3 ms·
Doucouliagos and Stanley published a great review in 2009 with the key figure being a scatterplot of study size vs elasticity (elasticity = change in # jobs / c
by jjoonathan 11y ago
Doucouliagos and Stanley published a great review in 2009 with the key figure being a scatterplot of study size vs elasticity (elasticity = change in # jobs / change in min wage) [1]. This looks like a funnel centered around the true value. The funnel is wide where N is small and narrow where N is large. Two conclusions from the figure:
1. The true elasticity is ~0 (maybe ever so slightly negative). Only small increases in minimum wage were studied, so this isn't an argument in favor of drastic raises, just an argument that small raises don't hurt under prevailing conditions.
2. The funnel should be symmetrical because random error does not favor higher vs lower elasticity. Instead, the funnel is bent, which is evidence of strong publication bias in favor of results of the form "increases in minimum wage decrease the number of jobs."
FWIW I don't think minimum wage increases are a great way out of this mess because I think reduced workweek and basic income / minimum income / EITC are all better options. Still, I think this figure is pretty convincing evidence that economists place too much faith in their neoclassical model.
[1] Page 33 of http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.398.2297&rep=rep1&type=pdf http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.398...
EDIT: added conclusion, fixed possibly misleading wording