7 ms·
Persistence of Long-Term Memory in Vitrified and Revived C. elegans worms
- ejstronge 11y agoTake this with a huge block of salt. This PDF is of a paper recently accepted by an unremarkable journal. Further, the research is sponsored by a company that performs cryonics. If this is true, it may be exciting but we should wait for others to replicate these findings.
- murbard2 11y agoAlcor is not a company, it's a nonprofit organization.
- gojomo 11y agoNon-profits are companies, too.
- gwern 11y agoI don't see why we should be skeptical. It seems to lack the usual warning signs like small samples or questionable statistics, and, for all the skepticism most laymen have ('but how do we know vitrification does preserve memory even if it preserves everything else?!') this is what one should have expected, if only from related instances like comas and drownings - whatever memory is physically encoded as, exactly, it's clearly not ultra-evanescent.
- ejstronge 11y agoI think there are a few causes for concern regarding this paper: 1. Rejuvenation Research isn't a widely-recognized biology journal. If this is the first time memories have been recovered from a cryopreserved organism, this should be in a top journal as it's great news. 2. The article was accepted on the day it was received[ref 1]. This doesn't inspire confidence in the strength of the associated peer review as such minimal review is unusual in biology. Indeed, the average review time for the journal is about 4 weeks[ref 2] (which itself is a short time). 3. This is pretty concerning - the key protocol used in the paper hasn't been published (see reference 14 in the PDF). While it's described in passing in this paper, there's no way to assess the full protocol. 4. There's a juxtaposition between the authors' new technique and an established protocol for freezing C. elegans. However, the authors only freeze C. elegans for 30 minutes in their protocol whereas they freeze organisms in the established protocol testing group for 2 weeks. There seem to be appropriate controls but this difference in protocol is stated very unclearly. References 1. http://online.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/rej.2014.1636 http://online.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/rej.2014.1636 2. http://www.liebertpub.com/DContent/Files/FastFacts/FastFacts_RejuvenationResearch.pdf http://www.liebertpub.com/DContent/Files/FastFacts/FastFacts...
- gwern 11y ago> If this is the first time memories have been recovered from a cryopreserved organism, this should be in a top journal as it's great news. Cryonics related research never gets published in top journals no matter its quality, so this is what you would expect. There is a long-standing war by cryobiologists on anything to do with cryonics - the old canards like the exploding lysosomes o' death may have been refuted but last I heard, they were still explicitly banning from membership any cryonicists. > 2. The article was accepted on the day it was received[ref 1]. Look up the journal policies and note the dates: it was posted the day it was received, as part of Liebert Instant Online/LION http://www.liebertpub.com/forauthors/rejuvenation-research/127/ http://www.liebertpub.com/forauthors/rejuvenation-research/1... but that doesn't mean it was reviewed or accepted in a day: > To enable the release of new scientific findings as quickly as possible, the Journal has a policy of pre-publishing all manuscripts in their unedited format upon acceptance. The papers will have undergone full peer review but will not yet have been copyedited, typeset, or proofread/corrected by the authors. All accepted papers appear online within 72 hours of acceptance as a part of Liebert Instant Online (LION). Given the editing gap is at least October 2014 - April 2015... > 3. This is pretty concerning - the key protocol used in the paper hasn't been published Reference 14 is to the SafeSpeed cryopreservation protocol, not to vitrification in general. They also tested out traditional vitrification. If you distrust SafeSpeed, you can throw out that entire part of the paper and the results are exactly the same: preservation of olfactory memory. (This was covered on pg3, I don't know how you missed it if you could look up the reference number...) > However, the authors only freeze C. elegans for 30 minutes in their protocol whereas they freeze organisms in the established protocol testing group for 2 weeks. ? The 30 minutes refers to the traditional vitrification itself (this is why it's 'slow') where they're immersed in Ln2, but then they were all stored in some more regular freezers at -80 celsius (much warmer than LN2) for several weeks (pg11-12).
- ejstronge 11y ago> There is a long-standing war by cryobiologists on anything to do with cryonics - the old canards like the exploding lysosomes o' death may have been refuted but last I heard, they were still explicitly banning from membership any cryonicists I'm not sure what to say here - politics definitely plays into biology publication but there are multiple well-respected journals to send 'small results', of which I don't believe Rejuvenation Research is one. > Look up the journal policies and note the dates I did exactly this. Unless Rejuvenation Research has an unusual application of the terms 'Received' and 'Accepted' (see ref. 1), I'm more inclined to believe the information on the article page than a general journal policy. Weirdly enough, all the articles in the most recently published edition of Rejuvenation Research (http://online.liebertpub.com/toc/rej/18/2 http://online.liebertpub.com/toc/rej/18/2) had at least some gap between receipt and acceptance. I'm even more inclined to think something unusual has started to happen with the current batch of online-before-publication papers. This could, of course, be a bug with the journal's content management system. > Reference 14 is to the SafeSpeed cryopreservation protocol Publishing a reference to an non-peer-reviewed protocol is unusual, irrespective of the details. This is even more unusual when the protocol forms the core of the paper. To be a bit more precise (using details from the paper): Vitrification and slow-freezing are distinct methodologies for preserving specimen. The authors only use two methodologies for preservation, which they explain in the methods section: The cryopreservation methods included worms that were trained and cryopreserved by vitrification and worms that were trained and cryopreserved by slow freezing > If you distrust SafeSpeed, you can throw out that entire part of the paper and the results are exactly the same: preservation of olfactory memory I think this is part of why my original comment said we should wait for replication and be skeptical. Trust in science is a difficult thing to gain and an easy thing to lose. The choice of journal and the very-unclear description of the cryopreservation protocols make me a bit more skeptical of the results. The SafeSpeed protocol seems to be under review at Nature Methods. If it's accepted there, the authors will likely need to supply supporting data which will only bolster the claims they made here. Further, the slow-freezing result is a fairly cheap one to replicate; we're likely to see many people try it and they'll likely cite Alcor's work. > The 30 minutes refers to the traditional vitrification itself I think the authors were intentionally vague in comparing the two preservation methods, especially given how clear the rest of the report is. First, note that only one vitrification technique was used, SafeSpeed. Additionally, only one slow-freezing technique was used, a standard approach that one of your sibling commenters references in passing. The SafeSpeed-vitrified animals were stored in liquid nitrogen (LN2) for 30 minutes and then recovered. This is stated (unclearly) in the methods section (pg 8) and alluded to in the discussion. > 30 minutes refers to the traditional vitrification itself (this is why it's 'slow') This is counter to what the authors state - they explain that the SafeSpeed method is actually slower than 'slow-freezing'. See page 11. Conclusion I think that this will be exciting if SafeSpeed gets published somewhere more reputable. As you alluded to earlier, if there is a physical correlate to benzaldehyde training that isn't damaged upon freezing, we'd definitely expect it to be recovered after freezing. This paper just isn't compelling enough to say that we've seen this occur definitively. References 1. http://online.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/rej.2014.1636 http://online.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/rej.2014.1636 'Received' usually indicates receipt of a manuscript; 'Accepted' usually indicates the end of scientific edits. Often, articles are held up (i.e., not published online) to coordinate publishing with other labs/projects within a lab.
- IndianAstronaut 11y agoWhen I used to work with C elegans, whenever we would freeze the worms and try and recover them, we would be lucky to even get a few revived from thousands of worms. This result should also be made available in the paper.
- crablar 11y agoCold storage
- dcminter 11y agoNot directly related, but it reminded me of this: http://everything2.com/title/The+ability+of+planarian+worms+to+run+a+maze+more+successfully+after+being+fed+the+remains+of+a+successful+worm http://everything2.com/title/The+ability+of+planarian+worms+...
- reasonattlm 11y agoCryonics is the low-temperature preservation of the deceased in order to grant them a chance at a renewed life when technologies for restoration are developed. One of the big outstanding questions is the degree to which a well-conducted cryopreservation successfully preserves the fine structure of the brain and thus the data of the mind. The fact that cold water drowning victims can live again after an hour or more of brain death tells us that memory is encoded in physical structures, with the current consensus (not undisputed) suggesting it is located in synaptic connections between neurons. Scanning technologies have been used to show that cryopreservation via vitrification of cryoprotectant-infused tissue does indeed preserve the fine structure of brain cell connections. E.g.: http://www.brainpreservation.org/content/competitors http://www.brainpreservation.org/content/competitors So it seems reasonable to move forward with initiatives based on the theory that yes, cryonics is going to preserve the mind. Certainly all too many people are left with no other viable option for a shot at a longer life in the future. There is always the need for more and better proof, however. At the present time studies involving restoration of vitrified individuals must be carried out in lower animals, unfortunately, as researchers are still far from the point at which they can safely restore vitrified mammals. That said, restoration of a vitrified mammalian organs has been demonstrated, though even that is very early stage work in the grand scheme of things.
- stefantalpalaru 11y ago> cold water drowning victims can live again after an hour or more of brain death They don't reach brain death. The cold causes a drop in the oxygen requirements, but the brain keeps on living.
- ciphergoth 11y agoIndeed. If by "brain death" you mean "massive ischemic damage", then cryopreservation under good circumstances also takes place before brain death.
- vegedor 11y ago> memory is encoded in physical structures well, what else, a dynamic flux in a meta-physical hyperplane? :) I understand you mean it's kinda static.
- trhway 11y agowell, today we can restore information - sound - from a photo of the gramophone recording media (https://mediapreservation.wordpress.com/2012/06/20/extracting-audio-from-pictures/ https://mediapreservation.wordpress.com/2012/06/20/extractin...). Tomorrow - from a frozen brain. So, i wonder, if i had enough money - may be instead of whole body or head cryonics, i should go for sub-micron thick slicing of my brain and making photo and various other wavelength scans of it and storing this digitized info somewhere (like Glacier :) Or may be i should just start a start-up offering just such a service to make money for my future cryonics :)
- thms 11y agoThat would make brain perservation via digitalization a lot more viable. But just imaging the precise connection points and volume of neurons might not be enough if every cell's DNA is methylated in a slightly different way, i.e. depending on the memory is is part of not just the general brain region. Then every neuron's DNA has to be specially sequenced to extract that information, and until such a technology can be applied to all the billions of neurons the brain has to be kept on ice.
- tim333 11y agoI think you'd be a bit ahead of things trying scanning now given we don't really know how memories are stored. Quite likely as chemical changes which are going to be subtle to pick up. Also Glaicer's going to cost you - cheaper to chuck the head in the freezer. If you're looking for a startup idea you could give plastination a go. It may also preserve memory information and gets around having to store liquid nitrogen and all that: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_Worlds http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_Worlds
- gwern 11y agoThis is a good question. There's a lot of active research into chemical fixation and then doing brain scanning on thin slices to reconstruct the connectome and other features, with regular progress like "High-resolution whole-brain staining for electron microscopic circuit reconstruction", Mikula & Denk 2015 http://connectomes.org/pdf/mikula2015_.pdf http://connectomes.org/pdf/mikula2015_.pdf . I have some more links in http://www.gwern.net/plastination http://www.gwern.net/plastination The upsides to chemical fixation or plastination is that you avoid issues with temporary interruptions in cooling (as far as we know, Alcor and CI have a nearly perfect record in maintaining LN2 coldness, but one could wonder how well that will work for the next century) since a fixated brain will be stable at room temperature, and you can have a much more quantifiable idea how much progress has been made in fixation and scanning through things like the BPF's prizes (http://www.brainpreservation.org/ http://www.brainpreservation.org/). So that makes this attractive. The downside is that there is no infrastructure setup (there's no one you can go to and say "here's $10k, please wait by my bedside and as soon as I'm declared legally dead, dunk my head in osmium"), and the concerns about cryonics being too slow are magnified massively - people are worried about vitrification taking several hours and cryonics possibly being too late, but the current fixation solutions take more on the order of a month and don't necessarily fixate the entire brain volume. So you may get a great preservation which can be easily stored and imaged at high quality without any concerns about how to heat it back up... but what will you be imaging? If I died tomorrow, I would go with regular cryonics hands-down no contest. But in 30 years? If Mikula, Hayworth, the BPF, Seung, etc keep on pushing forward this area, maybe then plastination will be equal or superior.
- teddyh 11y agoThe viability (or not) (and the incentives of different parties in) the field of cryonics was previously discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8241374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8241374
- dang 11y agoAlso https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9593988 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9593988.
- pavlov 11y agoCryonics is fascinating because it's the closest thing to a technological religion so far. (Scientology does not count, it's more like a pulp sci-fi religion.) St. Paul eloquently described the upcoming Singularity and the raising of the vitrified minds: "Listen, I tell you a mystery: We will not all sleep, but we will all be changed -- in a flash, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trumpet. For the trumpet will sound, the dead will be raised imperishable, and we will be changed."
- ggreer 11y agoI often hear the "cryonics is a religion" claim, but a closer examination refutes this. Unlike religions, cryonics is not exclusive. A person can practice Christianity or Islam and be signed up for cryo. Cryonics makes no claims about morality or politics. There's no dogma about how to live one's life, or the origins of the cosmos, or what happens to consciousness after the brain is destroyed. The most important difference between cryonics and religions is that religious people are typically convinced of the afterlife. In contrast, cryonicists rarely assign high probability to being revived. Most think of it like an experimental cancer treatment: Unlikely to work, but better than the alternative. And like experimental treatments, research is ongoing. Since cryonics organizations were first founded, there have been many improvements to preservation protocols. Modern cryopreservation methods allow a rabbit kidney to function after thawing, albeit with some damage.[1] This is very promising, as parts of the kidney have poor vasculature. Brains are much easier to saturate with cryoprotectants. 1. http://www.21cmpublications.com/PubFiles/11/12FahyORG5-3[1].pdf http://www.21cmpublications.com/PubFiles/11/12FahyORG5-3[1]....
- kansface 11y agoI will eschew Wittgenstein's advice and take the bait- I don't think the techno-religion claim is too far off the mark. Of course, the entirety of our argument is over the definition of religion. | Unlike religions, cryonics is not exclusive. I think we'd both agree that exclusivity isn't the principle quality of religion, though many religions are exclusive. Religions typically have some core set of beliefs - some of which may be untestable, ceremony, dress, and often attempt to explain the mysteries of the universe. I'd also throw in the quality that religions advocate their followers either do something they wouldn't otherwise do or abstain from something they would otherwise enjoy. Its possible some religion lacks proscriptions for life, but I certainly haven't met it. Cyronics certainly has a core set of beliefs (faith!?) that lead to action. I very much doubt that even if we were to develop sufficient technology to unfreeze all those heads, future humans would do so. Perhaps we'd unfreeze some heads for science and then a few more for the novelty. We both agree cyronics is unlikely to work and that there is no way to run this experiment within our lifetime - cryonics requires faith (by any other name) in humanity and technology. |In contrast, cryonicists rarely assign high probability to being revived. Most think of it like an experimental cancer treatment: Unlikely to work, but better than the alternative. I know Christians that would describe their experience in similar terms. | The most important difference between cryonics and religions is that religious people are typically convinced of the afterlife. Christians believe in an afterlife, but not all religions do, or even weigh in on the matter - Judaism immediately comes to mind. Apropos, cryonics proposes its own cycle of rebirth! Well, possible rebirth until the great robot wars, the sun explodes, or the heat death of our local cluster. As for the other attributes I mentioned - dress, ceremony, and the like, cryonics offers bracelets, (non)ceremonial decapitation with ensuing vitrification, and requires its devotees to die somewhere convenient! OK, I agree, this doesn't exactly fit the bill. Precisely defining religion and faith is tricky. At the very least, I would say cyronics is uncomfortably close to a religion.
- jacquesm 11y agoFrogs can do this too (and more in fact), so I wouldn't be surprised if it was true. That said it's a bit of a (ok, not such a bit) stretch to extrapolate from being able to freeze a worm which has absolutely minimal nervous tissue to how this finding will apply to the non-science of cryonics, though I can see why those with a stake in the game would want to make such connections as strongly as possible. Not only are there differences in scale between frogs, worms and humans, there are also differences in complexity and structure.