3 ms·
And that is the problem in a nutshell. Price fixing a single thing (in this case rents) means the market moves without those prices changing and that results in
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
And that is the problem in a nutshell. Price fixing a single thing (in this case rents) means the market moves without those prices changing and that results in huge imbalances.
Now if the NJ government funded a fixed rate building maintenance team you're family could use the price appropriate maintenance team to keep the building in repair, of course they could not pay them market wages (that is why maintenance costs more) so the people working for the maintenance group would have to go to the state run stores where they could get their fixed priced foodstuffs. Of course the manufacturers selling to that store would need fixed price ingredients which you would get from state run farms selling their crops at a set price.
It is a silly ad nauseum sort of response but the kernel is accurate, you cannot successfully control one aspect of prices without somebody getting disadvantaged. Since you want more housing, the answer is to let people build more market rate housing, not to control rents.
- sliverstorm 12y agoSince you want more housing... Trouble is what people really want is for nothing at all to change. Prices stay flat, no new housing is built, nobody gets evicted, no new people come to town. Sadly, since they want to have their cake and to eat it too, nobody seems to be approaching it from the POV of: We are up against an inexorable force of change; how do we channel that change in a way that is most acceptable? Instead they demand the impossible and lose all control of where that inexorable force is going to take them.
- williamcotton 12y agoI know us programers have a proclivity towards binary thinking, but these people aren't arguing for a world without any change, just a way to decrease the volatility of a housing market that fluctuates beyond human scale. Humans are big, blundering slow moving beasts at the top of the food chain. It takes us years to settle in to new homes and communities and find our footings. Having rents double over just a few years is just too much for most people to handle. Call it "rent stabilization", not "rent control" and it makes more sense. The goal is to slow the rates of change and make sure things are happening at human scale. Real estate, contract law and marketplaces are all human constructions and we shouldn't let them get the best of us.
- fragsworth 12y agoRent control is also something corrupt local politicians can do to increase the value of their own properties in the neighboring districts outside of where the rent is controlled, because the prices in those districts will go up even higher than they would have otherwise.
- dllthomas 12y agoIn principle, you an end the regress at any point with subsidies. Ramifications are manifold, I've no idea if it's a good idea, and it's not what's being proposed, but it seems a potential way out of what you've described.
- dllthomas 12y agos/an/can/
- makeitsuckless 12y agoPrice fixing can be indexed. Happens all the time in many countries with many things, like housing and benefits. Like the thread about trailer parks and poverty elsewhere on HN right now, these are solved problems. If you don't like the solution because it offends your ideologies, fine, but stop pretending certain solutions can't or won't work. They can and they do.