffeine is bad, alcohol is bad. Then, some fat is good, caffeine can had positive effects, alcohol in moderation helps. People strive for simple rules to help manage the complexity of their lives, and the multitude of choices we have. Unfortunately, simple rules rarely encapsulate a good strategy for a complex system, and we are very complex system, even just our dietary needs. Of all the places where (societally) we should accept, even encourage, some complexity and the required critical thinking is brings, I think our health is a good candidate.